Milf Aunt vs Childless Aunt

[WincestDevil]

I am writing an incest VN on my spare time. I have an aunt character who is pretty young compared to the Mom character (27 vs 38). For the lovers of incest, would it be hotter to have her be a mother of one or two young children or be childless? For reference, she isn't the sexually aggressive aunt archetype that you typically see in games but more of an innocent, almost older sister relationship with the main character, having grown up alongside him and seeing her older sister, MC's mom, as more of a parental figure than their own parents.

Being that the story I'm working on is probably a little more grounded than other games on this site (no instantly falling in love with huge cock trope, etc. etc.), here are the pros and cons I can think of for the Aunt having children right off the bat:

Pros:

• Adds additional backstory to the Aunt allowing for SFW character development
• Possibility for some very naughty scenes fucking away from or in the presence of the kids
• Turns the aunt into a milf

Cons:

• Makes the aunt "used" goods
• Turns the aunt into a milf
• Presence of children in an adult VN is kinda iffy, also presence of children also means less time 1 on 1 with MC
• Adding children makes her storyline a little too complicated

Currently, I'm not married to the idea of her being one or the other but I do think it's kinda hot to make her a young milf, though whether or not I have the time and space in my story to explore her problems, if she is a milf, when her purpose in the story is to assist the main character in his, being somewhat of a second mother to him.

Actually, writing this out, I kinda know what the answer to this should be, however, I'll post this up anyways and see what you guys think.

 

[Hagatagar]

Having (young) children in a porn game is a tricky issue.
There will be players who are put off by them even being in the game, others will expect them to be lewdable (the loli-crowd (which makes it a no-go on F95zone and other places) and you can expect requests for that).

And even if they are not lewdable, it can lead to other problems. Patreon, for example, does't like it if children are in such games and situations (as in fucking in front of them).

 

[Lerd0]

...went with childless....so the mc can fill her with babies.....
...u should go with the one that makes ur writing dick hardest.....

 

[Doorknob22]

They are both hot, or can be depicted as such. As Hagatagar wrote: young children could be risky. If you do include them, I suggest that you make sure they are never present in a scene (they are in another town, with their father etc.). This way the aunt could be missing them, making her a little emotionally vulnerable and... well, you can probably take it from here.

 

[Count Morado]

Also, to provide clarity - MILF is a category related to the age of the person making the categorization. Typically, a MILF is near enough to the age of the person's mother - not simply a mother of any age of children.

The person who is calling another a MILF is normally adolescent to 20s in age, therefore a MILF would be a woman between the ages of 35 and 55, approximately (±5 years). A woman of 27 wouldn't necessarily be a MILF, categorically, unless the person objectifying her is prepubescent.

And before someone comes in to say "ACKTUALLY..." I know what you are going to say about words taking on new meanings, etc. You can call the sky red, the sun purple, and the grass black --- but just because you and a minority of people may come to agreement, doesn't mean the definition has altered. The word has only been in the public parlance for less than 3 decades - it's not like it's got some basis in the archaic that time has caused it to be altered to something different.

 

[+monochrome]

From this players pov, childless please, because children in porn games are just, well, eww.
But I definitely agree with Lerd0 pointed out, whatever gets you the hardest is probably the way to go, just follow where it's pointing.

 

[rk-47]

Childless but doesnt necessarily have to lack sexual experience

 

[WincestDevil]

...went with childless....so the mc can fill her with babies.....
...u should go with the one that makes ur writing dick hardest.....

Best compromise . But yes, ultimately I think childless is best. Narratively speaking, the story would be too busy and multi-faceted if I add in kids into the mix, let alone the problems mentioned above.

 

[おい！]

Cons:

• Makes the aunt "used" goods

 

[LionInDarkness]

Don't really have a preference personally when it comes to the aunt's maternal status I just want there to be one. If she childless okay then but if isn't at least make the cousin away if its a guy and if its a girl, of age. I don't have a thing for children in adult games (not even shotas or the mc being one) and honestly making her the mc's big cousin would be a bit different because usually the cousin is either the same age as the mc or younger. Plus that opens the gate for the mc's cousin seeing them or having a thing for the mc as well. Make the aunt a little older or switch the ages and make the aunt the big sister (which also isnt done as much). If she's childless then her being older would make it even more interesting because it could become a thing where the aunt was extremely maternal to the mc growing up because she has yet to have children which turns their connection from love to the mc falling for her.

 

[woody554]

27yo aunt is more of a 'big sister' character than a milf regardless of her family relation. could even be the result of her sister's secret teen pregnancy to give it more dramatic potential. there's really no point in trying to write a 27yo 'milf' because it just won't cut it for the kink.

 

[LionInDarkness]

27yo aunt is more of a 'big sister' character than a milf regardless of her family relation. could even be the result of her sister's secret teen pregnancy to give it more dramatic potential. there's really no point in trying to write a 27yo 'milf' because it just won't cut it for the kink.

well as i said i don't really have a preference lol, I was just spitballing

 

[WincestDevil]

there's really no point in trying to write a 27yo 'milf' because it just won't cut it for the kink.

Im actually not sure about this. I like the "daycare girl" type that's a mid to late twenties woman who's great with kids, which I imagined this Aunt character to be like, if she had kids. But yes, I guess in a more traditional sense of the word in which milf means older woman, despite her being young and having a kid, she probably wouldn't fit the archetype here.