Identify I can't find game, please check description.

[Momentum624]

It was an old web game where you wake up on an island inhabited by furry girls. If I remember, it had a rough looking art style, animations and had barely any content. I remember there being a squirrel girl, shark girl, cow girl(?), and a bunny girl. I remember there being a hotel your area and a fishing dock area. You went from place to place by clicking on different areas from the overworld map and would find specific characters by doing so. I remember being able to help the squirrel girl gather nuts or fruit from a tree, and I think you could swim or fish with the shark girl. I remember there being a scene with the shark girl where she would bite your dick off if you attempted a blowjob. The game was, or at least, had dating Sim elements.

I remember this game from forever ago, and it keeps randomly popping into my mind and it's driving me insane, so i gave as much information as I could remember. I avoided giving every little detail so this wouldn't be a huge wall of text, but if you need it, please say so and I'll share them.

 

[Penumbral Evanescence]

Did you try filtering by the following tags? You can try inputting other tags/filters as well to help narrow down your search.



I found these two links/threads, but I doubt it was what you had in mind.

https://f95zone.to/threads/sexy-sharks-final-artoonu.132840/ -> This one just had sharks in it.

You must be registered to see the links

If you can provide more details, I can try and see what more I can dig up on my end.

 

[vinnaryGames]

It was an old web game where you wake up on an island inhabited by furry girls. If I remember, it had a rough looking art style, animations and had barely any content. I remember there being a squirrel girl, shark girl, cow girl(?), and a bunny girl. I remember there being a hotel your area and a fishing dock area. You went from place to place by clicking on different areas from the overworld map and would find specific characters by doing so. I remember being able to help the squirrel girl gather nuts or fruit from a tree, and I think you could swim or fish with the shark girl. I remember there being a scene with the shark girl where she would bite your dick off if you attempted a blowjob. The game was, or at least, had dating Sim elements.

I remember this game from forever ago, and it keeps randomly popping into my mind and it's driving me insane, so i gave as much information as I could remember. I avoided giving every little detail so this wouldn't be a huge wall of text, but if you need it, please say so and I'll share them.

This may be a shot in the dark, but it might've been a very early build of monster girl island?
I remember that one of the first builds started you out at the beach, where there was a pier and a shark girl. You had to collect some coconuts from a tree, as well as a few crabs on the beach (I think you could also fish there), eventually leading to a scene. Shortly after, the prototype added a bunny girl with a scene after the beach in another location. There was one more character that I can barely recall, as well as another monster girl that could be seen in the distance near a cave entrance when you walked all the way to the left of the beach, however it was unreachable.

The game has drastically changed ever since then, which might be why you can't find it anymore.
Check the attached screenshot to see if it rings any bells~

//Edit:

You must be registered to see the links

is said beach from the early prototype, in a much newer release.

 

[Momentum624]

The game was 2d. For the squirrel girl, there was a seen where you could see up her skirt when you help her gather stuff from a tree. The cow girl worked at the hotel, you would stay in the squirrel girl's house, the game started with you being woken up by the squirrel girl and she yells you that you were found by the shark girl. When you could fish with the shark girl, there was an animation of her jumping into the water and taking out a large fish while you were sitting on the boat. In the hotel, you could click on specific doors to get to your room after you managed to save enough money to buy one. There was a money system, but it was barely used for anything at all. The might've been a manager character for the cow girl. The bunny girl had black fur, the squirrel girl had brown, shark girl was a shark, and the cow girl was white and brown.

It's literally impossible for me to remember the names of any characters. I played this like 6 or so years ago. It was on a random porn game site. I don't know how I forgot to mention it was 2d.