This is a weird one, the MC is a moron and unlikable but everything else seems pretty solid.
The Author gives us some choices, but nothing major. For example, when the MC and Kayla are "kidnapped" and we realize it's a prank, there definitely needed to be a punch the douche in the face option. Also when we are consoling Kayla about the situation, we downplay how serious it is. It's terrible.
I was going to give this game a higher score for the models and overall nice polish around everything, but the MC sucks and if he is not fixed this is a dead game walking.
(edit)
My review keeps bouncing around so I'm going to leave it a 3, the game has a solid enough base and I actually enjoy playing it, but like I said above, some major flaws need to be worked out with either how the MC acts or give us more control of how the MC reacts.