Is it Patreon friendly ?

[MrJak]

Hi there,

Got a question.
Let's imagine I'm creating a Ren'py harem-like game, which take place in a medieval-fantasy world.
What if hypothetically some of my characters have some resemblance to let's say... actresses.

Do you think I might get banned?

I share some visuals to give you an idea

Thanks for taking the time to answer.

 

[Thicc Lord]

In short, it’s a fine line you’re on. You could add a line that says “All characters are fictional, any resemblance to real people is purely coincidental” or something of that effect.

I would recommend you read the Community Guidelines.

You must be registered to see the links

However, plenty of creators already do this - so it really depends on how “obvious” it is and how much attention you’re going to garner.

 

[MrJak]

Thanks for you answer.

The line “All characters are fictional, any resemblance to real people is purely coincidental” was going to be put in the beginning of the game for sure.

I should have think to look at their guidelines, my bad.

In short, it’s a fine line you’re on. You could add a line that says “All characters are fictional, any resemblance to real people is purely coincidental” or something of that effect.

I would recommend you read the Community Guidelines.

You must be registered to see the links

However, plenty of creators already do this - so it really depends on how “obvious” it is and how much attention you’re going to garner.

 

[Thicc Lord]

Thanks for you answer.

The line “All characters are fictional, any resemblance to real people is purely coincidental” was going to be put in the beginning of the game for sure.

I should have think to look at their guidelines, my bad.

It’s all good, just make sure to read them real close. Last thing you want is for your Patreon to be shut down.

 

[ChaosOpen]

That being said, you are playing with fire. Even if you put "all characters are fictional" these things are judged based on what a reasonable person would conclude, and it would be clear to the judge that the resemblance to so many famous A list actresses is no mere coincidence and they could potentially sue you for damages. If you're that concerned, I suggest you see a lawyer, show him your game and ask for his advice.

*I am not a lawyer and this is not legal advice

 

[Meaning Less]

Fanart is not illegal... There are games not only making use of real life celebrities but even using them in the setting of a copyrighted story like Whores of Thrones (Game of thrones), clearly it isn't an issue for

You must be registered to see the links

either.

 

[MrJak]

Didn't know this game.

I'm less worried now hahaha.

Thanks

 

[JarheadGames]

I could be wrong but I think copyright only sets in when you SELL the game. If you use patreon, you're not selling the game. It's the legal equivalant of a friend giving you 10 bucks to support your hobby of drawing, not to actually buy a peice of art. If that makes sense.

 

[Count Morado]

I could be wrong

You're right. You're wrong. Copyright infringement occurs in the creation, not the compensation. The difference is personal use vs. communal use.

Whether on Patreon or just a buddy giving you 10 bucks to support your hobby - both are consider communal and compensatory.

The question for someone to consider is to what level they wish to pursue someone infringing on their intellectual property is mitigated by how much $$$ they can get from the offender in a civil case, however. It wouldn't stop them from sending a Cease and Desist to the infringer, as well as to any platform hosting that infringer's content. Patreon would heed a Cease and Desist, FYI.

Also, you're replying to a thread that is over a year old.