the renders are good, they get better further into the game after chapter 1. some of the scenes are really well staged and have composition qualities of a particularly striking photograph. i like the agency of having different paths to treat the girls in different ways. not that i think i'll work up the nerve to actually treat nicki or gabby badly; they are sweet and have had their share of troubles. this game gets what modern media often gets so wrong (galadriel in rings of power, or rey in star wars) the main character doesn't need to be perfect at everything or a badass warrior. the main character could just be nice and help people. that makes them very likeable. the main character in this formerly had a mediocre job at a supermarket, and then uses his money to help those who need and deserve it. this makes him very relatable and likeable, in turn we root for him and get emotionally invested in the story. then because of that investment we are more likely to give the benefit of the doubt for little issues or flaws that may come up. it can be that simple. this isn't a perfect game, but i like it much more than a lot of games that may be "technically" better. a deserved five stars.