Recommending Butter's Ultimate(?) Wholesome Games/Doujins List! (a la VoltageFlame) || Also a Discussion and Recommendations Thread! (UPD: 12/17/24!!)

[Oh-Taco]

Oh so you didn’t even play some of them? Yet you put them here?

And just because the rape is avoidable, doesn’t mean that you could put them here, because there is ZERO romance, this is the WHOLESOME games thread, its right there in the title

This game is 1000% not belong here

I'm 100% at fault for that and I apologize again for it, but I also can't litmus test all games 100% and I'll try to cut back on them.

That's all, I have exhausted my games as of late and have next to nothing left so I misfired trying to come up with something forgetting the original purpose and I'm very sorry for it.

 

[butter_scotch13]

Other than the ones with the tag (Incest) as you pointed out the quick answer would be rape to various degrees/fashions

I'll try to break a few down, but as I have not played the games fully I might mislabel some.

(I'm going to use ? = unsure, * = potential/optional, and *? = uncertain if it's optional and make use of this for future recommendations)

Feminist F-ist Is quite simple as nnt1996 pointed out it contains rape or at least so say the tags I don't remember much of the game other than the fighting dialog gave me a good laugh. I think most if not all scenes are bought with money earned after the fight so it can be avoidable, but then it's just a fighting game where you strip your opponent. (Rape*?)

Introducing An Apprentice Incubus game seems to have some "romance", but I really can't get myself to play these games at the moment so I have little experience with it. (Rape, Reverse Rape? Loli, based off tags Futa/Trans, and Shota? It depends on if you would call the protag a Shota or not) idk why I initially included it other than the slightly fluffy dialog I saw at times.

Nemurimouto Just adding this one again to give a bit more substance. The game feels empty atm (it is v0.06) so some scenes seem to be near obvious rape, but then others are too absurd to be real and make me skeptical. All scenes should be "optional" as they would need user input to initiate (or so I think), but also some aren't as obvious.

Now the SEQUEL games (that I have played) are a mixed bag, but they all share one tag (Reverse Rape) They do have some nice dialog and romance routes/"endings", but they are a powder keg of different fetishes so user/consumer/player be warned.

I hope my breakdown was enough and I'll try to add the more sketchy tags at the end from here on out.

For future reference should I add the tags at the end of my review such as

EXAMPLE GAME yap yap yap desc

(TAGS)

or is the way I have done it now acceptable? (I'm leaning more toward the new format personally)

Also, I don't know if games found on Itch are fine as Goddesses' Whim (Loli?) or maybe Living in Viellci (Loli and the game is heavily in-dev so art is changing at times) MIGHT work, but most are just Renpy + Koikatsu VNs that I would need to scrape into for "proper" tagging and honestly I have very little drive/motivation for doing that rn.

I think the format of
[GAME] - [Short Thoughts]
[DESC]
[Tags]
works best

Thanks for the games, I do remember that Goddesses’ Whim appealed tome at first, but just a little too much harem shown in the front page to get me to download it. Living in Viellci is a game I’m saving for later- thanks for reminding me!!
Also just remember, I’ll try to include any game with romance (maybe just not in the highest tiers) no matter the tag UNLESS it’s ntr, so it’s fine if the games don’t perfectly fit. Though also, if the game has no plot it’s probably going into mid tier as long as it has clearly consensual scenes.

 

[Arabi1]

Feminist F-ist Is quite simple as nnt1996 pointed out it contains rape or at least so say the tags I don't remember much of the game other than the fighting dialog gave me a good laugh. I think most if not all scenes are bought with money earned after the fight so it can be avoidable, but then it's just a fighting game where you strip your opponent. (Rape*?)

Introducing An Apprentice Incubus game seems to have some "romance", but I really can't get myself to play these games at the moment so I have little experience with it. (Rape, Reverse Rape? Loli, based off tags Futa/Trans, and Shota? It depends on if you would call the protag a Shota or not) idk why I initially included it other than the slightly fluffy dialog I saw at times.

These games are great and Feminist F-ist is one of the funniest shit I ever played, but it is all about raping the opponent and the romance comes after. Introducing An Apprentice Incubus is a puzzle game and mostly dubious consent, where the MC falls under some kind of lust magic and can't control himself, and the woman falls under the spell too, so they willingly do it where they normally wouldn't. I don't remember much, but I'm sure if butter_scotch13 saw the loli scene he'd have a heart attack. As I said, these games are great and I personally recommend them on my list, but I don't think they're wholesome enough to be here.

 

[nnt1996]

I don't think they're wholesome enough to be here.

They aren’t wholesome to begin with

 

[Oh-Taco]

These games are great and Feminist F-ist is one of the funniest shit I ever played, but it is all about raping the opponent and the romance comes after. Introducing An Apprentice Incubus is a puzzle game and mostly dubious consent, where the MC falls under some kind of lust magic and can't control himself, and the woman falls under the spell too, so they willingly do it where they normally wouldn't. I don't remember much, but I'm sure if butter_scotch13 saw the loli scene he'd have a heart attack. As I said, these games are great and I personally recommend them on my list, but I don't think they're wholesome enough to be here.

Hey Arabi, thanks for the constructive reply.

I've struck both games off the list, as your response gave me a better perspective than I had, and I decided it was best to just drop them based on your feedback.

Thanks again!

 

[butter_scotch13]

Finally updated this list with the extras section, please send more if you can! Want to get the wholesomeness out to as many groups of people as possible : D

 

[butter_scotch13]

Forgot to add Corrupted Kingdoms & Goddesses’ Whim, but also currently asking for as many game recs as I can from the servers im in since with the extras section I can basically take anything

 

[butter_scotch13]

Realized most people don't read the comments, so I grabbed all the links I could find from them and put them into another section in Extras!

 

[butter_scotch13]

I’m gonna add which platforms these games can be played on in a bit- everyone on the MDRG server seems to have an android with no windows device for some reason, lol

 

[butter_scotch13]

Well I was too lazy to do that, but I added Fallen shinobi into low tier.
I'd imagine most of you guys aren't as dogmatic as me about keeping stuff as perfect and consensual as possible, and fallen shinobi, from what I've seen, has the potential to be really cute and wholesome if you can get past the initial rape barrier (..)
I couldn't do it, but some others could probably have fun!

 

[Arabi1]

Well I was too lazy to do that, but I added Fallen shinobi into low tier.
I'd imagine most of you guys aren't as dogmatic as me about keeping stuff as perfect and consensual as possible, and fallen shinobi, from what I've seen, has the potential to be really cute and wholesome if you can get past the initial rape barrier (..)
I couldn't do it, but some others could probably have fun!

You could have asked me, I played it a long time ago and could have warned you beforehand but welp.. Next time tell us about your new game so I can tell you if it's safe.

 

[butter_scotch13]

You could have asked me, I played it a long time ago and could have warned you beforehand but welp.. Next time tell us about your new game so I can tell you if it's safe.

Yeah, I’ll check here first next time. I got it from a thread with some guy saying it was pretty cute and similar to teaching feeling, so I spent the next 6 hours trying to find a way to not let her die while also not having to literally rape her.
Needless to say, I was a *little* tilted after that experience, but at least there’s something to add to my list, lol

 

[butter_scotch13]

Arabi, I got a whole bunch of game recommendations from Seeking Similar Games like Life with a Slave. Enriched with nurture and romance. Same thread where I got jump scared by Fallen Shinobi, so I'd appreciate it if you could give me a heads up on any of these games! Thanks : D

 

[Arabi1]

Arabi, I got a whole bunch of game recommendations from Seeking Similar Games like Life with a Slave. Enriched with nurture and romance. Same thread where I got jump scared by Fallen Shinobi, so I'd appreciate it if you could give me a heads up on any of these games! Thanks : D

Goodbye Eternity - Has corruption route where you whore your mother and get involved in mafia or something and turn one of the girls into something horrible, I don't remember what it was but it was optional. The problem is the whole game only has 2 scenes and they are quite far and one of them is in the corruption route so it is a slow burn but I think it has potential but for now I don't recommend it at all until enough content is added.

BDSM Apocalypse - OK... The art is great and the story is good. But the gameplay has a big problem, it puts you on a map and you're lost looking for zombies for hours in a mission and don't know exactly where to go. If you're willing to spend some time exploring for a looooong time, and I mean that, give it a try, otherwise the other aspects are fine. I only saw one shot of sexual content, I think it was a blowjob even though I spent a lot of hours on it, but expect female dom like footjob later on.

I tried Masters Of Raana and it's good. It gives you all the control over what you do, I don't know if there are conditions imposed on you, but I think it's okay to try it. Keep in mind that it's a game designed to kill your time, so you can play it for dozens of hours and most of that is to learn the game mechanics because it's a bit complicated. The game is not wholesome by itself, you make it wholesome by controlling what happens in it. It better to ask crnisl he knows the game better than I do.

I haven't tried Love and Corruption but it sounds wholesome if you don't mind harem.

 

[butter_scotch13]

Goodbye Eternity - Has corruption route where you whore your mother and get involved in mafia or something and turn one of the girls into something horrible, I don't remember what it was but it was optional. The problem is the whole game only has 2 scenes and they are quite far and one of them is in the corruption route so it is a slow burn but I think it has potential but for now I don't recommend it at all until enough content is added.

BDSM Apocalypse - OK... The art is great and the story is good. But the gameplay has a big problem, it puts you on a map and you're lost looking for zombies for hours in a mission and don't know exactly where to go. If you're willing to spend some time exploring for a looooong time, and I mean that, give it a try, otherwise the other aspects are fine. I only saw one shot of sexual content, I think it was a blowjob even though I spent a lot of hours on it, but expect female dom like footjob later on.

I tried Masters Of Raana and it's good. It gives you all the control over what you do, I don't know if there are conditions imposed on you, but I think it's okay to try it. Keep in mind that it's a game designed to kill your time, so you can play it for dozens of hours and most of that is to learn the game mechanics because it's a bit complicated. The game is not wholesome by itself, you make it wholesome by controlling what happens in it. It better to ask crnisl he knows the game better than I do.

I haven't tried Love and Corruption but it sounds wholesome if you don't mind harem.

Love & Corruption is already on my list- and it IS the most wholesome rpg game as of yet. Harem is optional there so I'm fine with it.
Goodbye eternity sounds.. yeah I'll leave that one alone
I'm not really into BDSM so I'll prob leave that alone as well

I love time sink games so Masters of Raana sounds really nice! By not wholesome by itself, is it similar to like, Strive or something where there IS a romance system but it's up to the player to use it? Or do you have to like, pretend that stuff exists (like in SfP)

 

[crnisl]

I love time sink games so Masters of Raana sounds really nice! By not wholesome by itself, is it similar to like, Strive or something where there IS a romance system but it's up to the player to use it?

Every girl has lots of stats. Roughly speaking, you can either break a girl to make her work for you (as a prostitute or whatever) through punishment and bdsm, or gradually make her fall in love with you through compliments/gifts/wholesome sex and other stuff (like getting victories together with her in your team, if she's a fighting type). Then you can marry her (several wives is possible, depends on the mc's religion), and so on, rise your children, etc.

Breaking is more profitable - though there're lots of different ways of getting income in the game, and instead of managing a brothel, you can do crafting or raiding. On the other side, once a girl trusts you, she will tell you more of her backstory, and eventually it's leading to some quests - about going to some forgotten vaults, raiding bandits who wronged her in the past, like that.

 

[butter_scotch13]

or gradually make her fall in love with you through compliments/gifts/wholesome sex and other stuff (like getting victories together with her in your team, if she's a fighting type). Then you can marry her (several wives is possible, depends on the mc's religion), and so on, rise your children, etc.
On the other side, once a girl trusts you, she will tell you more of her backstory, and eventually it's leading to some quests - about going to some forgotten vaults, raiding bandits who wronged her in the past, like that.

aww, that sounds super cute!! I'll check this out then- a system like this is something that I've always wanted in a game (love & Corruption does this, kinda but less so)

 

[pir]

Read the reccomendation, bro plz, keep out of Black souls, that thing gonna broke you, i reccomend you add "Haremon" is a real good dating sim game, with good story, good characters and good and funny scenes, saddly aside the name, you cannot make an harem, only have girlfriend (You can broke with her and feel like shit, then change to other girl, but that is be a dick)

 

[Arabi1]

keep out of Black souls

yeah absolutely

 

[iYuma]

But.. Black Souls is.. depressingly PEAK..