To preface this, I played this after seeing it very highly recommended almost everywhere, so I had very high expectations. Sadly, for me, they weren't met.
It's a decent VN and I can totally see why it's very popular, the art is good (although something about the eyes of one or two of the characters was a little off-putting) and the story was nowhere near as formulaic as many in this genre. The characters themselves were mostly well done (Liam is likeable and his dialogue did make me chuckle a few times) and the main girls didn't seem completely one dimensional (though I feel they could've been fleshed out better).
I think for me, part of the issue was the length of the story, the last couple of chapters seemed very brief, almost rushed in fact. However, I think the biggest issue I had was that as I've played some incredibly well written games in this genre (and yes, for me and some others, the descriptive writing makes or breaks a game), the actual writing was pretty average. Scenes, especially the H ones, weren't especially well described and considering the very basic animations (I honestly would have much preferred still images, as the models themselves were attractive and for me, some of those animations were a detriment to the scene).
All in all, especially considering how relatively short it is, it's worth a play but in my honest opinion, I sadly believe this to be an above average VN, that has been massively over-hyped and for me at least, that huge hype set extremely high expectations that just weren't met.
It's a decent VN and I can totally see why it's very popular, the art is good (although something about the eyes of one or two of the characters was a little off-putting) and the story was nowhere near as formulaic as many in this genre. The characters themselves were mostly well done (Liam is likeable and his dialogue did make me chuckle a few times) and the main girls didn't seem completely one dimensional (though I feel they could've been fleshed out better).
I think for me, part of the issue was the length of the story, the last couple of chapters seemed very brief, almost rushed in fact. However, I think the biggest issue I had was that as I've played some incredibly well written games in this genre (and yes, for me and some others, the descriptive writing makes or breaks a game), the actual writing was pretty average. Scenes, especially the H ones, weren't especially well described and considering the very basic animations (I honestly would have much preferred still images, as the models themselves were attractive and for me, some of those animations were a detriment to the scene).
All in all, especially considering how relatively short it is, it's worth a play but in my honest opinion, I sadly believe this to be an above average VN, that has been massively over-hyped and for me at least, that huge hype set extremely high expectations that just weren't met.