Wow stumbled upon this one later than most it seems and it was way more than I was expecting. Got to be the longest "adult" game I have ever seen from start to finish of current content. I'd say my review lands a bit more like 4.5/5 stars. I hate to pick 4 given how that works out percentage wise, but I don't think perfection really exists, so I can't do 5.
Pros:
Story: The underlying story is actually really good, even though it often has to force in somewhat absurd lewd tie ins to keep with the overall genre. Still the underlying elements are great, and honestly was just wanting more of it.
Girls: There is definitely a great attempt at catering to all physical types. I appreciate that even some of the curvier girls (such as Sarah and Lethe) still have small areolas. That's pretty rare (both IRL and in games). Usually they're all setup more like Leah. Personally Scarlet is my favourite (physically she is literally my perfect type, 100% perfection), followed by Zero, Fang, Sarah, Lethe, and Lyra. Alice is pretty good too. Yuki is okay (not a fan of brown nipples and such), and Nyx would be except she has really just weird looking nipples. The rest I have like zero interest in personally... anyways...
Cons:
Bondage bondage bondage...: I can tell the creators have a definite direction here and I can't knock them for catering to it, but I personally don't really care for it much. ESPECIALLY the feet/tickling/spanking stuff. I have to say though, even if you are into bondage like a mofo, it has to get pretty old. I mean literally almost every scene involves at least being tied up, and gagged, and probably spanking. Personally I like the exhibitionist stuff, but the only girl who seems to do that ever (and it's still very rare, especially without also being tied up) is Sonya, and I don't really find her attractive (too muscular, and her face/hair is yeah...). This pretty much is going to also tie into my next thing:
Lots of girls with more adding constantly: This is still a pro for the reasons I mentioned, but the problem is that the ones I have no interest in (and others would feel the same about others) end up snaking their ways into the ones I do have interest in. I'd really suggest calling it good here for the future. I'm pretty sure you have covered just about every base here...
Suggestions:
Branch out to more interests beyond bondage: It's cool if you're into that, but man I'd kill for a scene where Scarlet does more exhibitionist stuff (aka public things), especially without needing to be tied up. Give me a proper public scene with her and one or more of the girls I'm interested in, and I'd hit Patreon sub for the first time ever in a game. There are some light examples of public stuff here beyond Sonya, and somewhat even without bondage, but it's very underutilised. Would be great if there was an option for the guests to directly get involved with them there too. Even beyond that, there are a lot more things you could cater to for keeping it interesting. I mean Bukkake is sorta out, as well is multiple males, due to the story's situation of how males can't stay there for long, but there are still some male guests and such that could get involved. I know "sharing" type stuff really grinds some people's gears but it could easily be optional. Also, there were a couple instances of lewd writing on girls, but was barely a thing. Honestly this just seems like more than anything something that would just fit right in for punishments/humiliation etc. Could easily make more use of that. Just would be nice to have some more variance in general. I mean how many variations of tied up, gagged, spanking, tickling etc. can you even do. It gets old, and often a bit frustrating. I mean this in the nicest way possible, and I respect the direction, but still...
Sound and music: I dunno what all is planned for the final version but would it be hard to add some sex sounds? Pretty sure there are quite a few open source options out there that would go a long way to improving the scenes. Additionally, the music (which is fine), gets to be pretty much the type of thing you can hear in your damn dreams after you play this game from start to finish over a few days. Hopefully you can manage to snag at least a few more tracks to make it a little less tiresome. It's an extremely long game so hearing like 5 music tracks over like 30 hours or something of play gets pretty draining.
Story amount/Main quest: At the end of the day this is an "adult" game so I'm not going to suggest we cut out the porn, but honestly once you play it for this long, and with how interesting the story actually is, it would be nice to have like less porn... It feels quite forced at times. Like "Oh man we went 5 minutes worth of dialogue without putting in a lewd scene, gotta jam one in here somehow." I don't feel like the "side" quests and "main quest" segmenting really coherently works consistently either. A lot of side stuff feels like main stuff, and vice versa. Kinda wish the "main" tagged quests were really just straight up story (even though some lewd is basically a part of the story itself), and the side stuff was really just always the lewd scenes with the girls involved. It's not far from that being a thing, but could be a little better segmented there. I mean at this point it's so long that I don't expect much going backwards, but it's something to consider.
Customisations: Not really sure how to word this, but if there was a way to make scenes and things a little more choice based it would be nice. Maybe I have the option to choose their outfit for X scene, maybe I have the option to not gag them/tie them up, maybe I have the option of what hole to take etc. There are occasional glimpses of this, but not really anything fully materialised. I can see how that would be a large undertaking in some ways though, so it's a loose suggestion where feasibility/ease of doing exists.
Overall this is quite the game, and I hope I don't come off too negative. I was very surprised by its length, and quality. This is actually the first time I have even left a review, and I've played a lot of games from here. It's quite a gem that has been a long time running, and it only needs a few things really take it to another level. I could mention the grammar mistakes (which somewhat understandably got more frequent later on), but I mean it's so dang long I cannot even really fully fault that. Only in some of the last parts was it actually frequent and bad enough that I noticed, or sort of had to guess what the actual intended sentence was. Really though, it's an awesome game, and I greatly appreciate the effort that went into its undertaking. Despite some of my problems with it, it has become one of my favourite games here of all time.
Pros:
Story: The underlying story is actually really good, even though it often has to force in somewhat absurd lewd tie ins to keep with the overall genre. Still the underlying elements are great, and honestly was just wanting more of it.
Girls: There is definitely a great attempt at catering to all physical types. I appreciate that even some of the curvier girls (such as Sarah and Lethe) still have small areolas. That's pretty rare (both IRL and in games). Usually they're all setup more like Leah. Personally Scarlet is my favourite (physically she is literally my perfect type, 100% perfection), followed by Zero, Fang, Sarah, Lethe, and Lyra. Alice is pretty good too. Yuki is okay (not a fan of brown nipples and such), and Nyx would be except she has really just weird looking nipples. The rest I have like zero interest in personally... anyways...
Cons:
Bondage bondage bondage...: I can tell the creators have a definite direction here and I can't knock them for catering to it, but I personally don't really care for it much. ESPECIALLY the feet/tickling/spanking stuff. I have to say though, even if you are into bondage like a mofo, it has to get pretty old. I mean literally almost every scene involves at least being tied up, and gagged, and probably spanking. Personally I like the exhibitionist stuff, but the only girl who seems to do that ever (and it's still very rare, especially without also being tied up) is Sonya, and I don't really find her attractive (too muscular, and her face/hair is yeah...). This pretty much is going to also tie into my next thing:
Lots of girls with more adding constantly: This is still a pro for the reasons I mentioned, but the problem is that the ones I have no interest in (and others would feel the same about others) end up snaking their ways into the ones I do have interest in. I'd really suggest calling it good here for the future. I'm pretty sure you have covered just about every base here...
Suggestions:
Branch out to more interests beyond bondage: It's cool if you're into that, but man I'd kill for a scene where Scarlet does more exhibitionist stuff (aka public things), especially without needing to be tied up. Give me a proper public scene with her and one or more of the girls I'm interested in, and I'd hit Patreon sub for the first time ever in a game. There are some light examples of public stuff here beyond Sonya, and somewhat even without bondage, but it's very underutilised. Would be great if there was an option for the guests to directly get involved with them there too. Even beyond that, there are a lot more things you could cater to for keeping it interesting. I mean Bukkake is sorta out, as well is multiple males, due to the story's situation of how males can't stay there for long, but there are still some male guests and such that could get involved. I know "sharing" type stuff really grinds some people's gears but it could easily be optional. Also, there were a couple instances of lewd writing on girls, but was barely a thing. Honestly this just seems like more than anything something that would just fit right in for punishments/humiliation etc. Could easily make more use of that. Just would be nice to have some more variance in general. I mean how many variations of tied up, gagged, spanking, tickling etc. can you even do. It gets old, and often a bit frustrating. I mean this in the nicest way possible, and I respect the direction, but still...
Sound and music: I dunno what all is planned for the final version but would it be hard to add some sex sounds? Pretty sure there are quite a few open source options out there that would go a long way to improving the scenes. Additionally, the music (which is fine), gets to be pretty much the type of thing you can hear in your damn dreams after you play this game from start to finish over a few days. Hopefully you can manage to snag at least a few more tracks to make it a little less tiresome. It's an extremely long game so hearing like 5 music tracks over like 30 hours or something of play gets pretty draining.
Story amount/Main quest: At the end of the day this is an "adult" game so I'm not going to suggest we cut out the porn, but honestly once you play it for this long, and with how interesting the story actually is, it would be nice to have like less porn... It feels quite forced at times. Like "Oh man we went 5 minutes worth of dialogue without putting in a lewd scene, gotta jam one in here somehow." I don't feel like the "side" quests and "main quest" segmenting really coherently works consistently either. A lot of side stuff feels like main stuff, and vice versa. Kinda wish the "main" tagged quests were really just straight up story (even though some lewd is basically a part of the story itself), and the side stuff was really just always the lewd scenes with the girls involved. It's not far from that being a thing, but could be a little better segmented there. I mean at this point it's so long that I don't expect much going backwards, but it's something to consider.
Customisations: Not really sure how to word this, but if there was a way to make scenes and things a little more choice based it would be nice. Maybe I have the option to choose their outfit for X scene, maybe I have the option to not gag them/tie them up, maybe I have the option of what hole to take etc. There are occasional glimpses of this, but not really anything fully materialised. I can see how that would be a large undertaking in some ways though, so it's a loose suggestion where feasibility/ease of doing exists.
Overall this is quite the game, and I hope I don't come off too negative. I was very surprised by its length, and quality. This is actually the first time I have even left a review, and I've played a lot of games from here. It's quite a gem that has been a long time running, and it only needs a few things really take it to another level. I could mention the grammar mistakes (which somewhat understandably got more frequent later on), but I mean it's so dang long I cannot even really fully fault that. Only in some of the last parts was it actually frequent and bad enough that I noticed, or sort of had to guess what the actual intended sentence was. Really though, it's an awesome game, and I greatly appreciate the effort that went into its undertaking. Despite some of my problems with it, it has become one of my favourite games here of all time.