Create and Fuck your AI Cum Slut –70% OFF
x

Zirael Q

Well-Known Member
Aug 28, 2017
1,630
9,653
717
It's crazy, because I remember when I first played episode 4, I was thinking the exact opposite to people hating on Maya and Josy. I thought MC was completely overreacting (though somewhat understandably at first), but what annoyed me in particular was the agency taken away from the player. You had to fuck around for the entire episode before you could actually resolve the conflict. I get storming out initially, but for the entire episode he avoids them, I'm just thinking "JUST FUCKING TALK TO THEM YOU IDIOT, COMMUNICATE", and it annoyed me the game wouldn't give me the option to approach/talk with them (like ignoring them in class and sitting with Camilla). Like I get they're meant to horny, emotional, stupid young adults, but I find it so annoying when games somewhat arbitrarily take decision making away from you.

For my two cents on this dead horse:

1. Yeah, Maya fucked up by not telling MC about Josy/having a gf, but in her defence, it did seem she was eventually going to tell you before Josy appeared, she is emotionally distraught by due to the rocky status of her relationship, the fact her dad hates her, and she's trying to reconcile her new bisexuality.

2. Josy didn't actually lie to MC, she though she was holding out on specific details. She at the very least told MC she was in a relationship, which was the important part.

Honestly there actions are completely understandable and forgivable. If MC just wants to remain friends, that makes sense too. What I don't understand is how people somehow think this so horrible that they should be instantly and completely cutting them out of MC's life.
Understandable and forgivable, yes of course. The problem is people claiming she did nothing wrong. Even when she admits she fucked up multiple times and asks for another chance. Every character in the game fucks up something. It all comes down to the fact that they fucked up and if you are willing to forgive them and accept their mistakes or not. Downright claiming they are innocent is... Hypocritical to cover it mildly.
 

lemonfreak

The Freakiest of Lemons
Oct 24, 2018
5,611
10,423
925
At 4344 pages I'm sure this isn't the first time this has come up up but what if that picture found in Jill's room is of her best friend from from childhood with her mother (the friend's, not Jill's)? Maybe a friend who was bullied in childhood and commited suicide because of it. It's long been assumed that Jill was the one who was bullied and that's why she's so protective of the MC (and has the campaign brochure in her room) but, to me, it makes more sense if the victim was someone she knew and was unable to protect.
 
Mar 18, 2019
245
150
97
The sooner we know about Bella's past and the MC's Mother's family name the better. Getting really tired of seeing the pointless "iNcEsT iS pOsSiBlE" debates cropping up all the time. :rolleyes:
True we literally have no idea what MC last name is, and we don’t event know if he has a last name but when Bella said Jill was a Royce, she got kinda scared for a bit. Like MC knew something about the Royce family. And when MC and Jill went on a date, she didn’t want him to know about her family
 
Dec 19, 2019
422
1,259
277
True we literally have no idea what MC last name is, and we don’t event know if he has a last name but when Bella said Jill was a Royce, she got kinda scared for a bit. Like MC knew something about the Royce family. And when MC and Jill went on a date, she didn’t want him to know about her family
Because Jill doesn't want the guy she's interested in to date her for money or power that the name Royce has. MC doesn't know that she's a Royce and that's why she reacted that way when Bella said she is a Royce.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maviarab

Holy Bacchus

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 13, 2018
7,748
19,555
789
True we literally have no idea what MC last name is, and we don’t event know if he has a last name but when Bella said Jill was a Royce, she got kinda scared for a bit. Like MC knew something about the Royce family. And when MC and Jill went on a date, she didn’t want him to know about her family
Good grief. :FacePalm:

Jill didn't want him to know want him because she was simply enjoying the fact that he didn't. All her life the pressure and prestige of her name has followed her and people have so often only gotten close to her because of her name and status, and not because of her. The MC didn't know who she was, let alone anything about the Royce family, and he treated her like a regular human being and not as an access point to high society and privilege, and she was likely worried that him knowing might change how he sees her and was probably hoping they'd get to know each other better before telling him.

None of this had anything to do with them being possibly related because A) how would she know, B) how would he know, and C) it's not going to happen. Period.
 
Mar 18, 2019
245
150
97
Good grief. :FacePalm:

Jill didn't want him to know want him because she was simply enjoying the fact that he didn't. All her life the pressure and prestige of her name has followed her and people have so often only gotten close to her because of her name and status, and not because of her. The MC didn't know who she was, let alone anything about the Royce family, and he treated her like a regular human being and not as an access point to high society and privilege, and she was likely worried that him knowing might change how he sees her and was probably hoping they'd get to know each other better before telling him.

None of this had anything to do with them being possibly related because A) how would she know, B) how would he know, and C) it's not going to happen. Period.
Holy shit I completely forgot, I feel so fucking stupid
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemonfreak
Feb 13, 2020
38
82
124
Yet no one blames her for that (quite rightly so)....still a lie of ommission though isn't it..much like some other female made, who continually gets slated for it....
A lie of omission, that's true, but not of the same importance.
Josy's was about her girlfriend being in B&R, which is relevant to their relationship.

Beside is Jill really lying ? :unsure:
I mean they are talking about her family, she herself brought the subject up, then she awkwardly change the conversation to another direction.
Unlike Josy who didn't bring up the info at all and stayed away from it.

The relationship is different too.
With Jill, it's their first date, to get to know each other, it's normal, expected even, that some things will be left unsaid because they don't know each other that much.

With Josy, they are kinda romantically/ sexually involved in a serious way. No THAT serious but there are lots of strings attached.

So you can't say " much like some other female made, who continually gets slated for it...." because the context is totally different.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mistrophera

Maviarab

Doing Mafia Helmet Things....
Donor
Jul 12, 2020
14,401
35,700
997
A lie of omission, that's true, but not of the same importance.
Josy's was about her girlfriend being in B&R, which is relevant to their relationship.

Beside is Jill really lying ? :unsure:
I mean they are talking about her family, she herself brought the subject up, then she awkwardly change the conversation to another direction.
Unlike Josy who didn't bring up the info at all and stayed away from it.

The relationship is different too.
With Jill, it's their first date, to get to know each other, it's normal, expected even, that some things will be left unsaid because they don't know each other that much.

With Josy, they are kinda romantically/ sexually involved in a serious way. No THAT serious but there are lots of strings attached.

So you can't say " much like some other female made, who continually gets slated for it...." because the context is totally different.
I could give the real reason why people defend Jill's lie of ommision and not Maya's....but I'd probably be kicked off the thread and upset a hell of a lot of people..

Let me just say...you're response didn't surprise me...in the least ;)
 

Phynix

Member
Apr 12, 2018
158
228
231
I could give the real reason why people defend Jill's lie of ommision and not Maya's....but I'd probably be kicked off the thread and upset a hell of a lot of people..

Let me just say...you're response didn't surprise me...in the least ;)
I don't see how not wanting your last name known can be compared to hiding your relationship from someone you're fooling around with.
 
Feb 13, 2020
38
82
124
I could give the real reason why people defend Jill's lie of ommision and not Maya's....but I'd probably be kicked off the thread and upset a hell of a lot of people..

Let me just say...you're response didn't surprise me...in the least ;)
Well I have a little idea why, but I accept pm, just to be sure ;)

I do understand and accept Josy's reasons though. I don't blame her in the least, I just didn't like that she did it.

The same for Maya, though I DO blame her, she got chance after chance. I'm not pissed at her as much as I am usually for things like that because she was about to tell everything to MC before Josy knocked on the door.

And I do agree MC over reacted. Especially towards Josy. Personally in his situation, I would have left too, but not as dramatically as he did.


And just to make it clear, I'm not a dying hardcore fan of Jill. (Cause Sage is the way)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Phynix
4.70 star(s) 1,730 Votes