What to say that hasn't already been said?
This is an excellent game/novel/story by any definition/standard (for AVNs) and ratings less than 4* are matters of personal preferences, like older graphics, too much/not enough NTR, need more old guys having sex with young girls, story too long because one has a short attention span, etc, etc...
If it isn't already, this one should/will be a "classic". If there was a college course for AVNs, this one would be on the required reading list...
Well crafted, great script, intriguing story, great music, fun, drama, sex, variety...so many great things about this one.
While there are a lot of personal preferences I would like to have happened, done, added, etc., this one is just well executed overall with very few "flaws" or cons, but here are a couple:
- If you try this one without a walkthrough (especially w/ time limit active) you are a braver, smarter, more patient soul than I am...
Without a walkthrough, this would be like getting dropped off in the wilderness and told good luck... Yeah, you have a "general" idea of the direction you need to go, but you'll more than likely end up going in circles, backtracking, get frustrated, quit, never get the "good ending", etc. Simply put, give it a try without a walkthrough if you dare. But before giving up, just look at the walkthrough...
- There are a handful of times in this story, particularly at the end/climax of the story, where the MC's thoughts and exposition drag on to the point where it triggered my Holy Grail "get on with it"... Those "get on with it" scenes/moments really don't take that long, but the MC's thought commentary was delaying the "action" and was restating the obvious or "saying" stuff that had already been said/thought/expressed, etc. That's the only "negative" criticism I have for this one.
If you've had this one book marked for months, like I did, stop passing it up and "get on with it"; you're missing a great one...