VN - Ren'Py - All My Girls [v0.22] [MDYetiLab]

  1. 2.00 star(s)

    Jnx

    English:............5/10
    User Interface:.....3/10
    User Experience:....7/10
    Art:................5/10
    Dialogue:...........2/10
    Story:..............3/10
    Opinion:............1/10................
    Avg:.............3.71/10 [1.85/5]


    I've tried this one a few times. While I have played worse, this is not very good. It's your bog standard "MC walks room to room and females throw their vaginas at him." The English is not good, the UI is default aside from the main menu, and the models are odd looking. So all three pillars of what makes a visual novel are poor quality. There wasn't even enough to make a lasting impression for me to do my typical rambling intro paragraph. All I can hope for is that it sounds better in French. But even then, the rate at which this spirals can't be a pleasant experience. If nothing else, I'm happy that a game is being rated what it deserves to be rated.

    This cold opens to MC moving into a new apartment. Sophie, a new neighbor, see him and thinks he's attractive, so she helps him unload. Then, SOMEHOW, he has no water in his apartment so she lets MC shower in her house. This game OPENS with a shower scene where a LI catches his penis in the shower. This scene is so overdone I shouldn't have to tell anyone why it feels lazy. And Sophie's daughter, that catches him, screams and nobody cares. Then he goes back home to suddenly have no power after they just showed his home having power. Is it too much to ask a writer to read what they wrote merely 10 lines before? It'd be funny if it wasn't sad. The models all have exaggerated faces too it's very uncanny. I can usually get behind a stylized look, but this looks more like a SFM movie with expressions that make it look wonky. At the table they ask about MC and vise versa, I guess they say the daughter has a lot of sex? Or masturbates a lot? I don't know it's poorly translated. Either way I don't know any mothers that would say any of that about their daughters. And the next day MC goes to work and... His boss lets her pussy flop out at him? Wow, so appealing. Later? Sophie gives him a drunk blowjob and is found out by Laura. I'm gonna call it now, MC was Sophie's ex and she's already re-in love with him. After that he goes to lunch with the girls from work and they all give brief summaries of their lives because these are not characters. These are DAZ models in a subpar sex novel.

    Skipping ahead, Sophie finally talks to MC again. As a surprise to no one, MC was 100% right about why she was avoiding him. Because MC is right about everything. And super strong. And so handsome(even though he's really not). They have sex, and the next day she asks more about him. Because again, she literally only knows he said he has amnesia and works for an insurance company. He then says he liked photography in college. But he just graduated? The timeline of this really doesn't work. He JUST graduated, but hasn't been able to do photography because of college. But college was when he got interested in it? I'm sorry? Unless they mean before the coma. But he doesn't remember that? Hello? Is this real? Then he gets stuck in an elevator, porn trope #4905. They somehow get too hot and start stripping. And MC just leers at the woman like a degenerate. This guy's an asshole. And the fact she somehow has the only female underwear that turns transparent when wet? Have you never seen or felt a bra before? That's not how they work. Then at the end of the event, they're dressed and not sweaty and none of it mattered. And for him to say "I wonder what she looks like naked" when you could literally see everything means he's dumb. He has serious issues with self restraint. Any and every minor encounter with a woman gives him a need to start masturbating. And guess what? You, the player, who is 99% a male, gets to watch him masturbate? Why? We don't need, and I doubt want, to see this ugly manchild crank it. Then you find out she's Sophie's other daughter. To which he offers to talk to her after she runs off, embarrased? This man has amnesia, no sense of time, just got done jerking off to this girl, barely started dating Sophie, but suuuuure. Let HIM talk to her? Criminal parenting.

    Eventually time skips forward and Miranda, MC's boss, is killed. She's already been edited because the "peak alpha males" that play this couldn't handle her femdom content. Now she's killed off. And nobody cared. She had no character. She did nothing in the story. MC only used her to cheat on his new girlfriend right away. The only thing the murder scene does is introduce a runescape character. If you didn't catch him, when Zoe hugs MC, on the right side of the screen you just have some menacing runescape model leering at the camera and it makes me laugh so hard. There's also a cop whose hair is clipping through her hat. Then that cop comes to talk to MC BUT THE CLIPPING IS STILL HAPPENING? It'd be one thing if this was animated, but these are all stills, you can fudge things from the camera's perspective. Why does this look so bad? Front and center it's so bad. And June isn't crying until she's alone. There's so many small details that really shouldn't be an issue but are completely overlooked. This is absurd. June even says "I learned a lot from her" But earlier in the game she said that Miranda started AFTER her and wasn't even qualified for the job. Again, do we not read what we wrote before? I know it's not good, but you are writing this, you have to know your own story. And she even cheats on whoever she's married to? That was one of the only things she talked about, being in a relationship. This is just bonkers. It then leads into Suzi acting like an actual child. She's going to college but cries her mom, a single working mother, can't be there. Then she goes to sleep at MC's place when it thunderstorms that night? She has a sister. She's also a grown ass woman. MC is still a stranger. I could see a world where this was written better and I'd have less of an issue, but we're not there. We're stuck in this one where the writing is bleh.

    I actively checked out after that. Nothing redeeming happened. Suzi goes to college you meet her friend. She starts calling him daddy for some stupid reason. Another coworker suddenly thinks Miranda was amazing. That plot went nowhere. They go to a beach, MC beats up three bodybuilders no matter what you choose. Any time it cuts to the crappy phone, the images are all squashed or stretched because instead of cropping, they just scaled it weird. The only "problem" is if you decide to let MC sexually assault Suzi in her sleep. Again, I completely checked out and skimmed so I'm not 100% certain if it's revealed at another time, but in the bad end Sophie does reveal he was the father. So wow, never saw that coming... This is not worth your time. I'm sorry to the creator, but this is NOT good. Read a few real books, learn more about 3D modelling and posing and improve.

    The English levels out toward the end, but the start it's awful. It's never good, but it is more tolerable. The UI/UX is stock like I said. The Art is not technically the worst I've seen but it's pretty bad for DAZ. Clipping, ugly characters, over exaggerated emotions, bad posing, low poly characters the list goes on. The dialogue is two robots programmed to have sex later that day interacting for the first time. And the story is nothing. Guy moves into apartment has amnesia for no reason, starts dating a woman he most likely abused. The end. Writing isn't easy, but it's not this hard. I could excuse ALL the visual stuff if it was proofread well and the story wasn't total crap. If the English, story, and dialogue are all on point and the art was mid with no UI changes that'd still be a 4/5. But this has next to no redeeming qualities. It's not even short enough to breeze through, sadly. If the dev somehow reads this, just work on a story. I don't care if it's this one or a new one, but write something you'd want to read. It doesn't need to be the next great novel or even very original. Just write decent characters and a story that isn't porn slop. And if this IS something you want to read, well... Count me out.
  2. 3.00 star(s)

    vaelenor

    This game is rough, especially in the beginning. Overall the plot is nothing to amazing, models and animation are a bit basic, and the scripting is very basic.
    BUT
    As the story moves forward these things do improve. They get better grammar, action, even animation.
  3. 1.00 star(s)

    Fragmandk

    Could have been a great story and even has harem tag but killing one of the Li's is bad and will end bad for people that wanted to support the game.
    So just be warned before playing the dev is killing the Li's
    So no need for me to support the woman i liked the most is already dead in the game.
  4. 3.00 star(s)

    JackMiejov

    Updated review for All My Girls v0.21:

    On the upside, the English writing has drastically improved. I even restarted the game from the beginning to see if the earlier dialogue had been rewritten, but it's still not very good, so I don't think it was. Gameplay now seems to offer different choices that are worth checking out, so that's another improvement.

    On the downside, the story is still just cliché after cliché. Facial expressions are occasionally still weird, animations aren't smooth, the head-to-toe panning is low-resolution (why bother), and the quantity of content is decreasing for the time between updates.

    I bumped my rating up to a 3. That game is worth a look, now.

    Previous review for All My Girls v0.20:

    Summary: This game has a below-average story and it happens to be the best part. The whole thing seems like it was conceived by a teenager. Other reviews say the game has improved. If so, I'm glad I didn't play it before. It may eventually get better, but it'll never be good (or even average) without a complete re-write and remastering. For now, it's really not worth the time to download and play.

    Story: 2.5/5 - Pretty average in terms of the setup for the sexy fun, but way too many clichés and stereotypes. Some of the interactions between the MC and girls are cringeworthy.

    Writing: 2/5 - It's terrible "Engrish". Maybe the French option is better.

    Art/Renders: 2/5 - The render quality would've been average more than 5 years ago. Most of the female models are OK, but the male models are ugly. Facial expressions are frequently weird. Body poses are sometimes weird.

    Animations: 2/5 - Just unnatural looking and very noticibly lower resolution than the renders. Like the renders, they would've been average more than 5 years ago.

    Gameplay: 3/5 - Not much of a gaming experience and that's good. But most of the choices are whether or not to peek on various girls.

    Content: 2/5 - It's got the right amount of content for a year of development. It uses the typical lame dream sequence to get lewd content early in the game. The lewd content isn't very erotic because the animations are poor.
  5. 4.00 star(s)

    Hedylogos

    Grading this on an early game curve, as I always do.

    Just a note to other reviews. The dev listened to feedback and made some changes towards them, which bolds well for the future of the game. Devs that listen are the best.

    Overall I see a lot of potential in this game. It has a good assortment of LIs and fun girls. The story is a good base, but is a bit jumpy right now. May need a bit more fill and warm up before jumping into things.

    I would spend a little time on the story to work out the flow a little better.

    The graphics are good, not top notch, but good. Animations are also about the same.

    Look forward to future releases and will update rating as it goes.
  6. 2.00 star(s)

    Porthas

    Some feedback, if you're interested.

    View attachment 2138623

    You don't have to narrate what we can see. Let your images do the work for you.

    View attachment 2138624

    MC speaks for me as well. I don't care to see meaningless sex scenes in a dream. I'd prefer sex scenes that actually move the relationships in story directions. Dream sequences are pretty much okay for me only when they move the story forward in an interesting an entertaining way.

    Other notes where there can be improvement:

    Give the MC more agency about what's going on. The option to make the lady boss stop sexual harassment should be the MC standing up for themselves, ideally, instead of the way it's implemented now.

    I don't want to see the old male boss dude having sex with anybody. There is an option to skip looking at it, that's a plus. But later it's become blatant the old fart is using the workplace as his own bachelor pad. I'd tone that down and focus more on the MC, we're invested in them not the boss. But that's just my two cents.

    The angry daughter is a tired character. I wouldn't mind playing a game where there isn't some girl screeching "pervert, pervert, pervert, hentai!" in the MC's face.

    What do I like about this game? The MC seems to be a nice guy. Girls don't scare him. I like the first neighbor lady, she helps out and is pleasant. So, a couple characters have some redeemable qualities.

    The writing can definitely be improved. There are definitely inconsistencies with the coma story which can be fixed.

    The sex scene animations aren't the worst I've ever seen, but they certainly need improvement.

    I like the neighbor lady and MC's very basic friendly dynamic, that would be the only reason I'd return to see how this game progresses.
  7. 2.00 star(s)

    consumptionist

    lets not kid ourselves. this is pretty bad.
    i scoff at anyone who can rate this beyond 2 stars as not only does it do a massive disservice to the developer by over rating them, but it also sticks two fingers up at the few developers on here who have created some seriously good works. if fate/stay night and leap of faith are 5 star then this is not even close.
    learn some perspective

    some of the art is okay but some is just strange looking.. lots of room for improvement but as it is an apparent attempt at a VN then it has to do better.

    and then we come to the writing.....
    my impression is that the writer is either underaged for this site or barely past the age requirement. there is no sign of maturity in the writing or the plot at all. in fact it is really bad.
    ok it's an adult game and doesn't need to be poetry that leaks off the page in silken tones, but it does need to be something you read that doesn't feel like your IQ is leaking from your ears. it just has no scope of vocabulary.
    it just reads like the bare minimum to link scenes as opposed to telling any real story.

    i just cannot see any sign that the developer/s give much of a toss beyond some effort in visuals and throwing sex scenes at us to induce the weak minded into high ratings.
    it could be a lot better with some effort in writing alone.
  8. 3.00 star(s)

    UselessSphinx

    I had an accident 8 years ago, and spent 10 years in a coma. Am I the only one that can't wrap my head around this? Honest to god dialogue in the diner with your fellow employees.

    PROS
    Models are lovely
    Renders are decent enough
    Lighting is pretty good

    CONS
    Writing is a bit tough in spots
    Another amnesia story

    Summary
    So, it isn't awful, but it isn't on the level to be good or excellent. Maybe if the amnesia angle wasn't there and it was just the MC lost his job and decided to start over somewhere else, it would be better than a 3 star VN.
    I'm not sure if the line mentioned above is just me not understanding, but could you fix that?
    Brush up the writing and try not to run off the rails and this VN might turn out to be pretty good.
    Good luck to MyYetiLab with future updates and progress.
    These are just my thoughts and opinions. Don't let my rating deter you from at least trying this out for yourself
  9. 1.00 star(s)

    TheSmoothCriminal

    Don't be fooled by the tags listed here. This is not a harem game, unless the one with the harem is the MC's boss. You as the MC are nothing more then a voyeur watching others have sex instead of yourself.

    Be wary if you are looking for harem/romance because you will not find that here.
  10. 3.00 star(s)

    anon280

    Version: 0.11

    A simple story with a lot of girls in the form of neighbours and co-workers

    Writing & content
    • jumps right into the story, none of that backstory intro nonsense
    • the game comes closer to a porn game but the sexual encounters are at least justified and play out how you would expect
      • as such there isn't heavy dialogue but what is there is just enough to get to know the characters and situation
    • MC's amnesia seems like a copout to avoid further character backstory or is indeed a placeholder for further backstory - as of now it just seems weird in it's current form as there's nothing connected to it in the story
    • decent amount of lewd content for an early release
    • option given if you want your supervisor to sexually harass you
      • personally wouldn't have mind if she looked more attractive
    Graphics & animation
    • the renders are relatively fine but there's some random overexposure
      • overall lighting could improve to match time of day
    • refreshing face of a MC
    • models look nice
    • other graphical peeves:
      • MC's suit jacket is unnaturally puffy
      • the texture on Sophie's butt area looks too dry
      • when MC is walking the streets with Zoe, the placeholder models are a bit too noticeable

    • Animation starts off fluid and you get
      • actions played out, e.g. when Sophie puts MC's dick in her mouth
    • but the quality drops further in:
      • bad loops, e.g. Sophie cunnilingus
      • slow and mechanical animation, e.g. View 2 - Sophie's face during sex
    • and a cowgirl scene (from MC's dream), I would have liked to see animated, gets downgraded to crossfade looping, i.e. fake animation
    Sound
    • diegetic audio, i.e. natural ambience, sfx, moans etc
    • sex sounds sometimes don't match animation, e.g. View 1 - Sophie cowgirl
    You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

    Easy going VN with decent sexual content but animation needs to return to it's original charm
  11. 4.00 star(s)

    batturo

    i dont like the neighbor side i should say just delete completely but its little late for that. just focus on around the office and add some new hot assistents in the future etc and it ll be all good. you know we dont have many choices with this genre, you can take lessons from "the bastard" if u want they are similar games.

    tl;dr its short, but i like the start.
  12. 4.00 star(s)

    prowler60

    Very good start! There's not enough games like this with simple, "realistic" setting without extreme fetish and when there are they usually involves incest which is not my cup of tea... Looking forward to the next chapter !
  13. 4.00 star(s)

    giggles90210

    As of version 0.1 pros:
    diversity between girls models (appearance and character)
    not a wuss, mature mc ( always a good sign)
    actual story
    cons:
    the staff at the office are somewhat lacking and bland (personal thoughts)
    the mistress character more sl*tty than dominant and bit*hy