Overall a good game which greatly improves as the game progresses. Took me ~4-5 hours to complete and I used the walkthrough mod. I unlocked most scenes, but some depend on which ending you choose. I would rate this a high B-tier or low A-tier game.
TL;DR
Good
-Interesting story (and somewhat realistic?)
-Animation and renders significantly improve in the 2nd half of the game
-The girls have unique models, they aren't just carbon copies that you see in a lot of VNs
Bad
-The animation and renders are really awful at the start
-Some of the girls are not attractive at all (e.g. Kirla)
-Audio is very basic
-Incest patch doesn't feel very natural, i would recommend not using it
Full review:
The story is one of the high points of this game. I really like the mystery and detective work. Since I used the walkthrough mod, I'm not sure how impactful the choices are on the story. I thought the story pacing was great and the conclusion was well done as well.
The character design goes from really awful to amazing. The render quality is average at best for the first 2-3 hours, then for the second half of the game the renders have incredible quality. In particular, Judy's face in the 1st half is really quite ugly and unnatural, but in the 2nd half she's super hot. The only girls which remain hot throughout imo are Carli, Christina, and Stella, and even then their render quality greatly improves. I do appreciate that this game uses models which are unique unlike a lot of other VNs.
The scenes, just like the character design, goes from rudimentary and basic in the 1st half of the game to incredible in the 2nd half. The animation in the 1st half is choppy and often is just 2 images playing back and forth - at that point I'd rather just have still CGs. In the 2nd half of the game, the animation is noticeably better, with actual smooth animation and it's brilliant. The scenes are also easy enough to unlock if you're following the walkthrough mod. There is also a gallery in the main menu which shows all the scenes, even if you havent unlocked them in game which i think is good. One of the problems with City of Broken Dreamers (the dev's other game) was that I only got like half of the scenes and the rest was just locked.
The characters are also interesting, they do have actual personalities for the most part, though of course a lot of them are super slutty (this is a porn game after all). I don't really feel like a huge emotional connection was made with any of the girls in aprticular, in my playthrough, the MC seemed to have gotten together with Carli, but it didn't really feel natural? Like he's banging all these girls and he just chooses Carli, I didnt really have a choice. Another thing is the incest in this game. I feel like Judy wants to fuck you way too easily, after like a few days of living together, and the incest did not really feel natural (though I guess this could be attributed to the Awakening?). Either way, it doesn't affect anything too much, just a small criticism.
My only other 'issue' is taht the audio was very basic, I would've appreciated more moans during scenes or just some music during the story/dialogue as some parts are just completely silent.
Overall, it's a good game with a great story and animation/renders which significantly improves in the 2nd half of the game. If you can get past the choppy, low-quality scenes in the 1st half then it's definitely worth playing.
TL;DR
Good
-Interesting story (and somewhat realistic?)
-Animation and renders significantly improve in the 2nd half of the game
-The girls have unique models, they aren't just carbon copies that you see in a lot of VNs
Bad
-The animation and renders are really awful at the start
-Some of the girls are not attractive at all (e.g. Kirla)
-Audio is very basic
-Incest patch doesn't feel very natural, i would recommend not using it
Full review:
The story is one of the high points of this game. I really like the mystery and detective work. Since I used the walkthrough mod, I'm not sure how impactful the choices are on the story. I thought the story pacing was great and the conclusion was well done as well.
The character design goes from really awful to amazing. The render quality is average at best for the first 2-3 hours, then for the second half of the game the renders have incredible quality. In particular, Judy's face in the 1st half is really quite ugly and unnatural, but in the 2nd half she's super hot. The only girls which remain hot throughout imo are Carli, Christina, and Stella, and even then their render quality greatly improves. I do appreciate that this game uses models which are unique unlike a lot of other VNs.
The scenes, just like the character design, goes from rudimentary and basic in the 1st half of the game to incredible in the 2nd half. The animation in the 1st half is choppy and often is just 2 images playing back and forth - at that point I'd rather just have still CGs. In the 2nd half of the game, the animation is noticeably better, with actual smooth animation and it's brilliant. The scenes are also easy enough to unlock if you're following the walkthrough mod. There is also a gallery in the main menu which shows all the scenes, even if you havent unlocked them in game which i think is good. One of the problems with City of Broken Dreamers (the dev's other game) was that I only got like half of the scenes and the rest was just locked.
The characters are also interesting, they do have actual personalities for the most part, though of course a lot of them are super slutty (this is a porn game after all). I don't really feel like a huge emotional connection was made with any of the girls in aprticular, in my playthrough, the MC seemed to have gotten together with Carli, but it didn't really feel natural? Like he's banging all these girls and he just chooses Carli, I didnt really have a choice. Another thing is the incest in this game. I feel like Judy wants to fuck you way too easily, after like a few days of living together, and the incest did not really feel natural (though I guess this could be attributed to the Awakening?). Either way, it doesn't affect anything too much, just a small criticism.
My only other 'issue' is taht the audio was very basic, I would've appreciated more moans during scenes or just some music during the story/dialogue as some parts are just completely silent.
Overall, it's a good game with a great story and animation/renders which significantly improves in the 2nd half of the game. If you can get past the choppy, low-quality scenes in the 1st half then it's definitely worth playing.