Seeking Looking for 'realistic NTR' or 'realistic cheating' in western games

Jun 17, 2018
72
71
Any recommendation for NTR game of my taste? My taste of NTR is realistic NTR or realistic reluctantly cheating story. I prefer western games.

1) Heroine should not be too cheap or too slutty, some degree of resistance or reluctance should be there. Or at least give a choice to players, not to being too much slutty or easily taken by bad guy.
2) Heroine should not be too naive or too stupid. I mean, come on, real women usually not falls to such obvious traps.
3) No incest to family. Maybe it is OK to far relatives like uncle or grandfather, but for some reason I'm not a big fan of family incest.
4) No netorase (husband or BF watching of being taken their wife or GF), neither sharing / swapping. Those are just not my taste. I prefer that husband or BF have no idea during seduction/corruption, or recognize the situation at ending at least.
5) No mind control, it feels like 'cheat engine of NTR' to me. I rather wish to see the effort of antagonist to lure heroine, and reasonable reaction / motivation from heroine. However, fantasy / futuristic background is fine.
6) I wish the story provide good enough reason of heroine's corruption or being seduced, not just big cock or pleasure. It is OK to see sex scene late, I mean, slow phase games, but I rather wish to see convincing story line of how heroine is taken by antagonist.
7) NTL (perspective of taker) is also fine.
8) Pregnant-by-antagonist ending is preferable.

Sounds like more cheating / adultery story, but please remind that NTR is placed in cheating / adultery category in broad concept.

To me, pleasure of NTR is coming from 'thrill of breaking the rule and custom', and I think I feel fappy when stories show how heroines are slowly being addicted to such forbidden relation, with a good reasonable motivation. I think the most important thing in NTR is showing the process: process of being seduced or corruption of heroine, in more reasonable fashion. I would say, those would be 'realistic NTR' or 'realistic cheating' with convincing motivation under reasonable story / environment. That is also a reason why I really don't like the NTR games with too "ez" heroines.

Typical cliche, such as Big dick with ugly / old guy or BBC, is OK, they are fine. BUT, there should be a good reason to convince players, why wife or girlfriend choose to being seduced by him, instead of kick him and running away or call the police, even after relationship. Typical porn stories like 'faithful wife being totally seduced after a single night with big dick' or 'royal girlfriend surrender to BBC and become a slave, just because of immense pleasure' is just funny, not fappy, at least to me. Most of real wife or girl friend would never being seduced or betray their husband just because of single sex event, they would rather call police or report to their husband/BF at least.

Seduction and love is more complicated emotional / psychological process, but I never saw any NTR games which show such emotional steps / process of heroines reluctantly being taken by antagonists. In almost all NTR games, heroines are too easy or too naive, which breaks my concentration or immersion to the story. When I play games where heroines corrupted by single sex with BBC and entire story after first sex is just being a sex slave, I just refuse to play further. Those are not horny to me... I just wish to see a game which convince players why heroine choose to continue forbidden relation with antagonist. I wish to see the game, which convince or explains to players nicely, why and how heroine choose to have sex with antagonist instated of call the 911 or husband, despite of being guilty from forbidden sex. It would be really good to see the description of struggle of heroine, to escape from infidelity and guilty, but fails by convincing reason.
 

Bablu (NTR)

Member
May 22, 2018
396
1,262
That's too much to ask for in Netorare genre which is still relatively new in western games. Maybe you can get these kind of things in Japanese games.
Fleeting Iris and Jessica's Hard News are the only games that comes to my mind for now. There was this japanese game (Rhode's Fortress) (transalted of course) i played where Female MC was somewhat clever and NTR element of plot was pretty great.
And for more NTR games check the About section in my Profile. I rated all NTR games i played there.
 

Lorric17

Well-Known Member
May 25, 2017
1,147
1,243
Lily of the Valley lives up to most of that. There is a hypnotherapist involved (which annoys me as I don't think it's necessary), but not mind control as such. And while Lily isn't the sharpest tool in the shed, she's not all the way into retard-in-lechertown territory. She can reject pretty much all H scenes. The game has plenty of content now, but development is slow.
 

WRONGS

Member
Jan 14, 2018
471
692
Good Girl Gone Bad. You can "choose" the path the main character, Ashley, follows. She can cheat on her boyfriend almost from the start or you can take a more leisurely pace and wait for her to develop a serious relationship with other characters before getting into bed with them.
 

deluges

Well-Known Member
Dec 28, 2018
1,072
1,190
Any recommendation for NTR game of my taste? My taste of NTR is realistic NTR or realistic reluctantly cheating story. I prefer western games.

1) Heroine should not be too cheap or too slutty, some degree of resistance or reluctance should be there. Or at least give a choice to players, not to being too much slutty or easily taken by bad guy.
2) Heroine should not be too naive or too stupid. I mean, come on, real women usually not falls to such obvious traps.
3) No incest to family. Maybe it is OK to far relatives like uncle or grandfather, but for some reason I'm not a big fan of family incest.
4) No netorase (husband or BF watching of being taken their wife or GF), neither sharing / swapping. Those are just not my taste. I prefer that husband or BF have no idea during seduction/corruption, or recognize the situation at ending at least.
5) No mind control, it feels like 'cheat engine of NTR' to me. I rather wish to see the effort of antagonist to lure heroine, and reasonable reaction / motivation from heroine. However, fantasy / futuristic background is fine.
6) I wish the story provide good enough reason of heroine's corruption or being seduced, not just big cock or pleasure. It is OK to see sex scene late, I mean, slow phase games, but I rather wish to see convincing story line of how heroine is taken by antagonist.
7) NTL (perspective of taker) is also fine.
8) Pregnant-by-antagonist ending is preferable.

Sounds like more cheating / adultery story, but please remind that NTR is placed in cheating / adultery category in broad concept.

To me, pleasure of NTR is coming from 'thrill of breaking the rule and custom', and I think I feel fappy when stories show how heroines are slowly being addicted to such forbidden relation, with a good reasonable motivation. I think the most important thing in NTR is showing the process: process of being seduced or corruption of heroine, in more reasonable fashion. I would say, those would be 'realistic NTR' or 'realistic cheating' with convincing motivation under reasonable story / environment. That is also a reason why I really don't like the NTR games with too "ez" heroines.

Typical cliche, such as Big dick with ugly / old guy or BBC, is OK, they are fine. BUT, there should be a good reason to convince players, why wife or girlfriend choose to being seduced by him, instead of kick him and running away or call the police, even after relationship. Typical porn stories like 'faithful wife being totally seduced after a single night with big dick' or 'royal girlfriend surrender to BBC and become a slave, just because of immense pleasure' is just funny, not fappy, at least to me. Most of real wife or girl friend would never being seduced or betray their husband just because of single sex event, they would rather call police or report to their husband/BF at least.

Seduction and love is more complicated emotional / psychological process, but I never saw any NTR games which show such emotional steps / process of heroines reluctantly being taken by antagonists. In almost all NTR games, heroines are too easy or too naive, which breaks my concentration or immersion to the story. When I play games where heroines corrupted by single sex with BBC and entire story after first sex is just being a sex slave, I just refuse to play further. Those are not horny to me... I just wish to see a game which convince players why heroine choose to continue forbidden relation with antagonist. I wish to see the game, which convince or explains to players nicely, why and how heroine choose to have sex with antagonist instated of call the 911 or husband, despite of being guilty from forbidden sex. It would be really good to see the description of struggle of heroine, to escape from infidelity and guilty, but fails by convincing reason.
You should probably list which games along these lines you've played so people aren't just listing the most obvious choices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sonicdriller03
Jun 17, 2018
72
71
You should probably list which games along these lines you've played so people aren't just listing the most obvious choices.
Sorry I wish to give some recommendations but I don't have any so far in western NTR games category, all NTRs I know are mostly out of those boundaries...
 

WRONGS

Member
Jan 14, 2018
471
692
Elena's Life follows most of your rules. Well, no pregnancy at the moment and Elena is dumb as a brick. And there's a story line with mind control and another where she's roofied... but you can choose to opt out of those and get the other content.

I'm linking the ren'py remake, which I like better, personally, but Elena's Life is in RPGM if that's more your bag.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sonicdriller03

GoblinSpirit

Member
Dec 31, 2019
205
105
Gotcha. I played a straight-laced MC, but I didn't think I'd be missing content in side stories.
4 years later, i've come here to ask, how was your journey man? Found some goods to share? If so, isn't there any game where the NTR is situational, like, if you make wrong choices/neglect your girl, she'll look for someone else but ain't focused on 1 girl only?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nameless King