2D Concept art for a wholesome bbw incest game

MilkFiend

Newbie
Sep 27, 2021
27
267
Hey there guys! Really sorry if this post sucks or anything, I haven't used a forum in years and I'm not quite sure what I'm doing yet. I'm kind of nervous!

Anyway, I'm pretty damn into incest stories, but I feel like too many of them involve some form of abuse, corruption, or manipulation, when a lot of what draws me to it is the early presence of love. I'd like to create a story that's more natural and romantic without necessarily being a slow burn.
On top of this, I also find my preferences aren't represented in a lot of the games on here, as evidenced by the concepts below, I'm into women with a LOT more meat on their bones, and I have a bit of a thing for body hair (don't worry though, if I do make this game I'll include a toggle for that).

Now I'd like to ask you guys some questions about what kind of games you like, but first I'd really appreciate if you check out the art I attached!

1659099652796.png mama.png

I hope you like it! Please let me know how you feel, and criticism is always welcome.

Anyway, I have a few questions for anybody that's made it this far:

What kind of protagonist do you enjoy? My idea at the moment is for him to be kind of weak and get picked on/bullied, so his family has the opportunity to nurture him and build him up. Then maybe later he can transition to getting stronger and more confident. Or not! Let me know your thoughts

How do we feel about fathers in these games? Do we prefer dead dad, deadbeat dad, abusive dad, competing against dad, etc. I'm thinking he was around but gets kicked out pretty early for being a piece of shit.

Do you guys enjoy your smut with a more grounded story or something more fantastical? I'm leaning toward the former here but I want to know how everyone feels about this topic.

Do you guys like having non-incest relationships in your incest games? I don't tend to find myself chasing them as hard because the taboo and the closeness are typically the main draw for me, though if someone is hot enough I'll definitely cave for her.

I'm definitely going to include breeding and impregnation, but I always feel like games kind of cop out on that one, is anyone interested in the concept of a time-skip and relationships with your children? One large problem with that is it can put off players that enjoy the younger designs of the main cast, and at some point you'd have to break off their plot for the future plot. This one's a bit tough for me.

And most importantly, if this looks or sounds like something you'd enjoy, what would you like to see?

And that's it! If you made it down here I'd like to thank you for reading my post, and I'd love to hear your thoughts. I've dabbled with games before but I've never finished one, and if I do start on this I'd like it to be the best it can be.
 
Last edited:

Saki_Sliz

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2018
1,403
1,011
I would be a fan of such a game. you ask a lot of questions so I'll list them out:

  • How should the male protagonist be written (example: start of weak, but get stronger/more confident)
  • What happens to the father (all the examples seem to be a way to remove him from the story)
  • is a story that is lest wild/fantastical and more slice of life still an interesting game?
  • planning to focus on more taboo and close relationships, but may explore other ideas if anyone has any suggestions
  • rather than just ending the game at sex, you're considering continuing the game post time skip, post children, with the characters a bit older.
  • overall does the project sound like something you should continue.
Let me summarize my thoughts overall. As you mentioned you never found a game that really matched your interest, so your throwing in the towel and deciding to do it yourself since no one else will. I can defiantly tell this is something you are interested in, and at the same time I can tell that your just starting out, motivated but no specific inspiration to lead you one direction or another. I'd love to give some feed back (and I would like to see such a project :D )



You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

MilkFiend

Newbie
Sep 27, 2021
27
267
I would be a fan of such a game. you ask a lot of questions so I'll list them out:

  • How should the male protagonist be written (example: start of weak, but get stronger/more confident)
  • What happens to the father (all the examples seem to be a way to remove him from the story)
  • is a story that is lest wild/fantastical and more slice of life still an interesting game?
  • planning to focus on more taboo and close relationships, but may explore other ideas if anyone has any suggestions
  • rather than just ending the game at sex, you're considering continuing the game post time skip, post children, with the characters a bit older.
  • overall does the project sound like something you should continue.
Let me summarize my thoughts overall. As you mentioned you never found a game that really matched your interest, so your throwing in the towel and deciding to do it yourself since no one else will. I can defiantly tell this is something you are interested in, and at the same time I can tell that your just starting out, motivated but no specific inspiration to lead you one direction or another. I'd love to give some feed back (and I would like to see such a project :D )



You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Thank you so much for checking out the thread! I really appreciate your detailed write ups as well, it gives me a lot to think about. I feel a bit better knowing at least some people might not be as hung up on some of the things I'm worried about while they're playing. While I understand people mostly play these games for the porn, I do think it helps a lot to create character relationships that feel a bit more 3 dimensional that you can really get invested in, that's mainly why I ask about the MC and father and such. Of course, I also think fostering discussion over the things I think are important can also help me think through exactly what I want to do.

The advice about goals and keeping it interesting is especially helpful, as that is certainly not something I had thought about, so thank you for that as well!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sandstorm 99

MilkFiend

Newbie
Sep 27, 2021
27
267
Hey guys, been doing a bit of work on this!

I finished these sprites of the mother character, I'm not 100% on if these are final. Took me 5 or 6 hours to do just these so if I want to have different poses for different emotions it could get out of hand fast, might need to simplify.

Anyway, enjoy! mamasprites.png
 

MilkFiend

Newbie
Sep 27, 2021
27
267
Older sister time! I think I'm going to do one set of fully rendered portraits for the first 3 characters but after that I'll do a simpler style so I can work faster. Either way, hope you enjoy!
Jocksprites.png
 

Sandstorm 99

Member
Aug 24, 2021
165
228
Hey guys, been doing a bit of work on this!

I finished these sprites of the mother character, I'm not 100% on if these are final. Took me 5 or 6 hours to do just these so if I want to have different poses for different emotions it could get out of hand fast, might need to simplify.

Anyway, enjoy! View attachment 1966712
Wow those look amazing
I'm happy that someone finally made a mother that looks actually like a mother (bbw, hairy) seems more natural and realistic .
I really like the art and the direction that you want for the game and it's true that most of incest games nowadays tend to focus more on the sex side and ignore the character development,logical plot progression and emotional impact on the player.
Personally I care more for the story than the art in these games so I really think that your game would be a great success.
 

MilkFiend

Newbie
Sep 27, 2021
27
267
Wow those look amazing
I'm happy that someone finally made a mother that looks actually like a mother (bbw, hairy) seems more natural and realistic .
I really like the art and the direction that you want for the game and it's true that most of incest games nowadays tend to focus more on the sex side and ignore the character development,logical plot progression and emotional impact on the player.
Personally I care more for the story than the art in these games so I really think that your game would be a great success.
Thank you so much for the kind words! It helps a lot to know that people are interested in what I want to make and will definitely help light a fire under my ass.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sandstorm 99