Reviewers like these is the reason why we can't have good things... It's SUCH a cool game! Usually, i would criticize the plot harshly, but i don't feel like this was the goal here at all. It seems the dev wanted to make a great-looking NTR game, with an "actual anime" vibes, intentionally making the plot look like a normal anime with edginess. And i would say - he succeeded.
Some say the maps are big. Boy do i have big maps for you then, if that's what you consider big. They're very small, compact even, with enemies barely aggroing on you, and you speeding around. Teleport is also available right after the first boss, so you can always do that to make the game even shorter.
Animations are amazing, both hentai and battle, artstyle is amazing too. Dialogues were never cringy or dragging on too much. Exploration was simple and fun, i liked finding secrets. Grind is almost nonexistent, just beat everything on your way and you'll be more than alright, both in EXP and money. You even get a NG+ mode after clearing the game, if you want to try to play it differently. Hell, the game is optimized even, i didn't have any lag on my side, and my PC cannot even play Elden Ring.
The only big downside of this game is that it's short AF. Short locations, short subplots, very short set-ups for scenes. Barely developed system of affection and battlefuck. It truly does feel like a demo - and i hope it is. A demo for a much grander game, made in the same way this was, but with more content. Maybe dev just decided to try something completely new, instead of the usual realistic 3D bimbo models, visual novels or RPGM, so this is just one of the stepping stones for a future masterpiece.
I simply cannot give it any lower than 5 stars. This kind of effort should be encouraged, not judged short-sightedly. Of course there are flaws, but they're easily outweighed by the game's better qualities, and aren't critical. Though i would've preferred if the game didn't bug out if you try to craft wooden sword in market location, and having all music loop properly would've been nice too.
I'm not sure what the fuck do people giving it 2.5 expect, but whatever that is they're delusional. H-games cannot be of a much higher quality than this easily.