VN - Ren'Py - Island Sun [v0.1] [cptkrabs/CaraCara]

i like the niche (way too underrepresented on this site... (not even tags for it...)
and it really makes me angry how there is a loud group who only consumes mainstream porn games who critize it which is unfair.

pros:
+ i like the fmc she os curvy, tall and sexy looking
+ old/ugly man niche which should be much more focused on in my opinion
+ ntr/cheating
+ a bit of story/character for characters in the game is a good choice and could be built out a bit further

Cons:
- render quality still too "grainy"
- not that much of content
- scared the creator of the game will bow to the loud guys and make too much other content like lesbo/younger man etc

if the game gets a bit more time and polish and expanded further in its main niches (ntr/cheating, old/ugly men) with this sexy fmc it will be interesting - her character needs to be built out a tiny bit more and i see a game with potential!

The game feels like a solid effort for a first game.

Renders could be less noisy and a little more polished, for sure, but far from being the worst out there.

The dev appears to be french—even the default language setting upon startup—which shows in some odd word choices, but the writing is ok for a v0.1. Though I would suggest using some AI would help, at least to point out unusual parts and make dialogue flow more naturally especially around choices.

The story seems typical for a fem-protag game with focus on her corruption and newly found desires, while leaving the obligatory husband somewhere between ignorant/naive and probably actively cucked later down the line.

Frequency of choices feels good. Impact of choices so far rather short-term coming down to:
A) Subscene with someone; often followed by additional choices on whether to go further or not.
B) Don't engage

---
Altogether not a "triple-A"-gem in its current state, but a solid effort by a dev learning the ropes, which is something I appreciate.
Looking forward to its further development and improvement

I just can't...sigh...this "game" is in a league of its own for how bad it is.
Bad story, bad renders (grainy, dull, low quality), poor story and just completely ridiculous that someone would post this and expect any good review. The only good thing is the model, but thats it, the renders are so bad that you can break out your VHS and feel thats HD by comparison...