Unreal Engine - Magic Shop 2 [2025-03-20] [FireArm]

A really, really good game if you're looking for something to keep you interested to the next fap session. This is a game with no failure scenario, just continued progress.

The gameplay loop is "go into dungeon to get currency and experience, unlock customization through Brewing and the Wardrobe menu, and customize your witch. " Unlocks give permanent stat increases, which is nice. As you unlock new ways to dress up your witch and maybe explore some of your dress-associated kinks, you can use that currency to unlock more wardrobe preset slots, meaning you can cycle through your favored outfits.

The battle fuck system is pretty damn good, with some challenge as you get used to it. Overall the battle fucking isn't the most balanced system in gaming, but it gets the job done. Every scene and battle fuck pose can be viewed in the Memories section after seeing it - not even after beating the boss.

The minigames, though, are a sticking point. If this game didn't have them, or if the game let you autowin them, it'd take a whole lot out of the appeal of striving for the unlocks. But I can also see these minigames being hard as shit to complete.

If you're looking for a fap, tbh it took me til the like... third boss? to find a scene I could queue up in the Memories segment and go to town on. Which was maybe an hour into it. But the whole time, the sexy witch was there barely wearing anything, which convinced me to continue on.

5/5, one of the best games on this site. Damn near the first porn game that made me think of buying one.

It is best to just grab an 100% save file after trying it first time for 1 or 2 hours. Minigames novelty wears off fast.

The good
-Character outfits and customization
-Jiggle physics for boobs and butt
-Decent amount of scenes and monster variety
-Boss fights have potential and should be the core mechanics

The bad
-Dungeon navigation is clunky and wastes your time
-The grind is insane after first few levels
-Traps /empty chests/Brew success chance should be removed
-Quantity over quality

Right out of the game, i must say. This game has one of the best customizations of female protagonists compared to almost any other game. Both the clothing options and the physical are amazing. They give you the ability to create a woman you want to see.

The sexual scenes are pretty good as well. Coupled with good renders and models, they are very satisfying. Its a bit of a shame that the animations feel a bit wooden in comparison.

The two main negatives to me that shot down two stars from the rating is the gameplay and the grind. Playing consists of a large amount of minigames that you get at random to complete while dungeon clawling. At first its interesting enough, but after a few hours, it gets repetitive and annoying to do the same 20~ minigames over and over again. They arent even that engaging or hard. The grind is somehow worse. You need to collect essence so that you can unlock clothing options AT RANDOM. It makes the grind both for cosmetics painful. That coupled with slow level progression, is just a slog to get through.

This game is a polarity of what i love and what i hate in one neatly packaged experience.

Not my type of game genre wise, decent model, cute, ok graphics, animations are ok, but could be better, wish it had some bulges in scenes (few have one but it's done badly, no inflation) and scene progression pretty much does not exist (there are few variations, but it's not really what I expect from sex animations in a game), model is customizable, but mostly wardrobe/makeup/clothes, etc, body customizations are pretty bad (just tits, muscular/skinny, skin shine and body fat, no face customization or anything else that's more in-depth).

Reviewing 03-2025 update.

Solid game. Graded 4 stars as im grading against other Unreal games which in generally aren't great. Animations are good, Character models are good too. Story is meh, but who's here for the story really. Game can be played with only mouse which is nice. Regular roguelike gameplay is solid, gets a little monotonous because the minigames are a bit easy and movement is slow (to the point there are stats to upgrade specifically to speed it up). Sex battle gameplay is actually good though.

The overall grind is ridiculously high. Highly recommend using a cheat table to get unlimited herbs and things if you can. Unlocking customisation options requires an insane amount of essence and RNG luck so definitely cheat what you can.

Overall though, still had fun with it. Hopefully theres more gameplay and customisation to come.

I like games where the sexy stuff is the gameplay. This is a ten out of ten for me in that regard. The grind sucks donkey penis so go ahead and use cheat engine to triple your essence every round. I like games where you can dress bitches up and change their proportions, this has that second only to custom order maid 2.

Pretty good. A lot of outfits and the animations are pretty decent. Can do everything with one hand which is always a plus.

The gameplay loop is going around rooms doing some minigames until you go to the H scene which is the boss fight and interactive, you win/lose then go back and unlock more wardrobe items and dress up the girl and go again. Win and you are onto the next dungeon with a different H scene.

I guess if you like ipad level (say, jewel matching or the sort) click-button games with a bit of titillating (and not particularly well done) erotic scenes, this could be enjoyable.

To me it was just boring and bland.

TL;DR: Good models, good animations, great customization and 'progression', but terrible selection of minigames and horrible exploration.

+ Lots of customization options and unlockable outfits, fun to just deck out a cool design and go bang with it
+ Animation variety is good, but could be improved upon, for now I like what I see and I hope to see more
+ Graphics are pleasant and game doesn't have any noticeable bugs that i've come across during my playtime of like 5 hours

- Absolutely dull exploration where one of the upgrades you can get just speeds up how fast you go, feels like a mobile game
- The minigames are clearly not meant for an adult and are more there to entertain children aged 2-4. Seriously, one of the 'puzzles' is literally an X+Y equation, why even add (heh) that at this point? 4+5 = 9 is not exactly thrilling gameplay.
- There is quite a bit of grind to unlock everything, and thanks to the gameplay being obnoxious, slow, and boring, it makes it so unlocking all the outfits is more of a chore than anything.

Game could be an easy 4/5 if the dev eased up on these tedious minigames and made an actual game instead, but I doubt that'd happen, I'm not going to up this score until I see minigames that aren't boring.

Story: 0/5. There's basically nothing here except "daughter of a powerful wizard goes dungeon delving". Some of the bosses have brief lore snippets also, but only a few of them.

Gameplay: 1/5. Gameplay has a few different parts.

1. Exploration is a chore and feels non-interactive. You click an undiscovered tile and wait for the search bar to fill, then something happens. You can upgrade your movement speed and search speed, both of which are pointless except as a time-saving measure since it's basically just point and click. Deleting the search time entirely and multiplying movement speed by literally 10 would drastically improve this aspect.
2. Minigames, by far the worst aspect of this game. There are so, so many: Warframe hacking, bad riddles, math, memory games, and 10 different flavors of QTE. They aren't fun, aren't engaging, aren't even remotely difficult, and are extremely annoying and unskippable.
3. Battle fuck- the only halfway decent part of the gameplay. It's pretty well done, but needs some balancing to really feel great. Also, make them a bit more common instead of a single encounter per floor that functions as a boss and progression lock.
4. Progression- for some reason progression is tied to an RNG fest of unlocking costume pieces. You spend 'essence' to unlock a random piece (you can choose between hats, tops, shoes etc) and get a random stat increase (stamina, stamina regen etc). There's also a more traditional level/skill point system, but that feels very much like an afterthought.
5. Magic shop mechanics: Error 404, not found. It's a game called "Magic Shop" but there are no customers, no inventory, indeed no reason to suspect there is any shop related things at all. A shame since that's what caused me to download in the first place.

Graphics: 4/5. 3D models and animations are pretty good, the costumes are excellent, but facial expressions are a bit too wooden, the physics looks weird if your character has smaller proportions, and (YMMV) the other female models have what I like to call "Anime proportions" with gigantic breasts larger than the head and hips a lot wider than the shoulders. If you're into that, great, but I'm not.

Customization: 4/5. There's a massive quantity of costumes and clothing pieces, as well as several options for adjusting the PC's proportions, but everthing except physical adjustments is locked behind RNG. You can't choose a specific piece to unlock, you have to choose a type to unlock, and you get a random one. There's also memories (animations) locked behind encountering them in the dungeon, and memories and costumes locked behind brewing (has a chance of failure, increases on success, decreases on failure). It makes me feel like I'm playing a game that should have predatory MTX in it but they haven't been added yet. In short, customization is lootbox central. However, the costumes are extensive and high-quality. Just getting them is annoying.

Sex: 4/5. Animations are all very good and there's a lot of variety. As previously mentioned there's some slightly wooden aspects still. Also, I don't like that the camera in memories is static (instead there's typically other memories that are the same scenes from a different angles).

As a game, it's garbage. As a collection of sex animations, it's pretty good. The developer is clearly skilled with art, animations, and creative costume choices, but they are absolutely not a good game developer.

Rated "poor" because the garbage gameplay is a massive roadblock to enjoyment. Also because the title is misleading.

I spent about 10 hours playing this game to unlock everything. It was well worth it. There for a bit it did get a little annoying doing all the minigames but that could have been because I was at hour 7 of straight playing. But none the less its a very good game with lots of good animations and TONS of customization definitely worth a download.

The game felt pretty great and I got stuck in playing it for a couple of hours easy. However, there were two issues That drop my rating to 4 stars. I could overwrite presets at all and I could not figure out a way to save my progress which was kinda annoying after the game crashed and I lost all progress.

really therapeutic game, helped me lessen my smoking habits. Bit gatcha-ish but it's relaxing and can be played by one hand

Bit grindy though because it needs that freaking coins all the time. My only gripe is I wish I can undo the presets I've bought. Also, where sexy wendy outfit??

Many of the animations are really good, especially some of the first few bosses, my favourites are the stone guy and the dragon. The combat system is actually pretty fun. The customization is great. Takes a bit too long to grind and and moving around and completing minigames in the maze isnt that fun, wish you could have a few more upgrades to make this process quicker.

Players are thrust into a richly detailed universe filled with mythical creatures, treacherous dungeons, and epic quests waiting to be conquered.

The game offers a seamless blend of exploration, combat, and character progression. From battling fierce monsters to uncovering hidden treasures, every moment is packed with excitement and adventure.

Great animations but the grind sucks. It doesn't really ramp up how fast you make progress. Spent around 2 hours just getting past the first level to look at a full save and see there's like, twelve of them. Could use some more fetish stuff, but i always complain about that. Free came for animations is a bit limited.

I love this game honestly, gameplay is p boring and bosses become trivial once you realize the flow of combat, but the animations are great and varied, and the character creator is one of the best I've experienced for a 3d game. Nice casual and fappable game

Very impressed with the rate of development and looking forward to more.

Gameplay is fun enough and not too grindy. Animations and models are decent, really enjoy the scenes

Only minor gripe is that changing costumes/presets doesn't seem to save all clothes

It is not really a game. It's same puzzles that you do over and over again, in grind hell, till you unlock everything. Not fun at all. Just use the linked full save.

It has nice models, nice graphics that will run good on low end machines. The majority of animation is on a camera that is fixed to the character, so you can only rotate and zoom.

The guy is competent animator, model maker and programmer, but the "gameplay" design sucks.

No story to speak of, but in the end I think games should be judged based on what they are and this one is a dress up game, first and foremost.

There aren't many dress up games, so always happy to see more, but this one is actually excellent. Great variety of clothes and customisation options due to customisable shapes and even textures, a cute base model, very good animations. Makes for plenty of fappable material.

And the customisable main menu is very well done, too

Only thing missing for me is an option to color the clothes and hair, the way you can colour pubic hair and a basic set of skirts / pants

The mini games get a bit stale but it's not too grindy once you get past the initial 1 or 2 bosses.