Ren'Py - Completed - Milfy City [v1.0e] [ICSTOR]

This is honestly the best game ever made. Icstor needs more people to make faster updates cuz i just finished 0.5 and need 0.6 asap! Best game ever!!! Oh and i hope there is a prequel to this!
*Mod Edit.. removed sentences that are not a review*

I've tried a lot of games on here, either with unity, RenPy or RPGM.

But this has the nicest story so far, really great renders and even dialogue is okay.

The only "downside" is that the last few updates were kind of fast to play, but took ages to wait for.

The popularity of the game definately has it's reason, just hope they will actually finish it completely and not abandone sometime.

Dev is taking the piss for almost 3 years. Game is dead. I gave it 5 stars at star because at that stage it was so promissing but now it just irks me to see it at top 2 being abandoned game. It should roll down outside of top 100 now. There are so many better games now since he started doing it.

High quality visuals.
Story-wise, could flesh out MC more to understand why everyone is head over heels with him. What are his winning qualities? Also elder sister felt like a third wheel, needs more characterization.
Could use with some UI tweaking for QOL, especially travelling to and fro, time-locked events etc. to let the player know which events have been unlocked.
ICSTOR transitioning to Ren'Py is a welcome change. Keep up the good work.

This game may be the best in this forum. Renders are just amazing and realistic. Plot is good without too long dialogs that makes some games just boring. Every update has a lot for renders and nice amount of content. Good job dev team!

Definitely in my top 5 games to play, lot of different options and great art. This game only seems to get better and better every new update. I only wish there was a faster way to get updates but they can't rush a good game so we can wait.

Love this game! There is a very long build up and Linda, the mother, is very much a tease. The updates for the most part have been great, except at one point you start begging one of the sisters to be lovers, and it's sort of annoying. The graphics are incredible!

it is the best incest game ever made , this is the next lvl of incest games great renders whith realistic look that make the game feel alive best story so far and easy to play since it use renpay .,i was expecting something great but i found a masterpiece .

This game is in my top 3 of best games on this site.

The Good:
- Excellent graphics, animations, and renders
- Beautiful female characters (some of the best I've seen in any game)
- Good story and plot
- Excellent characters who you identify with and grow to love
- Excellent game play
- Freedom to progress with all the characters as you'd like and at your own pace
- Overall a very enjoyable and satisfying experience!
- I highly recommend this game!

The Bad:
- The game isn't finished yet

How come I haven't rated this excellent game before ?! I have been following it, and fapping on it, since it was posted on this website and I've just been having a blast, coming back to it several times. The animations are just great quality, don't get me started on the models, the characters are pretty well-thought too. The dialogues, the events, the scenes... The only downside of Milfy City would be Sara but that is only personal taste, I know many others love her, that's why I won't rate down. Oh yeah by the way, I have nothing against Milfy City. One of the best, like most ICSTOR's games. Personal favorite: Caroline, even if I love them all except little Sara, sorry to say. Excited for more updates. I almost forgot to mention... WE NEED JUDY!

Renders are good, Animations are great, you know the dealio about all that.

The story is your average story for most of the characters except Caroline, who has a (relatively) more mature storyline so far. Compared to Linda who pretty much tries to rape you(and acknowledges this herself at one point).

Sara looks way too young for me.

Honestly, I don't really care about the other characters. I'm just staying here for Caroline. But that's the thing about this game. No content is forced upon you. If you like a girl you may pursue her. If you don't, Then don't bother. Completely optional.

This game is in my top 3 of best games on this site.

The Good:
- Excellent graphics, animations, and renders
- Beautiful female characters (some of the best I've seen in any game)
- Good story and plot
- Excellent characters who you identify with and grow to love
- Excellent game play
- Freedom to progress with all the characters as you'd like and at your own pace
- Overall a very enjoyable and satisfying experience!
- I highly recommend this game!

The Bad:
- The mom and younger sister already have a crush on the player. I would prefer this part of the story to be progressive also (like it is with your older sister). This is the only part of the story that feels unbelievable and detracts from an otherwise great story/experience.
- I had to refer to a walkthrough occasionally in order to progress in the game
- The game isn't finished yet

Mifly City has some of the best animations for a game in this genre that I've seen. Although the story telling is a bit unbelievable that's somewhat expected. Despite that, the animations and art are extremely good quality compared to the competition.

This is quite possibly the best game on this forum(and of the genre itself). I played Dreams of Desire(DoD) before playing this one and although i liked that game a lot,my main complaint was the lack of gameplay and player agency.Very often the MC would simply decide which girl he would visit at night/seduce by himself, regardless of whether or not i wanted to further my relationship with that specific girl. Plus,the story was very scripted,with day and night cycles being tied to story progression instead of player action. By the time i finish it,i thought to myself:

"...This game would benefit from having more gameplay mechanics like exploring the house(and the map),NPCs with their own daily routine,dynamic day and night cycles,etc..."

Then i discovered this game and it is basically DoD with everything i thought it would make DoD an even better game. Not only that but the assets are very well made(specially Caroline and Sara! I don't fell the uncanny valley at all when looking at them) and the animations are great. And if all this wasn't enough, the amount of content this game has is incredible. I'm currently playing the v0.4c and i'm amazed by how many routes you can possibly unlock in this game.

If you have money to spare and is thinking about supporting a project this is definitely a contender. Congrats Icstor and the team for this amazing project.

An excellent game, nice content and animations, updates are quite frequent. However it lacks an original story and, like many others game of the genre, it's still not complete and, for this, could end worse on the long run.

There's only couple of these that are as well written and executed. The continuing storyline keeps evolving pretty nicely, so that gets me back time to time to check out the latests developments in the game.
Keep up the nice work.

Excellent rendering as always, the models are hot and something being used over and over.

However, plot and storyline is just the thing ICSTOR always lacking and it seems didn't improve in this game.

Best game going around. Noone will ever be able to beat the animations. The mom is hot! Thank you keep up the great work and I hope there's heaps more to this one! I recommend this to anyone looking for a fantastic storyline, characters and mini-missions

I hate making it about money but the sheer amount of it that this title rakes in compared to how little movement development makes has made me feel like I have to reconsider my previous rating for this. That's a big pot and it could easily support some outsourcing, especially since the developer's passion for working on this title themselves appears to have pretty much hit rock bottom.

What is here is great, don't get me wrong. Fantastic renders, good characters, attractive female models, and decent writing even though you're playing more through a series of scenarios than a specific central story it seems.
And the fact that there's no solid story running through it might be why the passion has gone.

But that's no excuse.

Just a small portion of what Icstor pulls in each month could sustain a small team that could work on this if he doesn't want to, and he'd even get a sizable paycheck just for having started the thing if he stepped back and outsourced everything while progressing onto other projects. Instead, supporters are left paying each month with little to look forwards to other than a sharp end.
Characters and events have been teased with some placeholders even scattered around and I can foresee these being cut in favour of a speedy exit from this project on the devs part.

This used to be one of the best ero games out there in my opinion, and it's been left to rot.

It now gets 2 stars from me, and it gets to keep those based partly on what I previously wrote about the game (see below). If I were in a better mood today it might have gotten to keep 3, so feel free to imagine this more like 2 and a half or something.
That last line at the bottom of my previous review bit me in the ass.


-- I previously rated 5 stars --------------------------
Here's what I said...
------------------------------------------------------------
Some of the most attractive models I've seen in a game and each character brings their own individual personality with them.
The animation is some of the best I've seen in a Ren'Py game so far, with the buttock fucking after one of Caroline's shoots being a particular favourite of mine.
Each character's narrative has been interesting, even for characters I didn't think I would be as interested in.
The gameplay is simple enough that there's no frustration and even if you hit a dry spot as far as sexual content goes you can always take a bath, call in on someone at night, or video-call a teacher for some repeatable light titillation.
Overall it's a relaxing experience and you just keep hitting it like a piñata until the sex falls out, you can't really go wrong.
I'm excited to see what joys ICSTOR brings us in future updates and I'm not even picky about what that content may be. At this point, I trust the dev team wholeheartedly.

[Rev v0.4c]
Yay. MC + hot mom + 2 hot sisters. How novel.

I really like the art; the character models are well done and the scene composition shows talent.

I really DON'T like the writing. To get the good out first: the fluency is good, and I actually [guiltily] enjoyed the inversion of the horny kid chases all the girls trope. The bad: the writing voice is meta-juvenile. I would get it if the MC's internal monologue was the only thing presented this way, but that's not the case. Several attempts at humor fall really flat, like the pregame sales pitch from the Anonymous suit and the -meta-plugs for Patreon subs in dialog. The narrative flow is all over the place for the 'gradual' corruption and the day-to-day loop in general. The decision to halt some paths where they were makes me wonder if a writer got cold feet/lost their muse, or if the devs are making a halfassed attempt to milk money by being coy.

Not a fan of the minigames. Bansai Ren'py dev console.

Several routes gravitate towards anal sex. Not my thing. Some of this is avoidable and some isn't. Nothing I can't deal with, and thankfully offset by some well-done oral.

Overall: Keeping an eye on this in hopes the gripes get sanded down.