Version Played: v0.055, Downloaded here
Characters: Star of the show for this game. There is a nice variety between them, and it's been genuinely enjoyable seeing their stories unfold. Different Races, different people, different walks of life - and they all seem well rounded. We're discovering a lot from their backstories as time goes on, the biggest issue is lack of content for all the characters - but that's what happens when you're playing games released like this, it takes time to fill out everyone.
Graphics: If I can mark it down anywhere, I guess it's here. It's not bad by any means, I think the art is charming - but there is perhaps a lack of fidelity compared to some games. Whether that bothers you is your own cup of tea. I would go for a solid 4/5 on Art - but importantly, all the characters are distinct, no one looks too much like anyone else. Also, I'd like to add that the Dev is actually redoing a lot of stuff about art - and they are improving as we go on, which is always great to see.
Story and Writing: Writing falls in a couple of places - the biggest place that feels rushed/out of place is giving Alice the futa potion, I definitely felt like that should have had more build up/protest, it went over... very easy. Other bits are fantastic, pacing of people opening up is very well done for instance. To compare 2 characters, Alice takes a little to pry open, then once she starts to confide in you she's pretty open, and doesn't protest much when you try to help her. Sacha is very closed off, and takes time to pry and let her stew at every turn so far. You have to keep trying each step, where Alice only needs that for the first part.
The Sex: My main complaint is lacking in scenes, but that will be resolved as time goes on. We've got variety, we've got sweetness, and we've got plenty of horny. You get speed control, and a completion button - the writing in them is good as well.
Gameplay: A few people have complained about the Sandbox, but I'm a sucker for them. I usually prefer a sandbox game over a linear adventure - at least when they're done well. And this one is so far. There's development of skills and earning of money needed - and it's already well balanced, I don't feel you ever have to grind up too long. Some games I've felt the need to cheat to get through the story and content in a timely manner, I feel this one gets it right. The hint system is great too, barely needed, but nice and informative if you ever do want to use it.
Closing Notes and Thoughts: This is a game that strikes many of my fancies - fantasy world, monster girls, futa, non futa, size difference, and even the premise of running and inn is a personal favourite. So, I might be biased, but it's a 5 star rating from me. Pulling back on my biases a bit, maybe a 4 star generally - and of course if you don't like sandboxes, it'll probably feel more like a drag than a well paced experience.
tl;dr: cute girls, good pacing, go play it now
Edit: updated graphics section