Neither.
I don't really care how many likes or stars a game has. When I click on the Latest Updates page, I usually just scan over all the games on page 1 and 2, then start filtering on things that are tickling my fancy at the time.
I take note of the ratings and will usually read through some of the reviews, but unless they are all talking about clunky mechanics, paywalls, or buggy game code, the ratings don't affect me much.
I don't think I have ever really noticed how many likes any game has, it just isn't a thing I look for when I am searching for something to play.