Overall, it's a good idea but poorly executed.
Within the first few minutes of this game, you might think it has great potential, but you'll quickly notice some red flags as early as the first scene. The game does have potential, especially if you don't mind exaggerated proportions, which is more common in certain kinks like futanari. Personally, I prefer more normal proportions, but I don't mind it too much. The idea of a futa isekai, while not particularly original, is a good concept for a game, especially in an area lacking futa-on-male content. The character designs, while exaggerated, are mostly good as long as you don't mind that style. However, some characters look silly, especially Sinon and, most notably, Shuna. I understand wanting to include references to anime, and while Sinon kind of fits, Shuna feels out of place.
Here are the issues:
Within the first few minutes of this game, you might think it has great potential, but you'll quickly notice some red flags as early as the first scene. The game does have potential, especially if you don't mind exaggerated proportions, which is more common in certain kinks like futanari. Personally, I prefer more normal proportions, but I don't mind it too much. The idea of a futa isekai, while not particularly original, is a good concept for a game, especially in an area lacking futa-on-male content. The character designs, while exaggerated, are mostly good as long as you don't mind that style. However, some characters look silly, especially Sinon and, most notably, Shuna. I understand wanting to include references to anime, and while Sinon kind of fits, Shuna feels out of place.
Here are the issues:
- The scenes are too long. This is rarely an issue in most games, and when it is, it usually doesn't become a problem until much later when things start feeling too slow. Here, it feels too slow from the very first scene.
- The writing is unbelievably bad and repetitive. The game repeats the same things over and over in long, drawn-out scenes. "Men have so much mana, I'll choke you, I don't want to break you, blah blah blah." This kind of dialogue is repeated, sometimes multiple times within the same scene, seemingly to pad out the duration of these ridiculously long scenes. With shorter scenes, perhaps the writing could be improved.
- The scenes themselves are repetitive and lack variety. The animation and itself is not an issue. The characters all interact with you in very similar ways, using the same positions and exhibiting similar behavior and dialogue. There’s a lack of variety in all aspects, making the experience feel repetitive and monotonous.
- It's buggy. At one point, my screen flashed, and a character duplicated themselves, just as an example.
- The game lacks clear direction or a feeling of freedom. You just talk to people until something happens. You never feel like your choices have any weight or that you're actively navigating a story.
- The consequences for not paying rent are disappointing. I thought there might be an interesting scene if I didn't pay rent, but it just leads to a bad ending. There is a scene, but be sure to save before this if you want to see the scene.
- Repetitive sound design. The sound effects are decent, but they are repeated in every scene, which quickly becomes tiresome.
- Missed opportunities with guildmates. It would have been cool if you had the option to enter their rooms and even sleep with them, or choose to progress with them story-wise. Lyra is the only character who felt a little unique, and I wanted to enter her room and maybe sleep in the same bed to get some story or plot development. Instead, you just watch them sleep. Eventually, you join two other girls, who give you quests to steal from them, which gets you into their rooms.
- The main character is incredibly dumb and naive. Initially, I didn’t mind this, but how long is it going to take for him to stop being surprised by the situations he finds himself in? This ties into the overall issue of repetitive writing. The MC constantly reacts with the same lines like, "Oh no, I can't take it," "Why is this happening to me?" and "You're a demon." It would be nice to have some choices—perhaps the option for the MC to enjoy his time there, hate it, or something else. At the very least, the MC should start to show some actual development.