That's the route the guide told me to follow and it seemed to be going well until Eric came back to town and wanted nothing to do with Ashley. I was just skipping through seen dialog, so I couldn't figure out what happened there, I guess Ashley broke up with him at some point to start dating Eva. And I think Eva ends up dating the other black guy, Bubba, anyway, so it's back to square one... I'll try breaking up with Eric at the beginning to get back together later on and see how that goes. Man, trying to keep Eva away from black cocks is such a hassle :/Hmm... The other route to getting Eva in threesomes is to keep her pure, but pursue her as your girlfriend, assert your dominance, then open up the relationship. If you bring pure Eva to the orgy, she will eventually decide you can't be girlfriends anymore, but stay sex friends. The issue is I don't know if you can get that far with Eva without cutting Eric out of your life. I can't seem to recall.