Others - Marnie Game [v0.4] [wjs07]

Im playing it for the gallery. The quality is pretty low, if you are into Marnie getting poki-dicked down, then it might be worth your time to skim the gallery.

The art is (only) redeeming feature. Its pretty good. But i honestly feel like it would have been better to make standalone images/videos.

Many of the scenes involves Machamp. They are a bit too generic for my taste. I feel like the creator wasted some potential here, and that they could have at least made use of Machamps 4 arms.
The scenes are from a unknowing-cuck-POV. Im not too into that kink, but it works out pretty well storywise. However, the "Peeping" aspects awful, visually, and drags down the score.

The scenes are short too, like, average scene takes is 25 seconds to read.
This might just be me, but the lack of capitalization makes me want to scope my eyes out with a spoon.

I find the QOL lacking too. I have seen way worse, but its not good. Specifically the need to use A/S to toggle exray, and the lack of an overall toggle. For a porn "gallery viewer" game, designing the ui for 1 handed usage is absolutely critical.

I am giving it 2 stars, but a little bit of polish could push it up to 3.

It's basically a scene viewer, not even, more like a picture viewer.
The art is amazing but whoever made it should've teamed up with a writer and a coder to sell this game in a more rounded up package because it's a shame to present it in this state. And change the game engine to something more user friendly.

Pretty low effort. Terrible UI and H content consists of a few still images with some very basic movement for animation. It doesn't even include options to exit full screen or mute sound. The gameplay consists of wandering around to trigger the scenes. Art styles used aren't even consistent through the game.

I'd give it 1-star but at least you can go straight to the content from the start of the game I guess.

Like many games developed by well established artists, the art in this game is fantastic, while the game itself is a complete fucking mess. The gameplay is extremely buggy and worthless, don't bother, simply skip to the scene viewer... which is also bugged to shit, but at least less so.

Games basically a glorified and extremely buggy CG gallery. At least the CGs are really good.

The game is raw, it's hard to call it a game, there is practically no text accompaniment as visual novels, or real gameplay, as for normal games. A set of pretty good pictures with the mechanics of moving between scenes, the author has a lot to grow. Good luck

I really do like this game, however there a few things that lower its rating for me

Marnie's body is constantly changing shape, at first she has smaller breasts and looks more like you would think Marnie should, but then her boobs randomly get bigger later and she looks like a different person.

Also i feel that the scenes are missing something in between, The sex scene's happen too fast and Marnie goes from resisting being groped by Machamp, to lying down ready to have sex too quickly, like we missed a lot in-between and i dont like it. there should have been a first sex scene that Marnie was more reluctant and surprised at the sex before the current sex scene where she's seemingly fine with it.

Other than those things i really enjoyed the game, and am looking forward to any future updates, hopefully there's updates that add scenes in-between what we have now.

It has potential, the mountain walk has different endings depending on the route you take, if the developer wants to it, it could become a good game.

Hopefully, it takes better advantage of the exercise mechanics, with hidden scenes or the ability to enter the house once you get stronger. For now, it's fine for a first version.

Review as of v0.36

Sure, in some ways it's rough and unfinished, but it's put together where it counts!
Unique gameplay, nice loop, great drawings, very hot. What more could you ask for?

There are regular updates and it is clear what is coming next. These are all good things.

More than a game its a slightly interactive CGI slideshow
The Art is extremely high quality tho
If you like the pictures then play it, if you are in it for the story or game mechanics then just dont

TLDR nice pictures go brrrrrrrrrrr

Absolute Garbage.

There's just no other way to put it. Forget good, aside from the CGs themselves, no aspect of this game is even okay. It's a janky, buggy, and pointless walking simulator that shows you sex scenes accompanied by 2-3 lines of... dialogue, if a collection of "ah" and "oh" can be called that.

There's literally zero reason to package this into a game. Hell even CGs themselves are cut down comics by the same author. You can find them by artist's name, with more frames than here, and sometimes with more dialogue (yes, lol) on any decent booru.

It's just shameful.

You know that feeling when you start a project and are really excited about ideas, but then you lose steam as soon as you get going? That's what this game feels like. There are a handful of amazingly rendered scenes with concepts I really like, but then the rest of the game feels like it was put together with 0.01% effort. It's jarring seeing 10/10 art placed right next to what amounts to toddler scribbles. The writing doesn't do any favors. I can't even figure out how to save the game, but it's not a big deal because this "game" is one of the most glorified-scene-viewer-types I've seen. I really hope everything outside of the scene is an early placeholder because I love the base concept of the story. I really hope after some patches I can come back here and give this a 5 star.

Review of [v0.34]

The gameplay itself is a bit repetitive, but it doesn't take too long to complete. The really important part, the porn, is great. Love the style and quality of the art. It reminds me of NTRMAN's "Camp With Mom", where you watch the girl cheating through a peephole, which adds a nice little spice. Also, she's cheating on you with animals... spicy indeed. Very few games scratch those 2 itches at the same time.

So far, so good. Like the ideas and the art. Hoping for a longer version and some sort of story behind it? Anyway, it's good and I can see myself in the future enjoying this game.
Also, there's some issue where I need to restart or wait the game to let me pass through some route/stuff... and the dialog keep repeating itself when I pass through a certain "line". Overall, I like it.

pretty well done ntr troupe. Its only version 0.34. Hopefully full game has more options to fuck around with. Other than that, game is still buggy at times, cant go back to menu, escape fully quits the game etc.

One of the two kinds of ntr I have no issues with and it's done pretty well.

Arguably there's not much of a "game" to speak of (so far?) - this is pretty much just an unapologetic beast/monster ntr gallery with a little dialogue sprinkled in, which is fine.

This game may have some of the best art I've ever seen in a game on this site, especially if you like beast content. HOWEVER the game is majorly lacking in both quantity and game-quality.

As of v0.34 there are only 3 monsters the girl can have sex with, each having between 3-6 cgs. The gameplay itself is fine and scratches the "oblivious NTR" itch i.e. you go and train -> come back home -> look through window to see scene OR walking up a mountain while seeing girl have sex on phone screen. However all of it feels clunky and can bug out easily. Moreover the game does not save (which also isnt that necessary since you can complete everything in 15min) and pressing escape INSTANTLY quits the game. Some art in the world is missing/demo.
Overall if this would be more complete it would be amazing, simply due to the art quality. Looking forward to more updates.

Played it, artwork is excellent and incredibly hot. Story is fairly bizarre but hits upon the cuckolding kink, voyeurism and of course beasts and pokemon.

I should say the game is simply not complete yet. But it shows excellent potential.

I'll revise this review on later playthroughs and leave an average score based on potential only for now. Good luck with the project.

[v0.32] I tried after seeing the rating but was shocked in what kind of broken state the game is. This thing is barely playable. Can it in the future get better yes but until then lets not lie to other people and to ourselves. Try if you are into ntr but this is not really a "game" so dont expect much.

For future: The dev has the porn part of the game under control but coding lacks. If they gain experience in that part too i can imagine this game becoming really good.

I'd give it 5 stars if it actually was coded properly and had more content.

But as it stands, the content is good, the story is a bit generic, although I love that it has multiple partners for marnie. Especially the Farm is already a big 5/5. If that gets more content, I'll be happy to give it more. That is, if the content is actually reachable and doesn't remain this bugged

I really don't get why this game has such good reviews, even if you enjoy the beast content or horse content , well there isn't much horse so if your here for that you get 3 scenes none of which are animated and only two scenes are animated but the animations are just moving stills so don't really understand the animation tag, nor once again the great reviews this is at best a solid 2 and that's being nice about it .