RPGM - A Struggle with Sin [v0.5.9.6] [Chyos]

A Struggle with Sin is a deep and unique open-world RPG that successfully blends adult themes with an engaging and immersive storyline. The world-building is impressive, offering a richly detailed medieval fantasy setting where every character and event feels distinct and meaningful. With its branching choices and multiple endings, the game delivers a high level of replayability and truly embodies the essence of player freedom.

The quest system and character interactions are particularly engaging, with emotional depth and behavioral development that pull players into the narrative. However, one major drawback is the quality of the 3D character models. Many of them feel rough and, frankly, unattractive, which detracts from the overall visual experience. If the developers were to improve the character modeling in future updates, it would significantly enhance the game's immersion and appeal.

Despite its visual shortcomings, A Struggle with Sin shines through with its compelling story and diverse gameplay. If you can look past the outdated character models, this game is a worthwhile experience, especially for players who enjoy complex narratives and the freedom to explore.

It's tied with one other game as my favorite adult title (s). As far as open world harem based games it is second to none.

Choices have consequences but you are never tricked into an outcome you didn't want. To me a lot of adult titles set up booby traps for the player, I really appreciate that this game never does that.

THIS IS THE BEST RPG I'VE EVER PLAYED! A Struggle with Sin is the most fun I've had playing an RPG game. There are so many animations for each characters in different scenarios. This game made me feel like every choice or action I took would change a certain outcome of something, I love it!
Note: I would like it if each female character had aa scene with an orc. Maybe an invasion early on or maybe a way the protagonist can take them to the woods and lose a fight to trigger an event.

This might simply be the best RPGM game I've ever played.

Amazing characters, engaging story, different routes, custom assets, bunch of fetishes, monsters, sandbox with a lot of things to do, what more can one need

The only possible downside for some might be it's grindiness at some moments, like gathering resources, but it's not really that bad (except for clay, gathering clay for building the house is the absolute fucking worst)

Love this game. So many choices, NTR is well done. You even can have kids. Combat is little dull, but still fun. Graphics are little outdated at least in the ones from begging of game, but dev is working on that. Story and map are also good. Dev is pushing updates regularly and fixing bugs as fast as he can. Love the unique and different design of characters. Hope that Rick gets his own love aside from Kate and plays more important role in MC story.

I would strongly recommend the game to anyone who likes sandbox games and prefers their games to have more gameplay. But if you are here for the NTR tag, it's probably better to skip this one.

Gameplay: It is DnD inspired with rolls which make actions easier, so raising most stats is important, The combat, despite being turn based, is actually pretty good, enemies have abilities, you can break their guard for a stun, you can do some small combos with abilities, like with the bow, Mark Target to add bow vulnerability, Quick Shot for a bonus attack, then just a normal attack. My main problem is that I personally could not equip different weapons despite playing for about 20 hours, but I might have missed something or done the wrong quests. There is some tediousness to it with scenes often being very far between gameplay segments tho.

Story: Pretty good, the world is somewhat fleshed out, there are a lot of characters and you can fuck most of them, some characters have quite intricate stories, others feel more like they exist for some extra scenes, but overall it should keep most people entertained. My main complaint with this is that some stories are just too convoluted without hints that you might be going the wrong path, or you are skipping story bits by going trough the characters story too quickly

CG: This game follows the motto quantity is a quality of it's own a bit too strictly. Most CG, especially older ones look pretty bad, a lot of it is probably due to the rendering engine. But Most scenes are Animated, and if a girl exists in the game, you can Fuck her. Sadly, it can be quite confusing to get certain scenes, you might even miss some because of some hidden requirement, or because you had to trigger a characters scene 3 times in a row, despite it being the exactly same scene for the 4th time to be different, so you instead tought you were done with the story segment and proceeded to the next missing a scene.

NTR: For those afraid of NTR, you can disable it, or if enabled it is quite easy to avoid most of the time, sometimes tho you might accidentally go the NTR route with some character with which it is somewhat more confusing. If you are here for the NTR tag, not all characters have proper NTR routes, most have like a scene or two where they ger raped by an orc or gobling, there is some sharing but only a bit, and some NTR routes are extremely tedious and require days of doing nothing for the quest to fail and the NTR route to be triggered.

Overall, one of the better games on this site which you can play fore a long time due to the increddible amount of content this game has.

This is one of my favorite games on this site. Feels like a real RPG game. Even when i don't feel like playing game with sexual content, this game is still in my head. It has that old school RPG feel to it and i love it.

It has very good music and sounds.

I have not experienced a lot of bugs

The dev is extremely active, even posting and replying when he's paused Patreon for a month to take a break.

Only drawback of this game is it's graphics and animations. But at the same time it has a unique style.

One of my favourite games on this site. Has a decent mix of fetishes (nothing particularly outre (for my taste anyway)).

NTR tends to be the most controversial, and this game has shades of sharing, cuckolding and stealing other men's wives/partners, but most of the content that people might object to is avoidable.

The dev is extremely active, even posting and replying when he's paused Patreon for a month to take a break, for example.

The graphics and animations will not be for everyone obviously, but it's a solid game and is in active development and thoroughly enjoyable at the moment.

Great RPG, and great sex scenes. The developer has clearly put a lot of work into this game, and it's really paid off. You'll probably want to use the walk-through though, since there can be specific triggers to continue the story lines that aren't readily apparent.

One of my all time favorites. Been playing this since release 0.4.?. Don't know the exact number anymore but it has been years since now.
The game is fun and rather addictive. New features came over time and it is great so see how the overall world and gameplay improve more and more. You can see that the developer put some real thoughts into this and fleshes out already implemented concepts.
The characters are all realy likable. The MC goes from a total jerk to a responsible, capable and maybe manipulating young male - depends on how you play it.
This is another plus for me: The game is not linear at all, you can make your choices, corrupt the girls around you or do the love route with them - or both if you wish. NTR is relativley easy to avoid or (if you are into it) everywhere to find.

Love this game and i am exited how it goes on!

One of the best RPG Maker Games out there.
Nice Story about the (up today) lazy son of a hunter and the Change of his Life.

Many Women of all kind

Lots of Content no matter wether corrupted or not...

PLAY! THIS! GAME!

Walkthrough Boogaloo

It's an RPGM, sandbox type game with alot of content.

I recommend if you like Stardew valley and want a lewd game with alot of minigames, a time cycle, and running around that you do in a sandbox. I recommend avoiding if you hate sandboxes.

The structure essentially has storylines and quests, with the quests mainly mapped to certain characters and progressing their route and unlocking sex scenes with them.

There's a battle system, minigames involving farming, forging armor later on, etc. A quintessential sandbox.

PRO: The game allows players to make meaningful and impactful story decisions and the outcomes range from pregnancies, to getting NTR'd or not, quests failing or succeeding, etc.

PRO: There are also multiple questlines and side stories and alot of these are character based and also interlink with each other and can impact each other.

CON: However, there are some problems. The way to progress the quest and knowing which ones impact another can be quite difficult. There's almost way too many female characters and quests, with alot of storylines not yet fully complete. The game could take another 3 years of development and it's a big risk because each update could break the game saves you have.

CON: In fact, the only way to play this game and not get frustrated and get what you want as the outcome is using the walkthrough from the developer. Otherwise, you could get stuck, lose progress or worse, accidentally fail or get the ending you didn't want for each of these quests.

PRO/CON: Lots of sex scene content. There are alot of female characters, and they have mothers. So if you make the right choices, you're likely able to fuck the whole family basically. However, the renders are really rough looking and look dated and so are the sex scene animations.

CON: Renders are real bad

fayummmmmmmmmmmmm this game is yummy af, i fap it 400 times daily and come back and fap 700 more times, well to be exact the game is very grindy and rewarding, more like roundscape androvida but with realistic graphics. strategic.

It's the best game on the site, in my opinion. Why? There is so much content, and the sandbox mode really gives the feeling of freedom, like being in another world where you can choose what to do and which girl to go after.

Well if you like ntr this is one of the best games out there its rich with content and good characters there is always something new the dev is always adding new things it doesnt have the most rpgmaker game problems

great game many scenes alot of posibilitis and livly chars rent routes a good story the developer is regulary uddating and informing and making poll ervery month in good pace this is my personal opinion it is my number one favorite h game in this stile and i hope it goes for a long time it has alot potecial to grow in ervery way

This is my first time writing a review on this beloved forum, and I’d like to share my thoughts on this game.

First off, for RPGM I find it quite solid in terms of story, characters, and mechanics. The storyline is engaging, and I think the events that unfold in the village with its various characters should be resolved before moving on to the story involving the next village (please cmiiw, as I haven't played the latest version or finished the game yet). Overall, I’d rate the story at 4 stars.

Now, about the characters: the models and animations? Yeah, they could use some polishing. I’m not entirely sure how to describe it, but something feels a little off, like they could use a bit more detail or smoothness. But hey, I’m still enjoying it, so no complaints there—4 stars.

Next up, the mechanics. There are definitely some things that could be tweaked. For example, when you’re rocking the bandit disguise to sneak into the mayor’s house, it’d be awesome if it didn’t automatically come off when you’re leaving through the basement. I mean, I was kinda curious about what would happen if I just strolled around the village in that disguise, you know? But still, mechanics get a solid 4 stars.

Lastly, props to the dev! I’m not giving it a full 5 stars yet, but that’s only because I see so much potential for improvement. I’m really hyped to see where the game goes next. You’ve done a great job so far, so keep up the good work—Godspeed!

Yo, ok so i played this game for a year now. It is really good, despite few (beginning of the game animations n all ) , but still good.
Story- Well i don't wanna spoil much, but you're a guy, who lives in a village with beautiful looking women around you, and its all medieval times. You can build a massive harem or select few, or even let them be taken by other men.
Game-play- Its not bad, but not good either. Its you're RPG engine basics. Wish there was Battle-sex moves for enemies and player+npcs.
Like a bandit grabs one of your party members and you get a stplitscreen animation loop, were it progresses bases on how long it take for you to respond to save them. Goes well with corruption system.
Also MC seems to be classless, wich is a bit boring IMO, but you can do everything ( cast spells, use bows, or go for close combat attacks )
This game needs more outfits for female characters. When KATE gets her new waitress uniform, that is a banger ( hands down ) This could also open quest-branches were villages most talanted tailors combine their forces to make new daily clothes for everyone, and ofc you could CORRUPT THEIR DESIGN-MAKING PROCESS ( This could be animation/PIC heavy upgrade tho )
Love or NTR - my personal approach is simple. I choose to make massive harem, once all females are mine, and pimp them out to others if game allows me to. So for example ( Tia has sex in Rumah,Kate has sex with Thomas,Tavern friends and your best buddy ) Tho i wish there was more group animations for NTR path. Like more extreme gang bangs or something of those sorts. This would make for interesting game-play choice, since if you lose quest or task, you're female character gets taken by others.
Like on same note: Orc village would be massive arc in its self here. Like when you send one of your wanitas to orc's. For each day she spends their, her sex partners increase in participation. So on last day at the camp, there is a massive orgy / gang bang. That would make sense in here dialogue, when she returns to Rumah and say - Ive been ficked by Orc all day n etc, but then again whe you go there, all you see is just one orc doing the pounding (Also, animation heavy upgrade )
AUDIO/ART/ANIMS- Just gonna say it simple, they are good. For modern-day sandarts, meby not so much, but still good. Tho some older animations need rework ( You can see a difrence in style and effects were Developer has changed some old ones to new ones )
Its still is good. Not much to say here, but some girls could use more flesh and vice versa. Fuck it, make it some kinds witchcraft quest or special potion, like the one were that princess gets in Daves mansions ( Her body grows larger, and i mean her butt and boobs get bigger )
This could be nice addition to MC arsenal, but yeah with so many girls you can interact, that would be shitloads of animation variations for difrent body types. But hey im just giving feedback

Overall - Needs more crazy stuff too, not just LOVE-path with happy endings we all know about. That gangbang thing i mentioned, could be more engaging at your merc camp for example. Were the red-head woman trains all your mercinaries PROPERLY
The game feels alive, you can see seasons and time.
Now what about kinks and all that juicy stuff ? Well i might say that it has everything normal, you would expect, and things you would only dream about. But since its medieval times + some fatnasy elements, it makes sense. Just needs more SPICY FLARES once in a while.
I do not wanna spoil much, i do recomend this game. And with that i give it solid 4 STARS ( -1 = ROOM FOR IMPROVEMENTS )
Im 100% sure when its all done, and will have those flares, polished lose ends, IT WILL BE A PERFECT 5 STAR GAME IN THIS GENRE !
HAPPY DAYS o/

Among the best RPG's around here. Hunting system is something new and pretty cool. The focus of the game is not in combat or grinding to get strong, but the story and getting laid.
It scary me a bit the game change the seasons with the real life change of seasson. A cool and scary system.
The characters don't have the best model quality, but the animations are very fluid and optmized. I don't understand why the story have the options for go NTR, because at some point one route, with NTR or without it, will become the main plot, the real story, the true route, and the other will see more like a fanfic inside the game. Until now, the story is good.
The tribe management is something cool, and the mini games are ok.
A five star, nothing more, nothing less.

I'm to stingy to support the dev on patreon, so the least I can do is to give an exellent review to this very fine game. I'm almost 40 hours in of non-stop content with almost no grind and I'm still far from having finished it.