I was torn between a 4 and a 5 star rating.. I'd consider this game somewhere between a 4.2 and a 4.5 so I went with 4. Now for why.
This is just the first release, but there's a fair bit of content for a first release. Nothing is rushed just to get content in the first release either. On a technical level, there are only a few mild problems. There are typos here and there, a few things coded improperly and the animations are a bit stiff. Nothing bad, but it's not perfect so that's ultimately why I docked some points.
As for more subjective artistic notes, I enjoy the story. I don't even like football but the main character and his story is compelling. The only gripe I have with character personalities is that the sister is already coming on a bit strong. Not necessarily a bad thing, some may like it, but it's off-putting to me. I kinda like having to work for it, and she's already clearly into you. The models are also pretty good, though again, not perfect.
All in all, a great first release and I hope the dev can keep it up or even improve. GL Remveer I'll be watching this one with interest.