VN - Ren'Py - Gothcuck [v0.6] [GC Studios]

This is a below average AI generated game. Here is why:

• The CGs are not good. Some proportions are off, there are missing fingers, anatomically incorrect poses, and other visual issues. Almost anyone with an average system can get better results using SD if used correctly.
  
  
• The story is weak. For an AI generated game, you would at least expect a solid narrative, but this one fails to deliver anything interesting. What you see is what you get, and what you get is below average.
  
  
• The paywall. Let’s break this down. The game has poor AI generated visuals, weak storytelling, no animations, and censorship. If you're creating an AI generated game and want clearly money for it, you should put in enough effort to make it stand out, whether through good gameplay, superb writing, or quality animations. Without that, the result is just a low effort product that almost anyone could create.

PS: I’m not against AI generated games. There are actually some great ones here. But people need to think logically. Today, almost anyone can produce AI generated content. If you're asking to be paid for it, you need to offer something that truly stands out. You're entering a space where others invest serious effort in writing, drawing, rendering, modeling, animating, programming, and more.


You know what I find really sad? When people give feedback like: "I like your art style"

i love this gothic girls. i m not looking for mini game but change town discover new milf like summertime saga or the twist
really nice! unless it s not a real game.....great art work, perfect style... if it was a game was 5 star for sure

well, for a game called "gothcuck", you get what you see, you can either like it or not but it is what it is, you are not expecting to get some shakespeare writing and that's fine. I liked the goth girl so i can say I enjoyed it.....if it wasn't for the paywall....

LISTEN, it's okay if you wanna monetize your game like this instead of giving people a little demo to try like everyone does, but it is INSANE to me that THE CENSORED VERSION of the game is behind this paywall.
I feel like a more inteligent way approach this would be having the censored version (+captions?) as the default option for every scene of the game, but having to buy the game to see the uncensored version. Censorship is often used in NTR anyways so its a win/win for everyone.

but yeah, as it is, the game is not worth your time, +1 star for big tiddy gf tho.

i played the game and i was impressed on the story aspect of the game taking things slow not like the developers other project , i just wish we had more architypes in the alphas that we encounter like a fat guy would be awesome in the future but again this game is promising at least i was also hoping for more content with the landlady and other MILFs in the future too vanilla and NTR side maybe we can participate hopefully so as of now its a 5 star until proven other wise , i hope the developers see this review and take some ideas into consideration

One of the better NTR games being actively developed. It is on the harsher side which I enjoy and has features that I like, like the censoring and captions that elevate the gameplay. Really enjoy the goth aesthetic as well and this does that swimmingly.

Great work, I hope you concentrate on one project at a time though.
there is nothing better than a thick girl cucking you, so I have great hopes for this one. Chastity would be nice.

I did not expecttheAI to be no issue for me, but it isn't . The animations are very nice aswell.

Inconsistent AI images.
The Characters look different each time. The Art itself is also mediocre, even for AI.
Characters are not outright ugly but look very fake. AI includes a lot of messy details.

The writing is aweful.

Without Patreon membership you will see only around 10% of the content. It's a PAID only game.

Development is slow, the story is generic.

I like the topic and the genre, but everything else is trash. I can't recommend this game at all.

I'll update this Review later down the line, if I'm up for it and the Patreon version gets uploaded.

As an NTR fan, this is bottom of the barrel type stuff. Literally everything is low-effort...even the ai cg is low effort, but i've seen worse so I guess that's about the only thing this game has going for itself. Not to mention many of the images are pay-walled so you can't see some of them unless you wanna pay *laughs*

Basically what we have here is someone trying to get a quick buck with next to zero effort cause milking the NTR genre is easy money.

I would give this game zero stars if I could. Its that bad.

I normally avoid AI games because, like this one, they're pretty much all extremely lazy. But I decided to give this a try because big titty goth gfs are my weakness (yes even if they're NTRing you.) Man was that a mistake.

The writing is absolutely atrocious, I'm pretty sure most of that is AI too. There isn't really any semblance of a logical story, it just seems thrown together to shove the shitty AI "art" at you.

Speaking of the AI images: they are incredibly lazy. I caught MULTIPLE instances of really obvious mistakes like inconsistencies in the character's looks, body parts being the wrong color or just having random splotches on them, and of course missing/extra fingers. All of this is stuff that someone who knows what they're doing with AI COULD fix with some time and inpainting, but of course this dev is just trying to make money for the least effort possible, so they just left in all the mistakes. You can literally even see some of them in the preview images!

Then there's the paywall for all the actual "content." This is honestly embarrassing.

Gothcuck [v0.3]

This is a demo that serves as a gateway to the Patreon site. In fact, no choices are possible, and all potential views are inaccessible. It may have potential, but for the moment, nothing is kept.

The version posted here Is for all intents and purposes unplayable. There are no scenes, and most options are just links to their patreon. I am sure there Is a game If you and pay for It but don't bother installing whatever it is from here.

Incredible lack of content that is honestly really disappointing. If you're interested in the idea i'd stick to captions and videos. Game doesnt do enough to warrant a download in my opinion, the short length might make it seem worth a punt but it's still a waste of time at the end of the day

This game has a good story with a pretty linear path so far. There is no real content in the game yet, so I would say it's not worth playing in its current state. Can't tell if this is ai or some ones art either way it looks great regardless. By the way LAME ASS PAYWALL!

I liked it, it has potential, I liked the characters, especially MC's mother, I really like the NTR + BBC content, I just didn't like that there is no content at all, the game is very light, it's not even 100 MB, no sex scenes, but just seeing the art makes me anxious for more.

This is still just a little more than a simple proof of concept, but it is very promising. The writing so far is nice and leaves you wanting more of this game, images are very nice for being all AI and the potential route for the protag promises a lot of hot stuff if you're into a dominant and very rough waifu. Will follow the development closely!

There is not much content present at the moment. To call this release even a demo would be very generous. With such little content to include a premium choice was certainly a decision that is questionable.

There's not a single sex scene available in the posted game here also the issue with it saying virus when downloading which isnt a big issue as some games do say that. However the biggest issue is 2/3 of the choices you cant make unless you pay for them and their tiered so to make the 1/3 of the choices you have to pay 7.50$ and to get all the choices you have to pay 13.50$ which is insane most x rated games you can buy completed versions of for that price.

Well, what to say... There's close to no content, and yet... there's already a paywall.

I won't dive further into that, as I believe there's no need for further explanation why a paywall in a project this early into development is bad.

The game's writing is mediocre. It's not bad, but it ain't good either. The story, or the skelleton of it, fails to pull your interest at its starting point, making everything else just... bland.

The art, even though it's AI, is decent still... probably edited in PS/Krita, which is the path anyone using AI art should take. I won't give out any extra points to that though, since I also dabble in AI art, and know that once you have a decent understanding of the UI you're using (such as Auto1111, ComfyUI, etc) it doesn't take much effort to get results at this level. Heck, I can even guess the model that was used here.

The characters introduced thus far are ok, if a bit bland. Nothing really good, nothing really bad. I'd give 2.5 stars, maybe even 3 stars for the characters alone.

But then, I look again at the current amount of content, and the presence of a paywall...

Nah.

Cannot recommend playing this.

GCNDev built a very promising setting with GOTHCUCK. I enjoyed the story greatly so far, and I couldn't be happier about the kind of style he chose for the drawings. If you're into thicc goth chicks, and airhead bimbo sluts, you'll love the game.
I specially liked the way Blair—the main girl—is written, she emanates some kind of aura of mystery and cruelty, and I'm eager to get to know her character. And all the buildup GCNDev is creating will only make the NTR hit harder, when it finally happens.
This version works as an introduction of the setting and characters, and does a great job establishing a solid foundation for the next updates.

Everything is locked behind a paywall. Look, I get making money as a dev. That's fine. But not only is all choices locked behind a paywall each choice is locked behind a different paywall! So, if you want to go back and make a different choice guess what bucko you gotta fork over some more cash. And this isn't even original artwork or background + it's the very first update with barely any content yet you're expected to pay $7.50 to be able to make premium choices and then another $13.50 if you want to access to ultimate choices. And do these choices you're paying a premium to be able to make have any major impact on the game? Don't know didn't spend $21 to find out. For the story itself it's run of the mill. Premise is good (I like NTR and interracial) and I didn't notice any glaring grammar issues but I'm probably not going to continue playing or give money in the future. At least for now. With this sort of model if you really want to play this game I'd wait to see if the dev completes it and then buying it otherwise you're going to be spending a lot of money per month for this.