Unreal Engine - Magic Shop 3D [2022-06-19] [FireArm]

Overall its pretty good though I think it has many small inconveniences and though the game is made for fapping to, evident in the Harem mode, the animations just amount to edging the player.

My first issue is a minor one which is, the ingredients are scrambled every time you make a potion which only servers to inconvenience the player, by making it unnecessarily more difficult in remembering which ingredient combinations you have already used. Another slightly annoying thing is the minigames, yes they can be turned off but they really don't serve any purpose other than seemingly to increase playtime.

Lastly as a game that primary focuses on the different sex animations the fact that there is no progression in the animations, different speeds and more egregiously no climax scene, is really abhorrent.

For the things that I found to be good about the game was the variety of the different types of scenes, that is common with this genre, the aesthetic is pretty good for older 3DCG games and the Harem mode i thought was a good addition.

Its a fap game. I dont understand why people give it a low score for it being one.
It has tons of content unlike many games atm. The amount of content is crazy and all the animations are nice.
The game is very original and it shows that a lot of work went into it.
The only problem is the childish minigames, like why do you even add that.

Just a nice game with no big story, but fun gameplay.

Animations and scenes are great, the models are hot, the customization process is spicy.

I would like to replay it , cause it just give me fun and lust).

Interesting lil' game, I had fun with it for short while. It seems like it wants to be made-for-fapping game, what with that whole harem auto-play feature and all (select a buncha girls and animations you like and it goes through em one by one automatically)....

But without the sex scenes having any stages, it didn't do much for me personally. It should at least have a climax/cum. But I get it, fluid physics is hard af in 3d

Excellent and fun game with a lot of girls and fetishes covered but not without its flaws. Magic Shop is fun at first but all that minigames shit quickly become dull. The game is also poorly optimized and unplayable on old hardware.

Yet it would be a shame to pass on such a good concept so here is my advice: Play it and once it starts to get boring download a 100% save and enjoy!

there is a lot of content and i dont mind the grind, in fact, i find the grind kind of fun. i personally think this game is good and its on my watchlist. if you like games with a big variety of different girls this is it. also shoutout to the dev for updating so frequently. the only thing are the math puzzles which make me think too hard. me no like think.

Take a great old flash game, one of the best, but throw on outdated 3d, randomize the ingredients for no reason, add stupid minigames for no reason (Do you like basic math and drawing short lines in your porn? Yes. That dumb.)
Congrats, a classic 5 star updated into a modern 1.5 star. Rounding down because yes the grind is both excessive and flat out poor game design.
Barely worth playing once if ever, it doesn't even channel your nostalgia it just ruins it.

Clearly, the game is not bad.It has a lot of content ( 80+ transoformations )
But it has its flaws. The first one, was the camera which is locked. However, the fact that the game is in 3d could have made the experience much more pleasant.
In the end, it's really grindy. Maybe create a method to know which recipe has / has not been made yet?
The transformations are cool. Of all kinds! Furry, monster girl, parody ( zone-sama, Hermione Granger, D.Va, etc. ) But again, once you find the transformation, you still have to do a very repetitive mini-game to be able to get an h-animation or undress it.

The game has a lot of potential! It deserves 4 stars, but I put 3, and I wait to see the evolution of the game. And maybe the game will even deserve 5!

Very average 'pick combination see result' type NG+ game

Pro
+ Cute MC base form
+ has a fairly polished feel (UI, sounds, options, ...)
+ Animations are smooth and bouncy
+ Fun and happy tone

Meh
/ Sex scenes are just 3 second loops. Any kind of impactful H scene is sacrificed to have more transformations

Bad
- Takes forever to get all combinations, especially without a help guide
- Most transformations have no interactions available
- No internal CP or even external finishes (that I have found)
- Base girl is cute, but she mostly gets turned into a big tiddy bimbo. Good if you like big tit bimbos; bad if you like pretty much any other body type
- graphics are a bit blurry
- have to do lots of clicks and waiting for animations to get from transformation A to B. Very grindy.
- 3 Gigs

Game is lighthearted and the animations are pretty good, would love more combinations and interaction to help with figuring out the combinations. Also more music/characters would be fun. Princess having a voice and talking voicing her opinions would be interesting!

Overall, it's promising. Got a good foundation for a 3D match-two magic spell game, which were some of my favorite flash-type games. Needs quite a bit of refining and adjustments to be less grindy, and the shuffling of the ingredients is the worst part of the whole game right now. Mini-games and math problems are a close second.

The audio effects are really annoying and uncomfortable to listen to, particularly the text sound.

The mini games are unoriginal & boring, especially hate the math one, why would i do math when there's no blood in my brain?!

The main gameplay of mixing potions turning the girl into various things is a decent idea, until you start creating the same mixtures over and over again.

The animation & girls look decent tho, just not a lot there. Currently no story either, it's mostly just a gallery with torturous mini games.

You can't even avoid the minigames by using the gallery feature.

Classic magicshop game. 4.5 stars.
rules are simple mix 2 items get result (hopefully erotic one)

good animations.
hot girls.
a good gallery feature.
there is also a cool feature to switch characters in certain H-scenes as long as you unlocked them before.

there are mini games that I suspect were inserted to count as a game on steam. but they are quick and easy so I found them easy to ignore.

for an early access game its excellent, good amount of content, -0.5 star for the minigames.

positive:
The animations it has are good
The female character is attractive
You can with a single character have several very different scenes which is innovative.
It has nice textures and images.
Negative:
The camera lock ruins many of the few real animations.
The minigames are very basic and boring
It doesn't really have a lot of animations, most of it is simply undressing the character.
Combining ingredients gets boring.
It has a very poor performance in many moments.