This is a polarizing game. It was one of the first long ones I played, kind of a gateway into other AVNs, and the first one that actually turned me on consistently, but playing the most recent update after many years with many other games under my belt, it's time for the hindsight to kick in.
There's lots of potential, and thus lots of wasted potential. But the content is solid and there's many good things to say. I almost gave it a 4 but there are much better games I've given 4s to and I couldn't put it on that level, but if I could it would get a 3.5/5 overall
tldr:
+ choices are realistic and appropriately impactful
+ characters are diverse and consistently different
+ dialogue in both plot and sex is stellar (best aspect)
+ great pacing and ratio of story/sex scenes
- renders are mostly lazy
- animations are jarringly awful and used seemingly at random
- locked-in growth fetish would be fine but teases being reversible and just isn't
Gameplay: 4/5
Standard click-through-the-dialogue interrupted by occasional choices. Choices are actually pretty meaningful for the most part and lead to alternate content which is appreciated. Even more appreciated is that making one choice, whether it's between girls or between how to treat one, doesn't necessarily lock you out of revisiting the option(s) later. This is a double edged sword that is realistic (people change their minds) and lets the player try seeing the other side of the coin in the same playthrough, but at the same time it also means many choices feel less impactful at times where maybe they should have been more important. But overall, it's a chill vibe that matches the chill choice system. Even imagining how to keep all the branches on the same tree hurts my brain so I don't think I could do better.
Sex: 2.5/5
This one is the most heartbreaking because if the sex scenes were done better the game would immediately go from just above average to top marks despite any other complaints I might have, but instead holds it back from being one of my favorites.
The setup and execution of how we get to sex scenes is really hot. There's a lot of variety not just in the girls you can fuck but also the scenarios themselves. The dialogue is done really well and doesn't overdo it... mostly. Sometimes the girls match the MCs wittiness a little too closely to where their back and forths are hard to differentiate. Other than that it might actually be the most realistic sex dialogue as characters are consistent and while they say hot porny shit they are self aware of being corny and don't break character to do it.
But that's where my praise ends because everything when it comes to visuals and pacing is atrocious. When animations play it's the box standard positions for the engine, and when they don't play, while some position renders are good, the models are lazily used and the faces aren't even touched, so everyone has the same default pained face. The hottest scenes are the ones where the sex is mostly implied and the dialogue is the focus.
Even weirder is the pacing of the sex scenes. There are animations, especially early on (it did improve...slightly over time), that abruptly end halfway. There is no attempt at making the cumshots work in any way. When they are animated they feel rushed and without the dialogue in a lot of them you wouldn't be able to tell where a sex scene begins or ends. It's actually bizarre and no game since has made me feel this way, even much worse ones.
As for the girls themselves... I dunno. The designs have their moments with each girl's distinct look having its own charm but they aren't really used to good potential and the game goes all in on the oversized butts and boobs fetish which is fine but it also pretends to have options that let you stop this but NEVER FOLLOWS THROUGH. Multiple choices pretend to give you the option to stop their growing but without it some of the later plot would have holes so instead you have to watch hot models eventually grow into unlovable blobs (preference I guess) whose only redeeming feature is that the scene writing is still hot and there are enough side characters with better proportions.
Plot: 4/5
This is the most slice-of-lifey slice of life game there is, but is much less... Japanese about it. Sorry, I'm as weeby as the next guy, but it's just kind of refreshing when characters make decisions and say how they feel without tripping over themselves 8000 times in the process. Characters can be shy without being utterly mute and impossibly introverted. Characters can be sassy without being Tsundere. Characters can DO MORE THAN ONE THING. In a genre dominated by the same ol' anime harems, it's nice to see some characters with confidence who don't fall precisely into cookie cutter stereotypes.
When it comes to the actual story, it's hard to really fault something that barely exists. The stopwatch is an excuse for the harem to start for an MC who, while charming and clever, isn't particularily special. I actually like the MC a lot more than most AVNs. He never felt overdone. He spoke often enough to feel like a real character but not so often that you're taken out of his perspective. He reacts reasonably based on your choices and the progression of events. He isn't too big a bitch or too big a bully and it makes sense why the girls like him.
As for the progression of events, one scene just sort of leads to the next and the consequences of the stopwatch are appropriate even if it's probably the most annoying aspect of the plot. See, even though I'm not into the giant boobs and butt fetish, it would be fine if the game didn't keep reminding me that I should be able to fix it at any time with the fucking watch. It's just the big red flag where the MC and I don't agree at all. He's nonchalant about letting them become bad hentai proportions, where I would not be. I only fault it that as a preference.
Other than that the pace is good because it's always looking to setup the next sex scene. There are plenty of conflicts and drama of all scales and the characters are pretty good about how they react and adapt, but the plot does just sort of meander about which is probably why it takes so long to get to any major choices.
And that's fine. it just wants you to be along for the ride. I like the chill vibes, the harem with enough guilt to justify it, but not so much that you don't get all the sex you want without it feeling silly by the end. Most importantly though, I LOVE the fact that the dev doesn't cop out by adding more magical bullshit and universe shattering interdimensional plots that every other dev resorts to the moment they run out of real human stories to tell. Take notes people, you don't need fairies and elves to come out of portals or have someone reveal that you're part of a family of wizards or assassins in order to tell a complete story.
A single, magical watch is just fine. And so is the game. Wouldn't put it in my list of best ones, but would definitely recommend it.