VN - Ren'Py - Fake Father [Second v0.4 Full] [Netero3009]

I'm not sure why this game is rated so highly honestly. I can ignore the the gender messups as this was written by a nonnative english speaker, but what I can't really forgive is the terrible writing quality. The dialogue feels like it was written by an angsty teenager honestly and comes across quite stilted and artificial. The render are average nothing to complain about, but honestly not great. IDK maybe I'm missing something, but I can't even fathom how this has so many 5 stars.

I have now played through the current release once (v0.5a), and I like the game so far.
Cute girls and a fairly interesting story.
But there are some quite awful gender mix-ups, like when MC talks to his "daughter" and asks her, what she would do, if she got a son, and her son "gets and infection on her penis..."
Image example.

I liked this idea, so far no abstruse reasons and mystical theories, the only youngest daughter could have been made bigger. It was not boring and I look forward to continuing. There is little time for choosing fathers and this gives the plot a dynamic character.

good renders
no sex so far
I really like the bond the MC is trying to create with the other guy's daughters
about ~ 1.5 hours of playtime if you play slow and read everything.
If you are missing anything from the gallery change your answer to Lilly, she seems to be the only one with a split route of good dad/ bad dad.

interesting, seems like its got a lot of potential, girls look great and they are all new girls, hopefully we'll see more of this game. Story is good although the story currently mentions 3 weeks I assume the "real" father will either mysteriously disappear to prolong that, but either way I can't wait. Hope there is a harem aspect to this, but I've got lots of hopes.

Nice story, average graphics. keep it up. IT will be interesting how three of them will react to different routes, i guess there will be a good father and a bad father route for every one of them, imposter father i mean. The goofiness is at excellent level too for this type of games.

Good quality, very few spelling errors - even with the translation. Fun premise. Excellent hot models. This is a great start and I am excited for more content. I hope it will continue. It's rather incomplete right now but it's a great tease. Keep it up!

Not a bad start, I like where this story could go. Some translation errors where the text says "he" when it should be "she", but it's not game breaking. I'm assuming the choices that lead to game over will be alternate paths in the future.
I really don't see where the cultist sees anything political about this, other than the MC wanting to keep his fake family together and be a good "fake" father...nothing political is even referenced.

Played 5-10 minutes of this, so take this as opinion with a grain of salt:

My main thoughts on this title in the short playthrough was:

• Choices leading to "game over". These serves, IMO, no point other than to frustrate someone playing the game. Choices should be branches to alternative dialogue or entirely new game experiences, NOT to instant game over.
• Political opinions. This is personal for me, but I am not going to play a game where the MC expresses, for me, radical political opinions. MC here sounds like an alt-right nutjob. If he had been a hardcore SJW, a Trumpist, a follower of QAnon, or a Fascist, I also wouldn't bother playing the game. Keep extremist political ideology out of games, especially if it is the MC that has it.
• Renders are OK-ish for this site.
• I like the concept of being an imposter, that has potential.