I would love to give this game a higher rating, I really would! There are a bunch of positives. The girls are all really cute and unique. The renders are usually really nice, although I'm not such a huge fan of trying to blend CG models with real life backdrops, which does occur in some outdoor scenes. The writing is very competent, with proper English.
Just based on the girls alone I would give this game 4.5 out of 5, but... there are 2 major things that drag this game down for me. First, and the less egregious of the issues, is the pacing of the story. There doesn't seem to be much plot, its more of a slice of life, character driven story, which is totally fine, if done well. Here it is not done well, as some scenes just drag on and on and on with useless extra dialog. Some newer updates have "stuff" happen during the day, which technically advances time, but it all feels mostly like filler. So the feeling of nothing really happening kinda hurts my desire to keep playing and seeing new updates.
My 2nd issue with the game however is what ultimately made me stop playing, and that was the MC. I get that people will say it's unrealistic that all these girls will like him and such cause he ugly and whatnot, and I understand that, but at the same time, it's a game, it's not so hard to take that. What I can't take is just how annoyingly insufferable the MC is. He drones on endlessly about everything and anything over and over and over. I get that this is connected to my first issue with the fact that there's a lot of filler, but the MC is just so dumb and naive. I get he was in juvy, but I can't read all the bullshit he just keeps saying, and I end up skipping most of it. If I'm skipping most of what the MC is saying, it's not worth playing.
Early in this games development I supported the dev for a few updates. I liked the girls, I liked the renders and I was hopeful that as the MC was exposed to life events outside juvy he would get a little more bearable, more reasonable. Unfortunately that didn't happen. There are good reasons to play this game, it has qualities that many people will like. For me though, I sadly have to stop trying to play this.