UPD: I gave it some thought and am now adding the 3rd star. The game shouldn't lose that many stars for belonging to a specific subgenre.
_____________________________________________________________________________
A very disbalanced game. The dev put so much effort into the girls and 'collecting' them, yet at no point of development was the plot taken seriously. It could potentially lead to a good comedy game, but instead the events took a really bizarre turn.
Pros:
1) A ton on LIs, with each having a dossier that helps the player to get to know them. Just two chapters in, and I already have a clear impression and intent for 17/18 LIs (except Paris). These are some crazy numbers.
2) A leveling system for the MC may seem unnecessary at first, but it actually deals with the problem of either too overpowered or too weak MC: the player himself can decide what things the MC is gonna be OP in, and what things he's gonna do poorly.
3) A lot of sex.
4) Humour.
5) Writing is good (in dialogues).
6) The card game can be amusing at times.
Cons:
1) The plot barely exists. We don't know much about the MC (that's kinda the price of the skill system: he may be athletic, smart, or dominating, indicating very different backgrounds) except that he got into the uni on invitation, has parents, and helped Violet… Still, that info, however short, is the whole plot of the game!
2) While the dialogues are good, storytelling is very bad. The first chapter is atrocious. An almost-naked guy turns up at a feminist event… Where only 3 people (Taylor, Jordan, and Chloe) actually behave like feminists… The rest just immediately accept a half-naked guy crashing their party and are very welcoming to him. 3 cheerleaders (read: some of the most popular girls in the uni) just give him blowjobs out of the blue, one of them rigorously fucks him in a hot tub, jumping on his dick as if willing to break an Olympic record, but attracts 0 attention from the other girls present in the same hot tub! I've seen worse 1st chapters, but this one makes the least sense by far…
That same plot could be told far more realistically if only one cheerleader was interested in him, and the girls were in general much more wary of him, with Violet's (who actually has good grounds for vouching for him) arrival being what warms them up to him, not Taylor being 'officially polite'.
Thankfully, Chapter 2 tells us of somewhat more sane things, so here's hoping that this aspect improves further down the line.
3) The whole game has too much of a "just collect and fuck them all" vibe, something I'm not a fan of, especially with all the dossiers giving info on how to get into the panties of this or that girl the best. Generally, I prefer it when both the girls and the MC have more agency than just being sex machines, even in porn games.
After just Ch. 1, I wanted to give this game 1 star, but Ch. 2 led to me slightly reevaluating; I decided on 2 stars for now.
The game is very good and worth playing right now if you can just disable your brain going in, letting your cock and your spinal cord do all the thinking. But if you, like me, need something for that pesky post-nut clarity, it's better to wait for more updates.