• To improve security, we will soon start forcing password resets for any account that uses a weak password on the next login. If you have a weak password or a defunct email, please update it now to prevent future disruption.

RPGM - Completed - Magical Girl Sarah [yaminabedaiichikantai]

  1. 2.00 star(s)

    Fidzius

    Good ideas and bad ideas make it from a decent game to a bad one...
    they're mixed together with translation oddities, so it makes it even harder to justify playing or recommending:

    Instead of Gold or EXP, there's a mixed point system to be used exactly how you want
    BUT stat increases do not show price;​
    Renewable items scattered around, encouraging combat,
    BUT they're weak and makes the consumable shop worthless;​
    Infinite sustainability using out of combat skills,
    BUT it makes combat annoying and restoration items useless (since they're not good enough to match skills in or out of combat);​
    Clothing damage system,
    BUT it doesn't do anything (or at least doesn't do enough to be noticeable) + and requires a shop-only item to be restored​
    Easy to navigate: no ambiguous blockages, blue zones transition areas,
    BUT THE SAME PATH HAS BEEN USED 5 TIMES- explore it, reach some goal, get sent back and return for the next goal;​
    There's multiple H-stats,
    BUT the only not pathetic loss way to see them is triggered by one attack- tentacle bind, that's it, lose for the rest;​
    There's an item that can give you passive points (from walking),
    BUT it's 100x times easier and rewarding than any doing anything else...​

    Now only the bad:
    There are some untranslated menus and some boxes shift to obscure others; Monsters have incredibly inconsistent damage;
    Bosses are slow and boring to fight.

    More bad than good, is boring and unrewarding.
    For not being intentionally awful, but still incompetent 2/5
  2. 2.00 star(s)

    Neo Nocturne

    TL;DR:
    Not going to contradict my last review on the same author, one simple line:
    If you are aroused by the title, the author wins.

    The other half will be:
    Lower your expectation and you will enjoy this game, there are worse games out there.

    And lastly, DON'T ASK: What is the cat?

    Honest Opinion:
    Let's just say this is a bit better than most of the author's work...but then again it is his third title of the magical girl series...also it's one of his of the many titles.

    Again, it will not be one of the most best and most satisfying games you have played, but if you enjoy fooling around and find out "what does the cat say?", "what is the cat?", go ahead and dig in. (^_^)