Lets normalize decent dongs in games

[KindnessPrevails]

This might be controversial but is it just me or is the dongs of MC's increasing year by year?

I have yet to find a decent game where the MC's dong isnt overshadowing the Eiffel tower, this just seems really unhealthy long-term wise. Of course dev's should be allowed to make their MC's dongs look like the next major building project in Dubai., but i think the NSFW game market would profit off some non-herculian dong.

What are your opinion on this?

 

[GNVE]

Since it's porn I doubt you'll get many games with true realistic dicks. I think most games will go with the dick on the larger side of things as does regular porn. I agree with you and dislike the arm-sized dicks some games use. I do think there are a lot of games that use the more realistic but still big dick.
Part of the trouble is that big dicks are so common in the imagery that regular sized dicks look small.

for reference I did a render that conforms to 90% of men (between 10cm & 16cm with an average of 13.1cm)


for my own game I settled on 20cm (since its a bit of a stupid big dick fantasy) but it doesn't look as enormous as it should (99th percentile).

 

[KindnessPrevails]

Since it's porn I doubt you'll get many games with true realistic dicks. I think most games will go with the dick on the larger side of things as does regular porn. I agree with you and dislike the arm-sized dicks some games use. I do think there are a lot of games that use the more realistic but still big dick.
Part of the trouble is that big dicks are so common in the imagery that regular sized dicks look small.

for reference I did a render that conforms to 90% of men (between 10cm & 16cm with an average of 13.1cm)
View attachment 3044134

for my own game I settled on 20cm (since its a bit of a stupid big dick fantasy) but it doesn't look as enormous as it should (99th percentile).
View attachment 3044139

I get that, its probably easier when it comes to modeling aswell. (Bigdick fantasty games aside) i think its healthier to just use a regular size, it adds to realism and makes it more relateable.

But then again im not a developer so its not up to me to say. Thank you btw GNVE for giving insight! Its really appreciated, i dont think i have played your game(s) before

 

[imperialpixe]

The giant dick is a lot like the oversized hands and feet in games like Street Fighter. It's the important part that's moving around so it gets exaggerated for more satisfying animations. (ie If her hand covers most of the dick the stroking handjob animation is very subtle)

 

[woody554]

sure. but the thing is you can't make them create something they don't want. nobody is asking what size dick they should put on their MC because they're not open for notes on that department.

 

[KindnessPrevails]

The giant dick is a lot like the oversized hands and feet in games like Street Fighter. It's the important part that's moving around so it gets exaggerated for more satisfying animations. (ie If her hand covers most of the dick the stroking handjob animation is very subtle)

Yeah that makes sense! I was guessing the animation side of things require tricks like that

 

[KindnessPrevails]

sure. but the thing is you can't make them create something they don't want. nobody is asking what size dick they should put on their MC because they're not open for notes on that department.

Of course, but its still valid to put out opinions regarding it

 

[Hagatagar]

The giant dick is a lot like the oversized hands and feet in games like Street Fighter. It's the important part that's moving around so it gets exaggerated for more satisfying animations. (ie If her hand covers most of the dick the stroking handjob animation is very subtle)

Many other devs do this with the creatures in their games as well. For example both Ark Survival Evolved or Subnautica increased the size of the creature models compared to their supposed size, because they appeared too small in the first-person perspective.

 

[woody554]

Of course, but its still valid to put out opinions regarding it

yeah, sure, it's a discussion forum after all. but we have a thousand complaint threads where giant dicks are always the #1 hated thing and it never made any difference. it just isn't something people will take outside opinions on.

 

[Liquid Tube Technology]

I for one become giddy whenever the MC of a game doesn't have the third fricking forearm for his schlong, so I definitely share your sentiment Kindness. A more reasonably proportioned manhood, to me, helps with the immersion because I certainly don't have a ridiculously big dick like that, nor would I want to (surprise!), to be completely honest. Maybe it's the last part of that sentence that especially makes me weary of the "abundance of giant wieners here", as it were. All the John Holmeses out there, I mean no offence whatsoever.

That said, it's more about the personality of the MC when it comes to how well I can self-insert. If he has a super large dong but has the heart of gold who treats his love interests well, while never being a pushover, then I get to focus way less on his penis size and more on the story from his perspective, because he's presented himself as quite likeable to me.

But I'd still like to see more average sized (4 to 6 inches bracket) penises on the MC's! lol I've noticed there are some games where the MC's penis isn't too offensively large, though. "Long Live the Princess" is one that comes to mind right off the bat.

 

[KindnessPrevails]

Many other devs do this with the creatures in their games as well. For example both Ark Survival Evolved or Subnautica increased the size of the creature models compared to their supposed size, because they appeared too small in the first-person perspective.

Ayo i didnt know that :O Devs got a 100 different tricks for problems that may arise

 

[KindnessPrevails]

yeah, sure, it's a discussion forum after all. but we have a thousand complaint threads where giant dicks are always the #1 hated thing and it never made any difference. it just isn't something people will take outside opinions on.

Fair! I didnt see any similar threads when i wrote the title of this thread so i wanted to see the forums opinions on it! I appreciate you telling me that tho c:

 

[KindnessPrevails]

I for one become giddy whenever the MC of a game doesn't have the third fricking forearm for his schlong, so I definitely share your sentiment Kindness. A more reasonably proportioned manhood, to me, helps with the immersion because I certainly don't have a ridiculously big dick like that, nor would I want to (surprise!), to be completely honest. Maybe it's the last part of that sentence that especially makes me weary of the "abundance of giant wieners here", as it were. All the John Holmeses out there, I mean no offence whatsoever.

That said, it's more about the personality of the MC when it comes to how well I can self-insert. If he has a super large dong but has the heart of gold who treats his love interests well, while never being a pushover, then I get to focus way less on his penis size and more on the story from his perspective, because he's presented himself as quite likeable to me.

But I'd still like to see more average sized (4 to 6 inches bracket) penises on the MC's! lol I've notices there are some games where the MC's penis isn't too offensively large, though. "Long Live the Princess" is one that comes to mind right off the bat.

You sir/madam/person have a way with words! I have yet to see a game where the exposure of the MC's dong is responded by a "oh thats average!" comment, instead of "God damn! Thats a huge one, thats massive! Absolutely GIGANTIC" or "Ew, you have a small pp?". Im not looking to self insert but unless its a fantasy game or revolved around big dick fantasies, a 15ft dong just ruins immersion.

Like you mentioned, personality is quite important. Of course this is a taste thing but when a MC is either a creep or straight out sexual harassing someone and the dev make it seem normal (In a regular game, not a game revolving around that kinda fantasy) it bugs me out :')

 

[woody554]

I have yet to see a game where the exposure of the MC's dong is responded by a "oh thats average!" comment,

that would be hilarious! and everyone who saw it piling on how average it is.

 

[KindnessPrevails]

that would be hilarious! and everyone who saw it piling on how average it is.

Ahaha it would be awesome! Some good old body positivity!

 

[Liquid Tube Technology]

You sir/madam/person have a way with words! I have yet to see a game where the exposure of the MC's dong is responded by a "oh thats average!" comment, instead of "God damn! Thats a huge one, thats massive! Absolutely GIGANTIC" or "Ew, you have a small pp?". Im not looking to self insert but unless its a fantasy game or revolved around big dick fantasies, a 15ft dong just ruins immersion.

Like you mentioned, personality is quite important. Of course this is a taste thing but when a MC is either a creep or straight out sexual harassing someone and the dev make it seem normal (In a regular game, not a game revolving around that kinda fantasy) it bugs me out :')

Dude here, lol. *waves*

But yeah, I guess there are generally two popular niches: one the "big dick", and the other the "small penis humiliation". Those themes are common in porn and in webcam sites. That may be why we don't encounter any character remarking on the MC's penis size saying "it's average".

Ha! Actually, I can't remember which game it was but there was a female character that made a comment on the MC's HUGE dong saying something like "I've seen bigger but yours isn't bad at all". That was both face-palm worthy and somehow comical at the same time, lol. It's like, the dick is already as long as a wine bottle, and there's this woman character that's making it sound like it's not even a big deal. The realm of adult games is a curious one indeed. Sometimes I do find myself scratching my head going, "errr, wha...?" lol

 

[GNVE]

That may be why we don't encounter any character remarking on the MC's penis size saying "it's average".

 

[Liquid Tube Technology]

Man that was funny but.....kinda cringy too, or was it just me? lol But honestly, I would absolutely hate it if a woman ever said those things about my penis, lol. I am not by any means into the whole small penis humiliation thing, in fact I despise that scene(those of you who are into that, more power to you), but that doesn't mean I need my partner to flat out lie about my size just because she feels like she needs to be polite about it, either. I'd just be telling her like, "don't ever do that please", lol. After which point, the question gets way more real.... lmao

 

[Fate stay]

With Big Penis comes Big Responsibilities ✨

 

[NeonSelf]

Big dick is part of the story most of the time.

1 - I've seen his bulge the other day and now I'm curious what he is hiding there...
2 - Oh your dick is bigger than my ex-boyfriend's! Now I can only have orgasm with you.
3 - I will punish you for this... - Please dont put your huge dick there!
4 - As a servant of succubus you are granted big dick and infinite stamina

PS: I prefer MC with big dick. Its better for animations and to show penetration in different poses. Using realistic dick you will not see it entering vagina. Its ok in real life to have avarage dick, because you feel it. But in a game you can only see what's happening.