• To improve security, we will soon start forcing password resets for any account that uses a weak password on the next login. If you have a weak password or a defunct email, please update it now to prevent future disruption.

Recommending Anal-Only Games: The ultimate list

Create sections for games value on quality or keep the list as a compendium?


  • Total voters
    44
  • Poll closed .

Anon2298

Member
Nov 24, 2023
139
203
The Developer Notes indicate that will not be the case.
The notes mention vaginal sex but not that it will be obligatory, so far all the sex scenes in the game are avoidable and anal-only is possible. But as I mention before, if this changes I will move the game to the limited section, so far has enough content to be in the main list.

That being said, I would like to ask the dev about what are the plans for the game and if anal-only will be available from beginning to end to settle this now, but I don't want to interact with devs in their threads anymore (At least those who aren't commenting in this thread). If someone doesn't mind asking, please tell me so I can define where the game will remain in the list.
 
Oct 26, 2017
493
504
CrossinG KnighTMarE: A Hymn to the Defiled Holy Maidens (Added to the list) ended being a pleasant surprise, is a game like any other Japanese RPG but when the MC loses, the player can choose which part of her body will be used, no save scumming required (sometimes). I did one run and miss a ton of content because apparently has a ton of secret stuff, a guide is needed, but so far, it has genuinely anal-only content from beginning to end through losing scenarios and training.

Now if the side content is also anal-only, I'm going to find out.

Okay, so, I will add it to the main list because is indeed anal-only from beginning to end so far, if there is an update that ruins the anal-only run, I will move it to the limited section because at least will contain anal-only until certain point.
Is Crossing Knight, rape sex scenes or you can choose consensual with whatever position as you mentioned? l do prefer consensual more.
 
Nov 23, 2023
182
167
That being said, I would like to ask the dev about what are the plans for the game and if anal-only will be available from beginning to end to settle this now, but I don't want to interact with devs in their threads anymore (At least those who aren't commenting in this thread). If someone doesn't mind asking, please tell me so I can define where the game will remain in the list.
Not sure if the dev will care enough what non-patrons think though. With that in mind, I have subbed to Rebel Duet developer and am nagging them to add anal option to every story scene lol.
 

Anon2298

Member
Nov 24, 2023
139
203
Is Crossing Knight, rape sex scenes or you can choose consensual with whatever position as you mentioned? l do prefer consensual more.
Is like 50/50.

The Knight gets raped on her scenes, I was unable to find alternative scenes so I don't know if all the scenes is just rape, but in said scenes you can choose anal-only, I found just one that had just vaginal but it was avoidable.

The Princess gets pressure into being trained, her training scenes happen once at the end of each chapter and are more consensual, she also has her own stats and training progress, because there are only four chapters, this training is far in between.

Both characters have alternative scenes and extra content but I was unable to unlock them and I don't know if all the scenes have anal-only but overall, following the main story and main content the game is kinda short but it is anal-only, half training and half rape.

Not sure if the dev will care enough what non-patrons think though. With that in mind, I have subbed to Rebel Duet developer and am nagging them to add anal option to every story scene lol.
Thank you for your contribution, that is a game that would definitely would benefit from anal scenes in the main story, after all the training scenes allow anal-only.
 

Anon2298

Member
Nov 24, 2023
139
203
Niramare Quest added to the limited section. The game has three main girls and you can freely have sex with them but two of them have obligatory vaginal sex, the nun who is also hinted being a virgin has not obligatory vaginal sex scenes and she also has an anal fetish, the main character can have sex with all the NPCs and some of them, specially nuns, has the option to do only anal.

This games has everything to be anal-only, is just missing some options like being able to avoid vaginal and make more clear the virginity state, nonetheless, is what it is and is a shame, in the limited section will remain and I hope the devs considered more anal only in future games.
 

Achelexus

Member
Aug 22, 2017
359
211
Niramare Quest added to the limited section. The game has three main girls and you can freely have sex with them but two of them have obligatory vaginal sex, the nun who is also hinted being a virgin has not obligatory vaginal sex scenes and she also has an anal fetish, the main character can have sex with all the NPCs and some of them, specially nuns, has the option to do only anal.

This games has everything to be anal-only, is just missing some options like being able to avoid vaginal and make more clear the virginity state, nonetheless, is what it is and is a shame, in the limited section will remain and I hope the devs considered more anal only in future games.
Interesting, however it seems that most scenes are just the kind where the actual penetration is hidden from view, so choosing whether it's vaginal or anal only changes the dialogue a bit.
 

bigguy_foryou

Well-Known Member
Jun 8, 2018
1,026
875
Almost universally all the japanese rpg games are trash, incredibly low content to time/effort ratio, and the content usually isn't that good anyway. I just ignore them, it's a shame so many of the recommendations here fall under that category though.
 
Nov 23, 2023
182
167
Interesting, however it seems that most scenes are just the kind where the actual penetration is hidden from view, so choosing whether it's vaginal or anal only changes the dialogue a bit.
Oh dear... Schrödinger's Anal strikes again.

Almost universally all the japanese rpg games are trash, incredibly low content to time/effort ratio, and the content usually isn't that good anyway. I just ignore them, it's a shame so many of the recommendations here fall under that category though.
Yeah, I don't really play them either. I tried a few and gave up quickly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: randomname2243

ViviX12

Engaged Member
Jan 5, 2019
2,380
3,229
Almost universally all the japanese rpg games are trash, incredibly low content to time/effort ratio, and the content usually isn't that good anyway. I just ignore them, it's a shame so many of the recommendations here fall under that category though.
Can be said about most games in general tbh, especially when you count in "games" like VNs, and totally-not-vn-because-theres-minigames Ren'py stuff
 
Oct 26, 2017
493
504
l would say it's next to impossible to find a relatable Protagonist or supporting cast especially in modern times. And if we are talking about female protagonists, oh boy. Actually, it is impossible to find a stoic or serious or the "monotone voice"; not just the voice but personality accompanied,( only Deus Ex 1) perfected that(alongside the personality).
 

Gothgirlgames

Active Member
Game Developer
Jan 26, 2024
521
711
l would say it's next to impossible to find a relatable Protagonist or supporting cast especially in modern times. And if we are talking about female protagonists, oh boy. Actually, it is impossible to find a stoic or serious or the "monotone voice"; not just the voice but personality accompanied,( only Deus Ex 1) perfected that(alongside the personality).
Ah, My husband helped me to created the Male mc from my game, i think, at least by his view, he is relateable for most of the guy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: randomname2243

bigguy_foryou

Well-Known Member
Jun 8, 2018
1,026
875
I don't know I much prefer Western Ren'Py games, regardless of how much "gameplay" they have.
This. If the game has good gameplay AND good content more power to it, but these days I'm far more interested in seeing either good renders, or good writing, japanese games typically have neither.
There are several (western) RPGM games I've really enjoyed over the years, however I do typically see them as more of a chore now. They have to be very good for me to commit the many, many hours required to play them. Ren'Py just delivers, and if it's failing to because it's poorly written or not interesting, there's a fast-forward button.
 
Oct 26, 2017
493
504
Ah, My husband helped me to created the Male mc from my game, i think, at least by his view, he is relateable for most of the guy.
l am sorry, didn't pay attention to the game, just wanted to see what it contains. Once it has a majority of content or it is finished, then maybe l will experience it. Many games have lost interest in me. Years ago, l would have wasted time, now, l am just looking for quality. l do find it, but very rarely and only in old years.
 

Studio 781

Member
Game Developer
Aug 3, 2020
337
1,656
l would say it's next to impossible to find a relatable Protagonist or supporting cast especially in modern times. And if we are talking about female protagonists, oh boy. Actually, it is impossible to find a stoic or serious or the "monotone voice"; not just the voice but personality accompanied,( only Deus Ex 1) perfected that(alongside the personality).
I agree, is really hard to pull that out, the only way in which can be done is with a ton of dynamic dialogues, dialogue options, different speaking patterns and appearance customization. Is not that is impossible but that it would be an incredible amount of work to pull out, I can't point my finger right now but I remember some old RPGs which rely a lot in text pulling something similar to that.

I'm conscious about this, for my current project I just created a story multiple options and a main character with a ton of dynamic dialogues but without appearance customization and a define personality. I know my limits, I know how much people ask for the sake of roleplay but I can't pull it out, at least I try to put some extra effort on dynamic dialogues.

My second project will be kinda similar but with more dialogue options, however, for my third project I'm planning something... big in relation a roleplay, which will be present in my fourth project (an AA game).

But yeah, is really hard and laborious to do.
 
Nov 23, 2023
182
167
l would say it's next to impossible to find a relatable Protagonist or supporting cast especially in modern times. And if we are talking about female protagonists, oh boy. Actually, it is impossible to find a stoic or serious or the "monotone voice"; not just the voice but personality accompanied,( only Deus Ex 1) perfected that(alongside the personality).
I don't know, I often find it quite easy to relate to many characters, male or female. Other times, relating does not feel necessary, it depends on the game.

I think I specifically dislike Japanese NSFW games, because a good chunk of them are pixelated and / or have those childish anime faces, even if they otherwise have large breasts and whatnot. Not all of them look that way, of course, but a good chunk do. I tried a few games, but I have never finished a single one. I think they are better off sticking to SFW games lol. They're great at making those, nor are there any laws sabotaging them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bigguy_foryou

Anon2298

Member
Nov 24, 2023
139
203
In my opinion, Japanese games are the best of the best and the worst of the worst. Karryn's Prison, Violated Heroine, Artificial Academy, Custom Order Maid, Artificial Girl 3, Teaching a Feeling and many more, there are a lot of games that are great and come from Japan, but they also trow to the market a ton of trash, RPGs that are extremely lineal, Visual Novels that could perfectly be a manga or a pack of CG images, everything seems like a mess in quality.

I feel like the reason is the Japanese eroge market being outdated and crowded, a Visual Novel with just few choices is no longer enough neither an RPG that is just collecting CGs, western porn games are more experimental, yes, there is also a ton of trash games but most are average or just good enough, which is more that can be said about Japanese eroges in the current era.

By the way, I will implement a way to rate all the games on the list and sort them out, lets see if next time I'm able to add it.