Ren'Py - Maeve's Academy [v0.6.1] [Hatchet Games]

0.6.1 is the first version I play, so can't comment on character redesigns, they look good to me.

Art is an easy 5/5. Seriously, some of the best art on this site, the characters are cute, the animations are good, even the backgrounds are nice.

Story and writing: they're there, they're ok. The atmosphere of the game is nice and cozy, some of the humor is alright, the characters are likeable, but reading long dialogues and inner monologues about nothing gets tiresome and a lot of the writing is poor from technical standpoint. The game gets a pass here, there’s much worse out there. 3.5 /5.

Gameplay: and here we have a problem - what gameplay? The entire game up to 0.6.1 feels like an extended intro sequence because there's next to nothing player input on anything. Having an option to choose between saying ‘YES’ or ‘YES, BUT IN A FUNNY WAY’ every 5 minutes doesn’t count. You could skip all the dialogue and click on things randomly and get the same outcome as someone reading the text. The game is almost entirely linear, at some points you can walk between a few locations and talk to characters, but it’s pointless, 90% of their dialogue options are unavailable, the other 10% give you one line of text, and you can only progress by talking to the one specific character about the one specific thing that a quest requires. There is a skeleton of a game here, but there’s nothing on it. It's bad. Best I can say is that it’s not so bad or clunky that it’s annoying to play like some games. 2/5.

The game desperately needs some gameplay: I don’t expect complex RPG mechanics, but even something as simple as adventure game point and click interactions with the environment and inventory, or dialogues that do something to interact with the world and give you info needed to complete quests, actual freedom to explore locations and interactions with NPCs initiated by the player, some non-linear quests or character sidequest. Anything.

I love this game so much you not only u can interact them and have sex but all I care is the character like these girls has beauty and I don't see them with lust and the plot it self is actually good even it is not finished yet they still promise they'll update the game till it completed even though it took 4 to 8 month to completed one update and still haven't finish the story which I don't judge the plot it self has to be perfect and a beautiful ending even we don't know what will the ending is like but I hope this game has lots of love

the 3 star rating is honestly a personal bias due to the game annoying me

the game provides an incredible and promising basis which makes you believe you'll be getting an amazing choose your own adventure style visual novel where you can choose what you want to do... until i realized none of that is implemented, the 30+ options split across the cast that are greyed out were NEVER available in this build and you are forced to follow a linear questline where at the end you are shown a lovely screen telling you "content's over bub"

however, to be devils advocate to that critique, i understand that these options ARE to be in place and the game IS in development, i just came into it with high hopes that i'd get a taste of it from atleast 1 character

ahem, anyways, sex, it's good. there are about 5 or 6 scenes in the game right now (excluding non sexual) and they are stylized, great, i really did want more content from the teacher, and a few other characters to be fair, but the game is quite ambitious, i really hope to return to this in a few years and experience what i had felt i was promised from the start, i definitely intend to keep an eye on this game

The art style is adorable, the characters have so much personality, and the sex scenes are hot but tasteful
They allow you to opt in or out for certain fetishs which is always a plus
The only complaint I can think of is that the gui is a little buggy on mobile

[v0.5.2]

The games art style amazing in my personal opinion. Gameplay is your standard adventure-game-y kind of thing. Dialogue is a little clunky with constant awkward pauses, but more than good enough for a game like this. Character animations are well done and it honestly does make them feel alive.

A warning, though, some of the personalities on these characters are just grating. The main character is the biggest issue here, since he has a nasty habit of lying (but of course it always works out). On top of this, almost all conflicts in the game are from some level of xenophobia. When used correctly, it can be used to make a good story, but here it's practically the only thing. Conflicts boil down to someone with a nasty personality screaming, "but you're a muggle elf/demon/male!" every time.

I initially played this game year ago and decided there was too little content to even put any thought in to it. Forgot about it until I noticed it again today. Played it again and... There's still far too little content. At it's current state it still feels like its in an alpha 0.1 proof of concept stage with far too little H content to get the job done, so it's not even good for a quick fap. There's not even any sound 60% of the time. This is looking like one of those games that's going to take 5-8 years to have enough content for a real playthrough. By then it'll probably be an easy 5/5, though.

Subjectively, the art work is good. Objectively, the animation is above average when it is there. However, this game has an excessive amount of text. That in itself isn't bad, but much of the text is unnecessary, repetitive, and/or uninteresting. A lot of text is dedicated to establishing the character's personalities as opposed to advancing the narrative or the relationships, but those personalities aren't all that appealing. To make matters worse, the translation is pretty bad, not horrible, but bad enough that it is distracting and takes away from the dialog. Finally, the gameplay feels like an after thought. I don't really feel like I'm interacting with the world or the characters, but instead trying to find the right action to progress the story. Not the worst game I've played, but I hope the dev(s) take some constructive criticism and implement it before getting too close to the end.

A VN with a great foundation that you can spend a few hours with.
The character development is excellent. It’s not much of a rush with any of the ladies. Each has their own unique story and personality. You want to get to know them and what makes them tick.
The writing is above average but could use some editing and proofreading. It’s not enough to misunderstand what’s going on but it can be off putting.
The art design, while not flawless is fun. It can be a bit cartoony during the more intimate scenes but overall is a good touch. I especially like that you can customize each of the characters clothing to some extent.
Obviously this is still a work in progress and if the developers keep building on the foundation they have here this will be considered a gem one day.

Amazing art style, interesting characters. Gameplay can use a bit more polish though - game expects me to talk to a certain person but you get the right dialog only in the right location, this part seems odd.

Version 0.5.2

Short but pretty sweet. I found the artstyle very lively in this VN, with colorful characters and bouncy animations, although the cartoonish artstyle really weakens the adult scenes in my opinion. These could have spared some more details on the characters sprites to better convey their eroticism. There are very few of them too, only locked to two characters.

Overall, the story isn't incredible, but the devs have made a pretty good job of making almost every character likable, and I found Annie's wish for the future really cute, although it could have been better established with more show than tell. For now only a few routes are available and none of them are complete, also some scenes kind of drag on more than they need to, especially the ones with Lulu, but what is there is at least polished and sows a good direction for the rest of the game. It's a nice VN if you have ~30 minutes of your time to spare.

Great art assets, but the quality in writing leaves something to be desired. Having native-speaking English proof-readers would go a long way, but the storytelling is jilted at times and suffers from pacing issues

I don't usually review games but I can't not recommend something of this quality.

The story is really well written and the art is amazing. I genuinely spent maybe an hour or so just clicking through menus and walking around because I wanted more art.

The sandbox nature of the VN isn't apparent in the current demo berceuse there isn't anything to do besides the main story, but that still was incredibly engaging on its own.

Honestly as long as the direction of the game isn't changed drastically for the worse this will be one I keep coming back to. I'm most exited for the character individual quests!

This is one of those games with a great foundation that will be good eventually should the devs maintain their current trajectory. It has great art and design theory, the story is perfectly fine for an H game where nothing feels totally out of place, and the character designs are well done with good variety.

It just isn't overflowing with content yet but if and when the devs flesh out a large amount in the future, it will be a great game should they continue as they have.

[0.4.2 Review]

Only flaw is the poor story. It's nonsensical at times and could be a lot better when selling the characters and the world. Intro was fine but as it progressed, it was easy to address plot holes or flaws in character's thinking outside of H-Game logic. The other reviews go more in-depth.

My review is just to state everything about this game, except for writing, is great. Writing is a 3/5 at best. I'm impressed with the developers and wish them success with their creative talent. They use 3D models well and have great design sense.

v0.4.2
Rating: 4/5
Playtime: 1.5 Hours

Pros:
- wonderful art, its a breath of fresh air from what I usually see from H-games

- i truly appreciate the animations/movements in lewd/non-lewd scenes it really does leave a strong positive effect similar to enhancing food with a pinch of salt to enhance the flavor a little cliche but that is how I would describe it. The subtle animations/movements giving the characters more life than what most 2dcgs usually do with the bare minimum heavily relying on vfx, sfx, and scene transitions.

Cons:

Story - feels convoluted I'd say from what the overview explains and the subtle world building monologue/dialogue while progressing. It is NOT bad, but I don't want to force myself to say it is good either. It is fair with what the plot would/could become as the foundation already been laid.

Pacing - feels like its pretty fast, while its understandable to pump out lewd scenes for the updates it felt unexpected. The matter in question being the 2nd H-scene w/ Jade. It caught me off guard completely. It feels as if it is so out of place and not needed for that point in time. Will there be worth-while build up connection with the story and its characters? Or just a User posting their full save solely for the degens who just want to see the H-scenes?

Plot - hand in hand with Pacing. The only progression so far I've seen are the character statistics. Sure it has Sandbox/VN elements, but for right now it feels like a KN with sprinkles of choices that don't really matter or hold any weight to them just for the engagement of the player with humorous post dialogue options. Not every choice dialogue has to matter obviously in the grand scheme of things as engagement with the player is always a good laugh/sexy option to come by when playing through VNs. It just feels as if the build-up is TOO easy and could be better.

VFX/SFX - ol' reliable with 2dcg h-scenes. While this game in particular can probably do w/out it. its rarely ever bad to add them unless devs just choose crap effects or not to.

BGM - while playing some scenes such as the wand shop and dahlia's shop felt empty w/ no BGM probably fixed in future updates. Also BGM bugged out while during the hallway hearing two BGMs overlapping w/ one another. Overall not bad choice of BGMs though could be better the BGM that played for Angelica felt off.


Conclusion:

Good art, animation. Lovable characters. H-scenes decent gets the job done.
Story not bad, plot progression could be better.

The Animations are simple but they're still good, good story and a wholesome one, the art style is very pleasant to see, and I love every single character, especially Maeves, absolute mommy. I really hope to see just how far this gets, this game is in a very early stage, but it's already amazing

[0.3.0] - overall rating: 6.5/10

An adorably cute but incomplete magic-infused story.

THE GOOD
First of all, I am a sucker for eye candy and Maeve's Academy scratches all the good spots for me. Reminiscent of Paper Mario, the "sticker-like" character design is sleek, adorable and clean. Contrary to some other reviewers, I do not think it is "too cute for porn".
My Pig Princess has a similar (albeit a much different art style) fidelity, yet it does not get criticized for that. Audio-visual SFX are also on point, adding to the well-crafted atmosphere.

My only critique in the visual department goes to the backgrounds that simply look... bad. Right as they are blurred in front of our eyes we can see the low quality over-processed renders used for that "filler" part. I hope they get replaced at some point given the fidelity of the characters.

THE NEUTRAL
Now let's switch to the "neutral" gear and talk about the "bobbing" animation. While I appreciate the added motion, it is at the very least distracting, and at worst nauseating to see the talking head almost entering a state of seizure with how often they bob. Also, the effect itself is used rather inconsistently, as sometimes the characters will change their stance and not bob and other times they will just hop around like teenagers on adderall when articulating any sentence longer than one "click".

On the topic of "neutral" we have somewhat uninspiring character writing (the only exception being Jade and Maeve). The game also uses the well-known tropes for the main LI's[?] (the female childhood friend/lover[?], the extremely shy girl, the yandere, the chuunibyou), which is usually not explored in any meaningful way, but given the game's active development we can be pleasantly surprised.

THE BAD
Onto the negatives: The world-building kinda... sucks.

You start the game, get an intro scene, you learn there's magic and wands, and some sort of Academy you get accepted into. You are supposed to not be a man for some reason (to some it's a big deal, but others seem to not care?). There's other races too, apparently. You meet a demon for a very first time in your life only to mention exactly the type of the creature later during one scene (who told us that?).
I could go on with more examples, but you get the picture. Some choose the path of "show, don't tell" when expressing themselves in a medium, but this is just "show" and nothing else. I was confused on what exactly is going on and why.

And the last, but not least: The writing is just bad.

It is perfectly fine to not speak or write English as your first (or even second) language, and grammatical errors could be excused where other parts carry the flow. Not here, unfortunately. As one reviewer put it "the game right now looooves to hear itself talk".

The most egregious example is the "cake quest" where we are almost spammed with MC's thoughts and remarks on: the cake, how he cannot make said cake, how his friend is good at making cakes, and how someone eats that cake. Please, shut up - we know, we can see it.
The dialogue is fine at the start, but during and after the "cake quest" it just falls off really quickly (perhaps there was no proofreading done there yet? I dunno).

On the topic of MC - what exactly is he from the personality standpoint? Curious? Sure. But other than that, he seems oblivious to what's going on around him. He's sometimes eager to do things, other times he acts as if he has never spoken to a woman before.

Also, when presenting MC's thoughts put them in parenthesis or something (like you do for other characters), it's hard to distinguish when stuff is spoken and when it's not.

Overall, this game has a ton of potential, so I hope devs (who read those reviews) take my criticism and apply it where needed the most ^^

Extremely cute and wholesome
The game right now is mostly a demo with very few scenes, but the characters are adorable and charming
Right now the game is very linear, hopefully it will become more sandboxy once there is more content.
The strongest point of the game is the art, but the story is not bad, I just hope it has less harry potter-ish stuff in following updates, the wall piranha was a bit too silly.

Annie is love Annie is life

3.5/5 - v0.3.0

The game obviously has a quality artist behind it, both in terms of character design and UI design, however there's a few things that worry me:

1. Story pacing feels off in terms of world build-up and lewd scenes - one time you're getting a great in-depth explanation about the world and its workings, the other moment you have a dream about when you had sex with your ex-girlfriend (who's the friend that joined the academy alongside you?, that came out of left field).

2. Repetitive and mundane dialogue - this is a critique of one character in particular, but in general I found the dialogue to be needlessly wordy and repetitive at times as well. There's only so many times you can hear a character's self-deluded intro until it gets grating.

3. The artstyle is almost too cute to the point it's difficult to get into the mood. This is of course entirely subjective but it's not an issue I've had with any of the other games on this website thus far so it stood out to me. Artstyle wasn't the sole contributor to this feeling, the character's behaviors also felt too naively childlike. Even though it does make sense considering the story being told, it still felt odd.

I would prefer to give this game a 3/5 but the underlying quality of the game does deserve a rounded up 4/5. It's got potential but maybe wait a few updates before you try this one out.

Honestly, probably one of the best games on this site when it comes to quality, the art is great and so is the writing. I love the little animations. Everything about this game is incredible and I highly recommend it

I'm rating this 5/5, with the caveat that the game is new and there aren't many scenes, and the scenes that do exist aren't particularly "sexy." There are two blowjobs, 1 handjob, 1 defloration, and 1 titjob. The static POV and animations aren't amazing, although for 2d animations they are technically good.

How can I justify 5/5 with that in mind? The art is amazing and unique. All characters have idle animations that are cute. The writing is clearly well thought out. The setting is reasonably interesting and consistent.

This isn't a derivative copy of another game - It is a labor of creativity and quality. One that ought to be supported, even with flaws, to allow it the opportunity to blossom.