After giving it some thought & due to the interactions with the Dev I have decided to rate this game even though it isn't finished yet, and from what I have seen might not be too close to getting finished as well.
Keep in mind, please, that this review might change further down the road and also that I am writing this partially because I agree with the Dev that the early reviews of the game actually pull down the score, even though they don't really refer to what the game is at this point in time (build 16 with fix). The Dev also is very open to discussion & tries to make it so that the game can be enjoyed by different people, even some as "intolerant" (I plain out refuse to even click through content that I deeply dislike, no matter if 99% of the rest would be to my liking) and picky as myself.
Therefore I have decided to give this game a rating right now instead of closer to/after the finish, and just to be upfront I fully intend to give this game a good rating to help a little. That doesn't mean though that I will give it a free pass or just throw 5 stars as it.
All this being said, let me actually get into the rating and why I think 4 stars are well deserved here:
The first thing I enjoyed was the fact that the game does not start with an overly dramatic, depressing intro or some forced sex stuff, despite the premise (your character ended up as a slave) could have easily invited such a thing. Instead it serves as a small glimpse at the setting, before swiftly transporting the protagonist into the actual game world, which is (overly simplified) a Port Royal but with a lot less dirt and gore, some fantasy elements and, of course, lots of openly displayed sexuality.
At it's core the game is a sandbox where the player navigates the protagonist around a cast of colourful characters and into basically whatever lewd situation they wanna explore.
There is a bit of a story (or, rather, progress for the protagonist in regards to how many of the islands they can visit, which things they are allowed to do etc.) but it's never forcing the player to follow it. I don't recommend it but in theory one could just stick to the starting zone (first port, basically a refugee, very limited interaction with the other characters) and it would probably be an okay experience for about half to an hour, depending on how fast one reads.
I've been surprised by the amount of additional content that gets unlocked by actually going through the drill and making the protagonist become a useful member of the little island society, leading to far more and higher quality lewd scenes, as well as some more intricate relationship stuff with some of the more important npcs.
To me it is important to at least have some option to advance in the game without being forced to go through lewd scenes I dislike, so I can only emphasize how great it is that the Dev is keeping an eye on that and try to make it so that there are no "hard locks" tied to those things, meaning that one might miss out on (quite) a bunch of specific content and story lines by sticking to 1 thing, but not end up being unable to finish the game.
This is obviously an active process, so there will be moments between builds that will not yet have alternative scenes to progress, but they come in time.
Visually the game isn't groundbreaking, but it is appealing. The writing is pretty good, without apparent, general flaws & also overall pretty free of spelling or grammar mistakes, as far as I can tell.
I am looking forward to see where the game goes & really excited for the (probably next) release that will address the current lack of an alternative to unlock the rest of the isles.
If you like pirate stuff, a solid mix of soft and a bit harder BDSM, Futas, temporal Transformations & like reading a bit instead of having only visuals I highly recommend you give this game a chance, and maybe leave a review if you had a good time with it. If you enjoy M/F scenes this has even more to offer, and more paths to take, so I do recommend to give it a try for sure.