Recommending Butter's Ultimate(?) Wholesome Games/Doujins List! (a la VoltageFlame) || Also a Discussion and Recommendations Thread! (MAJOR UPD: 04/23/25!!)

[butter_scotch13]

Anyways.. I just started Akira points and well..

"second cousin.."

Debating on whether or not i should keep playing this..

 

[butter_scotch13]

From my memory, I believe Happy NEET was also second cousins.

I think these are going to be my guidelines on incest from now on:
1). Second Cousins are the MAXIMUM closeness in relationship that I'm going to be fine with
2). They have to have not been interacting with each other for a majority of their life (no actual familial bonds, basically- if you grew up together as a family or something then that's a hell no..)
3). Has to not be a major plot point, if the game is like, making a HUGE deal out of them being somewhat related, thats too far into making incest a kink.

With that being said, I'm probably going to finish Akira points as it (to my knowledge) just about fits all of the points i just made, and I don't want to drop an otherwise amazing game for something I can ignore/could've just not seen (like happy neet)

 

[Nameplaceholder102;]

doesn't one room have a sleep rape scene in the prologue? any thoughts on that?

 

[butter_scotch13]

doesn't one room have a sleep rape scene in the prologue? any thoughts on that?

There shouldn’t be any? Never seen it, and it wasn’t required for the ending which requires every obtainable scene and achievement.

 

[Typhu]

https://f95zone.to/threads/with-an-older-girl-yuinas-sweet-encouragement-final-dlc-bousabag.72209/ Played this one recently, and it's a really wholesome cohabitation game. It's incest though as the girl is your cousin, though you can say no to most sex scenes and her role in the story is more akin to a childhood friend rather than a family member if that makes it any better.

 

[butter_scotch13]

https://f95zone.to/threads/with-an-older-girl-yuinas-sweet-encouragement-final-dlc-bousabag.72209/ Played this one recently, and it's a really wholesome cohabitation game. It's incest though as the girl is your cousin, though you can say no to most sex scenes and her role in the story is more akin to a childhood friend rather than a family member if that makes it any better.

It’s going to go on the extras section, I do not interact with THAT close of a familial relationship..
Second cousins is the max I’ll go, but even then it both has to be 1). Not a main point and 2). They haven’t legitimately been like, real family with each other (estranged, forgotten, long lost, etc is.. fine I guess)

 

[butter_scotch13]

Also as for why the list hasn’t been getting updates, I’m 1). Sick right now with a pretty bad sinus infection, and 2). Kind of busy? Not enough time to be reviewing games and such, but I’ll still try to be as active as possible.

in the meantime.. check out my rule34 (xxx) account [wholesomeftw] if you feel like it! I post there occasionally.. though it’s basically ALL hololive content

 

[Reckoning10]

Have you tried Flowerglade or is that not really your kind of game?

 

[butter_scotch13]

Have you tried Flowerglade or is that not really your kind of game?

I’ve never heard of it, can you explain real quick?
JUST remember I only really do straight content, and definitely no incest or anything near that!!

 

[Reckoning10]

I’ve never heard of it, can you explain real quick?
JUST remember I only really do straight content, and definitely no incest or anything near that!!

https://f95zone.to/threads/flowerglade-v0-1-334-lavastone.214064/ Here's the link to the game. No mention of incest in the tags so I think it's safe.

Summary: Cozy/wholesome VN set in a lush forest where the MC has to help awaken the sexual desires of 4 forest spirits monster girls.

 

[HeoEva]

nice got trauma from darkk hero party i hope that i can find something lovely here

 

[butter_scotch13]

Hey guys, just a quick update.
I'll just copy and paste a message I sent in the MDRG server, should explain where I've been-
"I haven't been here in a while, one because it's hard to be horny when pulling the 5th all nighter in a row, and two, the lack of horniness also leads to me not having anything interesting about my game list"

Little bit busy with school & life, and I'm not in the best mindset to be playing these! D:

 

[butter_scotch13]

Got in the mood for a bit to play some more stuff- I'm currently fully commited to playing Eiyuu*Senki: The World Conquest [Tenco], and I have to say, this is both geniunely beautiful, ANDthe most fun I've had; both gameplay and DIALOGUE wise.
I'm only like half an hour into the game, but I've legitimately stopped to read/listen to every dialogue- the voice acting is amazing and the lines are actually really funny!

Also, Himiko is such an adorable little goober.. (first scene freaked me out, then it was just revealed that she's just a bit too imaginative, lmao)

 

[iYuma]

Got in the mood for a bit to play some more stuff- I'm currently fully commited to playing Eiyuu*Senki: The World Conquest [Tenco], and I have to say, this is both geniunely beautiful, ANDthe most fun I've had; both gameplay and DIALOGUE wise.
I'm only like half an hour into the game, but I've legitimately stopped to read/listen to every dialogue- the voice acting is amazing and the lines are actually really funny!

Also, Himiko is such an adorable little goober.. (first scene freaked me out, then it was just revealed that she's just a bit too imaginative, lmao)

If you liked the gameplay.. You'll love sengoku rance but.. ofc rance series is not exactly a vanilla game.. mostly

 

[butter_scotch13]

If you liked the gameplay.. You'll love sengoku rance but.. ofc rance series is not exactly a vanilla game.. mostly

I’d prefer to stay away from that stuff, yeah.

On the topic of World Conquest- you should like you’ve played it before.
Are the romances/sex scenes outside of Himiko optional? I started playing this game because I heard it has some really nice enemy-lover type stuff- but Himiko is SO precious that I basically immediately wanted to dedicate everything to her. Plus, I just got her first scene (cute- but.. that description was a little much..), however since it was essentially a forced mission, I’m wondering if any of the other girls are going to have something like that.. I really don’t want to cheat on Himiko D:

*Edit, looked on the wiki (for just Himiko, game’s too good to get spoiled on!) and it seems like she might be the sole LI? Not sure, but I really, REALLY hope so!

 

[butter_scotch13]

Or sole forced LI, at least.
Anyways- somehow I didn't put together that this is simply an 18+ version of an actual non-nsfw game.. I saw some of the most insane production quality I've ever seen and just thought that was normal, lol

anyways about himiko I love her so much I think I have a thing for slightly dumb yet very lovable characters shes so precious and headpattable but also she actually gets headpats all the time and its so cute argh I hope the game lets us not go harem though I also wish the first scene was a bit better like it started pretty cute and obviously stayed consensual but when its like she’s forcing herself for your sake but your also forcing yourself for her sake then its just kind of uncomfortable for everyone howd it start all gentle then end up with both people bleeding for various reasons !! anyways this is a lot of text tldr himiko is adorable

 

[butter_scotch13]

oh goodness
i do not trust arthur (i feel inclined to call her elizabeth) to NOT suddenly and unexpectedly lead me into a forced scene

 

[butter_scotch13]

Luckily, from what I've seen all harem/stuff outside of Himiko is optional!
Though, one thing I need to say is that the MC really needs to have boundaries. There's way too many people flirting with him (with Himiko openly being very defensive of him and disliking any flirtatious activities from other girls), and he almost never even addresses it or reassures Himiko of anything..
Like please, at least tell them that you're uncomfortable! :sob:

 

[butter_scotch13]

First major update in months!
The formatting on the stars didnt work out, but I'm still happy to update this list!
2 more games have been added, and if I have time I will try adding some doujins too!

 

[butter_scotch13]

well i spoke too soon
i knew it man, arthur/elizabeth hopped on me out of nowhere

and yeah the mc has absolutely no boundaries
like, whats the point of making the mc a heroic, "i must save everyone!" type character and then have him be so unfaithful to his literal (at this point) wife