Ren'Py - Milfy Day [v0.8] [Red Lighthouse]

Worth a couple of stars because it's playable and has a decent interface. The visuals didn't do a lot for me but might for others. No real grind.

Otherwise...I'm just surprised I played as much as I did. It seemed like a standard harem thing; go around town, talk to women, get sex. Then somewhere along the line you get magic and fairies out of absolutely nowhere. Far enough in that it's extra jarring and making you wonder why it wasn't a fantasy plot from the start. Except it's not really a fantasy plot, it's mostly about the town politics and this weird fairy thing is starting alongside it.

The main character annoys me. He's about two feet shorter than every woman in town. Maybe some people will like that, but he looks like a child and that only makes his freakishly big cock look even sillier.

I could look past most of it and see a game in there, but the plot issues are massively compounded by the terrible English. It's bad. Really bad. Part of what took me as far as I went was I started noting down the horrible dialogue. Here's some select quotes:
"Of course, our asses have both been on fire. Did that bring you any changes?"
"Ow, you're such a bad mate, letting man go after fucking him?"
"Wow, Cocky is a real master of emotion, and Greg's technology makes the band special."
"You wooden head! It's so obvious, do I have to say, MC, I want you to touch my boobies?"
"And your increasingly great kissing skill, I love it!"
"Have you met any other fucks? With who? Jessica?"
"Listen to that sound, what a slutty sound, you slut"
"But I feel so tight, your anal is so good, hha!" - MC as he's fucking someone
"Fuck me! Fuck your Auntie's anal!"
"Slave, if you wanna my pissing, just call it"
"Maybe I'm just a friendly neighbourhood"

There'd be a lot more but most of them are more incomprehensible than awkward. Which might explain my confusion over the plot.

If none of that's a problem for you then in terms of clicking around and getting through the game, it's quite smooth. You might well enjoy it. I can't handle reading any more of it.

A lot of content, and a great range of girls. Like the mix of sandbox and visual novel.

The replay and gallery being separate is a nice touch. I am a sucker for a demon.

Not sure i have a pregnancy kink, and would like to avoid that..

but over all a great game.

Absolutely amazing game! I am not a fan of Honey Select engine, but here the Dev managed to squeeze every bit of a potential from it. Models look very hot. Animations are good, but you sometimes recognize some Illusion games stock animations being used, although the Dev made a fair share of his own. In later patches of Milfy Day there are even better genital physics, which always sucked in Honey Select/Illusion games. Big props to Dev for trying to go above and beyond with the engine.
UI is very good, the in game tips and walkthrough on how to proceed are very welcome. Glad I didnt have to google or get some external walkthrough for this game.
Story is enjoyable and so are the scenarios you find yourself in.
Spectacular game, one of the best on this site.

Renders are subpar, and so are animations.
"Story" isn't really a thing. Just a teen horndog banging away, always the same phrases without any deeper sense.
Writing is bad as it can be, tons of mistakes in grammar, writing, pronouns, and even phrases are linked to wrong characters.

New rating!
This game is alright. The renders and animations are good, and the gameplay is simple. Making quick money at first is a bit convoluted, but it becomes easier when you unlock the antiques shop. The story is boring, but that is literally the case with 99% of games on here. It's literally all just fan-service. I would suggest only playing the game for the animations.

This is my personal rating

Story : 10/10
Originality :10/10
Render : 10/10
Sound :7/10
Animation :9/10
Voice Acting : -- /10
Amount of Content : 10/10

one of the best games on this site.
Recommend to download and become a patron

v0.6.6
+Absolutely massive amount of content.
+No grind.
+The waifus are mostly MILFs with absolutely massive ass and tits.
+Art is pretty good, and is animated well.
+Wholesome
+Pregnancy

-Story is a bit nonsensical.
-MC is a moron and a shrimp.
-MC combat ability extremely inconsistent. I got him magic, super powers (divine blessing boosting his strengh from sex), and martial arts training... and he still usually gets his ass kicked. Occasionally he will fight semi competently, but still lose. (eg: beat up 2 gangsters before the 3rd one downs him).
-MC is 18 years old, looks 12, has the mental development of 12, and goes to high school.
-Engrish is atrociously bad. Barely legible.

4.5 stars. rounding up to 5.

This is the first game that make me want to save and bookmark.

I really like the design, and the story flow was really tempting. Just play this game and learn how frustate are you. It has correct tag.

Game version I played had a bug, which affected my experience/rating for this game.

The models and UI are nice for a sandbox adventure type. The animations are also pretty decent.

Problem is the game's sandbox nature means bugs can occur as development goes and your progress resets because you have to start over. Alot of games of this nature have to juggle alot of variables and so broken questlines can sometimes occur.

Also, it's kind of grindy.

It is one of the most wonderful game i ever play. it have neerly every category i like. The sex sences is great and its storyline is good to me even i think it not even go halfway of the stoty.
And to me these MILF body in this game is really make me so hard, large boobs and big femoral

The last update I played was 0.4 and I thought it was good although it had elements that were quite cliché and I didn't quite like it, I would give it 3.5 stars. However, I just played the last update and I thought it was wonderful, 5 stars. The evolution of relationships is spectacular, and characters that seemed empty or uninteresting to me, like May, ended up becoming one of my favorites, not to mention Donna, the best character the game has so far, the best scenes, the best design, the best writing and relationship development.
All aspects of the game are interesting and it gives me the feeling that it can still improve much more.

My top 3 characters are:
1.donna
2.Sarah
3.Melissa

Recommendations:
Nothing from NTR, absolutely nothing.
No share path, or completely optional.
If she thinks of any redesigns, a bigger, rounder ass, along with wide hips and large, shapely tits, would suit any character.
Not making the MC so SIMP.
Domineering and smart MC is always the best idea.
And A game alternative like VN could be a great idea

Not sure how this has got good reviews. The models are good, mostly.

The problems are the writing. Obviously English is not the 1st language of the dev but it's really terrible writing. The phrases and words sound so out of place, if someone spoke to you like that in real life you would assume they had severe brain damage.

Another problem with these type of games is that you constantly need to look at the walkthrough to figure out how to get the next scene. It's not a fun way to play a game.

Lastly another issue that plagues a lot of games on here - boring fantasy plot added in which I have no interest in.

If the game was re-written by someone who actually understands English language it would be a huge improvement.

This game is very good. Fat tits aplenty and thicc thighs for days. Strongly recommended. Looking at previous reviews it seems like it was hard to find events in the past but the version I'm playing now doesn't have that issue, the walkthrough is very clear on what's needed and it's easy to get there.

A good game overall, it has a lot a sex scenes witch are animated along with a plethora of female characters to indulge yourself although not to unique nor copypasted, a few errors here and there along with a simple story which does have a flow and doesn't just pops the sex scenes out of nowhere.
if you're into HoneySelect renders this one is worth your time for sure!

Terrible writing, constant exposition hurled at you by identical cardboard characters, and mile wide, inch thin content driven by the sandbox environment.

True to form, a full year after first playing this, none of the grammatical errors I first noticed have been fixed. With these sorts of Patreon-driven sandbox games, no further attention ever seems to be paid to existing content. (Surely they have English-speaking patrons willing to do some editing?)

This has been a wild ride of a game so far lmao, i had no clue what i was getting into, i came for the Milfs, stayed for the story.

Id give it a 5 star rating if the English was better, its a bit rough at times, but its good enough to understand after a while.

Nothing really wrong with this as a porn game, checks most of the boxes for an average incest harem game. The dev does decent work with HS2 here and the models are all nice and curvy even the ones that are suppose to be "skinny". If you aren't into curvy types probably best to skip.
There is a ton of sex which is great and it isn't completely out of the blue, the progression takes a bit of time for most of the main LIs. The animations are decent but the way the scenes progress can be hit or miss as can the dirty talk with a lot of, what i can only guess are translations into English, feeling a bit off as the LIs will call the MC stuff like "my little engine" which while i kinda get the gist, is a bit off putting. Some of the dirty talk is great and there is enough in the scenes for them to be arousing.
the narrative is pretty standard power fantasy of the MC protecting his family from the bad guys and fucking them all along the way. Nothing particularly wrong with that in a porn game imo, but nothing to reel you in if you aren't interested in the porn
The gameplay such as it is is simple and straightforward and there is a built in walkthrough that is clear and easy to use. The dev also does a nice job with the interface, it is fairly easy to use and nice looking. It's a sandbox, though no real grind, but if that is an absolute no then best to skip.
The only other thing worth mentioning is the MC is pretty small, the game doesn't have the shota tag but the MC is right up against that designation imo, so if that's a no best to maybe check it out and see if the MC's model bugs you
Overall a decent but unremarkable incest porn power fantasy that is easy to play and filled with a boatload of competent porn scenes. Recommended for people that like Honey Select, incest and harems

rlly one of the best games so far.. no. 1 is harem hotel of course
I rlly like the animations, and the ladies are beautifull the ingame WT have problems, for example the day countdown till the next scene is bugged (there it says like you have to wait for 2 days but the next morning it still says you have to wait 2 days, its just confusing) the structure of the game is rlly good as well, it reminds me of harem hotel with the lain mod, and srsly can noone correct-read it? i mean my english is not the best cause i'm a handsome german guy, but it really is disturbing., the grammar issues are real bad!

game is good

Renders,sound effects ,lot of sex scenes , no bugs ,Lot of woman with pubic hair ,lara croft , lot of MILFS

bad
Walktrough is so confusing i tried to do the story in order of the character in the walktrough But you had to complete other character event first before you can unlock a spefic event,
No sister in the game but a niece who just feels like a replacement for the sister the game doesn't have
No scenes with emma She is a nerd like the mc Dressed in a sexy school girl outfit with shirt with open buttons But rather dates ben

very good and well made game. i usually don't like open world games , but in this game is well implemented..without to much grind and you know what you have to do thanks to the WT. i would have prefered that MC doesn't look like a 12 years old boy...but seems that this is, sadly, a recurring issue and bad habit for most of this kind of game. anyway i reccomend this to all thos elike harem, milf, incest and supernatural.