hmmmm.. this is interesting
animations 9.5/10 - some of the best i've seen. i like the scenes are long, immersive and very well animated. isn't just a simple loop. i like that sometimes it feels kinda between CG/doll-like and more life like compared to a lot of more robotic animations in other games. definitely doesn't feel robotic at all.
story concept 8/10 - i like the story concept. i like the setting. the bit of magic realism/ the whole kai thing.
sex scene setup 4/10 -maybe this is more of a design choice but i kinda feel like a lot of the story doesn't contribute to the sex scenes. it very much feels like the story is almost like a serious drama and then there are sex scenes interjected inbetween.
designs 6/10 - they're okay i guess. i would personally rate actually lower because i really like especially blondes/blue eyes and really dark black girls and more chesty girls and this game so far has none of that. i would like to see the girls be more on the "babe" look or just super sexy/beautiful. they look a lot more like attractive-ish-to-average but it works. i think it's mostly because the animation is so good. i definitely think with better models/designs, the animation would really shine and the game would have something truly special.
overall, maybe as high as an 8/10 but it's really because the animations are really remarkable. the designs are disappointing. the story feels kinda in the way even tho i like the story concept/broad idea. the dialogue also feels kinda slow or arduous. i even like the faust/nietzsche german setting a lot. i will say as a random note. i think the characters are named well. it's a small detail but sometimes i feel like character names are commpletely off in games or dont add to the immersion of the setting. in this game i feel like the character names mostly fit and add to the immersion/setting.
my main critique is the models and sex content ratio to story. with such good animations, it just seems so worth it to do it with really amazingly hot babes. doesn't have to be significantly better quality models, just design choice change.
also, one thing that might be nice but is kinda an "icing" on the cake thing, if good fluid or "juicy" effects can be added, either to intercourse or ejaculation, i think if it's done well, that always adds a satisfying element to a sex fantasy game but i also know that it can be very tricky or rarely pulled off well. the game definitely doesn't need that if it means making it worse. the model designs i think is more significant and will make a bigger difference above anything else currently.