Version reviewed: 0.8.6
Let's start with the good:
Characters: Mostly likable, with distinct personalities and enough development to grow fond of them.
Graphics: They're not groundbreaking, but they're not an eyesore either. The Honey Select engine might be a bit outdated, but the animated cutscenes are very well done, and the backgrounds (especially on the Eternum servers) are very well executed.
Story: The story is quite good, and the fact that it's set between the real world and the world of online games offers a lot of possibilities (fantasy, gothic horror, science fiction...). Furthermore, the humor it possesses at certain moments is genuinely hilarious.
What I absolutely hated:
Players who want to choose their love interests and decide when and with whom to have sex will be terribly frustrated: At one point in the game, the protagonist has the option to go and save a love interest or let an NPC do it for him. If he chooses the second option, the path with the girl is completely blocked, but, conversely, if he chooses the first, because he's interested in her, the protagonist will be forced to have sex with her under coercion and blackmail, with the player powerless to do anything about it. Seriously, that's the choice we're offered: give up on the girl or let a stranger force you to have sex with her?
Without a doubt, a deplorable decision, which causes a game that, on my personal scale, could easily have four or five stars, to drop to two.