Ren'Py - Eden [Ch.4] [FnBProductions]

Okay, hear me out.
When you first click into the game, you will see the average renders and belike "pass". Yeah that's true, for about 1 chapter. Then the render get upgraded significantly, like I don't know the dev work super hard and shoot his skill from 5 to 9 or he just hired some guy do that for him. But the render from chapter 2 are good, and chapter 3 are great, on par with quality game like Inanna Revenge. So render: 5/5
Character: 4.5/5, we has a lovely cast of 4 main girls, a streamer character with actually personality, a princesss, a songstress, and an assassin, why so diverse. Yeah we doing isekai and bring some friends. Anyway, their interaction with the MC and each other is a dynamic of wholesomeness. The MC is also competent, being detective, smart and all. The tiny complain is they fall for him a bit too quick, just a bit, but yeah that's harem for you.
Puzzle: We has guide, free, so it doesn't affect my rating, most of the puzzle are very short.
To summary, a game worth playing, I promise you the render get super better.

The game is funny and interesting. The girls are sexy and their interactions are great.

Now...

I have had issues with the puzzles, but maybe it's just me. Nothing terrible, but I think there should be some hint system in game. There is a walkthrough in the downloads though.

Some scenes are fast and hurried at first. The developer was new and you can notice it. Not terrible either, the next scenes correct that. The renders keep improving and are reaching a very good level.

The developer releases new updates between every 1-2 months and there is already a good amount of content.

Overall 8.25-8.5

Eden [Ch-1]
Okay -ish porn game and premise with average castaway porn story and 1D characters, nothing to write home about. You can check it for images and animations.

Story - 1-2,7/5. Whatever. Nothing much.
Characters - 1.4/5. Who cares. Generic porn chars.
Models/animations - ~2.6/5. Pretty good
Gameplay is okay.
Grammar - 3/5. Eh, whatever.
MC - eh.

Solid start. Mature characters. Decent writing, though we don't get to know too much about our cast in the prologue. MC is a detective, his new girlfiend / fwb is a streamer. And... go.

The UI self-admittedly needs a fair bit of work. And the last "beer" puzzle is awfully esoteric.

This has the potential to be really cool. I'll adjust my ratings as the game develops. Good luck!