It's not a one star game, but there are some grievances regarding a couple of issues I found while playing this game, but before I list out the issues, I want to make a small premise so I can properly dissociate from a couple of reviewers that bombed it because it was a NTR game as my judgment is by seeing it not only as a NTR game, but also as a project that is meant to last fifteen, maybe twenty minutes. Now, here's the list:
1) Art is decent, but there is so little of it. A good part of the action is shown through the game sprites, and it really feels very 'poor'. I feel the art is good and I wouldn't have minded see more of it, perhaps switching POVs a bit more frequently, reducing the more boring scenes while the guy is getting NTR'd;
2) The MC is a wimp; he is particularly stupid, weak-willed and atrociously naive. Which is fine- no, great even. I didn't feel much when he died nor even as he was getting NTR'd, but... I think it feels odd that someone like him ended up marrying someone like Vicky. I think that part could do with some working on how Vicky ended up with him, maybe with her pitying him and deciding to marry him out of that rather than genuine romantic love. It just feels so illogical and kind of disrupt the suspension of disbelief, just a bit tho;
3) This actually confused me since the very beginning of the gameplay: I don't know how to feel about Ludia. It's not that I found her bad as a character, she works well in the role she's given, but she also feels... unimportant. Like, I understand that it adds extra-chaddery to Bruce and co., but, plotwise, she doesn't feel important enough to also make an impact on the MC's grasp of reality. I dunno, maybe making her a cousin or maybe a 'past love rival' to Vicky- something that makes the MC care and thus break properly when the whole truth comes out.
Once again, this game is 'good-ish'. Art is good, and I can tell it's going to improve with enough practice, but there are some elements about the plot-telling element that felt too forced. Alas, I hope this criticism feels more as a reason to try your hand more into making games, but for now Fluffy Neighbours gets two stars from me.