I feel bad giving this 3 because overall it's of much higher quality than a lot of other Renpy games, but everything good in this is severely marred by an incredibly incompetent storytelling and a wet fart ending that leaves a rushed aftertaste.
So what this game is, first of all. You start in a slice of life situation with a girlfriend and group of friends who play some DnD sessions and you kinda alternate between the slice of life and those DnD sessions, and in the second half you travel into your DnD world and continue journey there until eventually coming back home.
And first chapters are geniunely fantastic, it's written really well, dialogues and relashionships are beliavable and pleasant to watch, our protagonist is a well rounded normal guy and besides glacial pace of the narrative which can scare away someone it starts really strong.
But around the time you transport into your DnD world, it almost feels like a completely different person takes over writing. Dialogues become worse, story become rushed and crumpled, previous characters and events are forgotten (like Shannon or what was the name of the mom? She literally appeared once and characters multiple time joke about MC also getting a go at her but she literally just dissapears forever). A lot of major plot points are completely unexplored and leave holes in the narrative, like the whole ghost village, MC and Hannah knowing each other from some other life or whatever, Oracle-witch and other issues. Considering prequel is in the works at the moment i can only assume that like any developer lost in sniffing their own farts, he wants it to be a big multi game universe and like all devs with bloated ego he forgot to make actually complete game before thinking about extended universe. It's not the first time and won't be the last.
This is more of a matter of a personal taste i suppose, but also it's important for harem lovers so i kinda have issues with how harem is presented in here. You start with Hannah and end with Hannah (short haired redhead), this is inevitable and if you don't like her tough luck. Any additions to the harem is with her approval, and happen only with her meaning never once you have meaningful one on one with other girls, everything happens with her presense. Also it's an awful case of "i love only Hannah and gracefully bestow a bit of sex upon others so they can get off too". It is implied several times that both Emi and Skyler develop stronger feelings for MC, especially in good first half, but it never goes anywhere, in the end it's just occasional bang buddies. Again narrative is split in half between really good first part and bad second part that forgot everything about the first. Another thing is, game is FILLED with female characters you can't do anything to, at least on the good route. Pirate captain, sirens, fairies, the orc, the dwarf, village girls, elves, just make them males if you don't plan on giving even an option to the MC.
Which leads me to the ending, so spoilers i suppose. You defeat big bad, kill-spare her, you come back home and marry Hannah. What happened to fantasy world? Who knows. What happened to sisters? Who knows. What happened to Calysto, what's up with the witch, are frog people alright, did mermaids find a new home, what's up with MC having magic in his world, the entire fantasy world is just forgotten and thrown out of the window. Even main characters don't have any closure, developed relashionships and results of their journey aren't even shown. It's the laziest barebones minimalistic barely ending possible and it sours the whole experience.
Character models and animations are nice, even if most animations are used for... weird stuff like running and walking, felt kinda pointless.
Overall could be an incredible game if only developer had a semi competent writer, but in this state it's just mediocre unfortunately.