Dear YioruYioru
I have played your game for the past days and had great fun. Enought to take the time to write down my thoughts. I just beat the Minotaur boss in the tower if that is important.
1) I really like your art style and I think you should stick to your current designes. Although some may call it „crude“ or „not good“, I really like it. Id has a certain charm and you can see the passion you have for your game.
SUGGESTION: Please keep the current Ashley, as she sticks out of the too perfect, blant, boring (possibly AI made) Anime character designs many other games have. Dont streamline her too much, as you may risk loosing what makes her special.
2) I read in this Topic that the game is censored now to appease Patreon. You took out bestiality, Monsters that look too animal-like and loli images. Its a shame, because I found your game specifically looking at the bestiality tag. It is kinda wierd though, that having a Dog companion is considered offensive, but getting fucked by Spiders is not? Dont get me wrong, I love all kind of insect and grotesk monster fun, so the more you keep/add the better for my taste.
SUGGESTION: Stick to one design philosophy. By chosing a middle path you will lose both the vanilla and the bestiality fans. If you want to keep it more vanilla, like I think you do, commit to your choice fully. For example the Slime is still addressed as a dog and barks when speaking to it. Make it a real „Slime“ with Slime like behavior and dialogue.
Same with the „Centaur“ in Carrot Village. He says people avoid him because they think he is hideous and scary, but he looks like every other NPC in that town. If you want to stick to the more human approach make him ugly or change the dialogue at least.
3) I guess you also changed the worms, right? Well I think you didnt do a great job here, as their design and color look like „angry poop“. Ashley having three of them on her body looks like she has a scat fetish. I didnt like that island because of that reason.
SUGGESTION: Unfortunately you probably wont change it to anything more worm-like, so maybe change the color from brown to something else, at least. Id say a light green, pink or deep red would fit them better.
4) There is also some immersion breaking moments. I grinded Lewdness to make her an Exhibitionist, but there are many situations you are force to equip cloths. For example you cant go into the Werewolfforest, because Ashley says she cant proceed naked. Or you cant enter your own float naked sometimes.
SUGGESTION: Find and fix those spots you are forced to wear clothes and let Ashley do whatever.
5) There are also many NPCs refusing to speak or trade with Ashley if she is nude. Some NPCs like the redshirted former Dwarf (Alex?) tell her to „put some cloths on“, only to make her strip and do lewed things to him the next time you talk to him while waering clothes.
SUGGESTION: While I can unserstand some NPCs like merchants not wanting to speak to her naked (although I'd liked it if they would), you should make their behavior consistent. Instead of outright telling her to „wear cloths“ only to have sex with her the next moment, change the dialogue to be intimmidated by her huge breasts or her licentiousness but they are reluctantly convinced to deal with her if you speak to them again.
6) Gold at the beginning is very tight. She got her ass kicked by a slime trying to fight it bare handed. I let Ashley work at the Smith and Bar for several ingame days until she could buy the regular sword. However once you leave the first island and prostetude her every possible opportunity (like did), Gold is coming in plentyfully. Maybe even a bit too much.
SUGGESTION: Add some kind of gold sink to spend excessive coin on. Additional animations or Sex positions only purchasable with Gold. Some additional outfits (probably too much work), flavor items, or not-mandatory OP weapons. Maybe a Demonic Whip that lets her breasts jiggle while fighting and that adds an additional animation when (intentionally) loosing the battle... like she gets tangled in her own whip, being unable to move, thus loosing the battle. You know appeasing to the BDSM crowd. Just add something that is nice to see but not mandatory.
7) Somewhat in the same category are Loot Chests. They are boring because most chests contain either gold, potions or both. I havent found anything rare or exciting inside a chest so far.
SUGGESTION: Add something rare but meaningful to chests. Like weapons only obtainable as loot, or one of 4 super rare crafting items needed to craft the Demonic Whip, or some decorations for your ship or some other cool gimmick. Just something that actually encourages me to get out of my way to get it, if I have enough potions and gold.
8) I have read here that Ashley can lactate if she gets sucked 100 times or/and buys the potion from the witch. Well I let Goblins and Plants suck on her for hours and I bought the potion multiple times, but the milk effects are very minor at best. I have only noticed some white borders in some images.
SUGGESTION: Go all out with breast milk. Let her squirt that stuff in all dierections when getting sucked or while orgasm. Maybe add a potion to remove the lactating effect for those who do not like that stuff, but for me there needs to be much more.
9) Lastly lets talk about animations. I think they are great! But they repeat themselves too much. Especially the breast groping and blowjob scenes. I get that everyone wants to tocuh Ashleys Breasts but it gets boring the 40th time.
SUGGESTION: Add more animations, more variety. If thats too much work, let the dialogue scale with her lewdness. At first she should be against being touched and should slap the groper, like she does now, BUT with more and more lewdness, she should like and even encourage the man to grope her. Even at max lewdness she still slaps the gropers and tell them to stop, while she should be sad that he stopped and tell him to do it again. It would be cool if the text reflects her lewdness level, being a Slut and begging for more at high lewdness.
