I see what you mean, I'm still going to be on her path personally for me but at the same time she is written as the classic bitchy older sister character so with some things like that she will rub some people up the wrong way. The lesbian friend character is alright but isn't on the top of my list tbh.
Yeah she is hot but personally, I think Jessica is hotter and I don't hate her but for others that is their opinion as we are all different people who 1 person who is attractive to you may not be so for me and vice versa a person I find attractive, you won't e.t.c. There is no right or wrong answer here.