Pretty notable effort to recreate Persona 1&2 system mechanic, I would rate it 3,5 if possible but some flaw are far noticeable to warrant higher rating.
That said I wouldn't call the game bad, more of imitation that lost the original meaning.
There are a lot of redundant mechanic implementation and missing stakes.
Because the Rpg stat, a lot of mini-event exist in correlation for those stat, this make the event way too many and made important one too sparce.
And there's also the inconsistent story thanks to no-one asking or pursue a question.
With all that said, the game is good enough to pour a lot of hour in.
Pro tip, Get Gremlin as Demon party member, her passive increase drop rate is a god send.
That said I wouldn't call the game bad, more of imitation that lost the original meaning.
There are a lot of redundant mechanic implementation and missing stakes.
Because the Rpg stat, a lot of mini-event exist in correlation for those stat, this make the event way too many and made important one too sparce.
And there's also the inconsistent story thanks to no-one asking or pursue a question.
With all that said, the game is good enough to pour a lot of hour in.
Pro tip, Get Gremlin as Demon party member, her passive increase drop rate is a god send.