The characters' cuteness is the only reason that makes me want to give it a try.
I do not care about futa, the model being the same as the woman one, it would be pretty hypocritical to say that it changes something to just put a stick between their legs. At most, it adds some plays, which is a good thing by my book.
That being said, you can't judge a game just by what you hope it to be, and no matter how cute the characters are, it is still plenty of text with a gameplay and both are failing miserably. That can be summered up to 4 flaws that keep on going on while playing.
The MC.
A good example of what is worse than a scarecrow MC with plot armor at every turn: the wimpy MC boasting about his manliness and making a fuss at every turn.
Almost all the moment the guy acts, it is to make a fuss and drag on what is happening. He is a simple wimp that thinks that he must prove that he isn't one and that really feels. You can't speak to a LI when she is in sport wear because he just runs away, you can't have a normal development when there is a bit of skin showing because he goes frenzy, and you can have actual progress with LI, because he is so full of his problems that he can't actually think about others.
Oh, and he has a multiple personality disorder, so he makes a fuss alone too. I know, it seems just so thrilling.
The snail space.
No, it isn't slow burn, nothing is burning. The writing isn't bad either, but when you put off the game after 30 minutes, you just get that... Nothing happened. The characters didn't get closer, there was no scene either, nor something in the "main story". It was just an everyday event without any purpose which was dragged on by the writing and our dear MC.
I am not against seeing our character's everyday life, but the MC is tiring and it is supposed to be the first affinity event. If you're already missing the point at the first step, you just don't know what your doing.
The gameplay.
It is a sandbox, so the usual: go to the characters to gain points, then when you did 10 times, go there at that time which only happen on weekday/weekend to get your event, while going on with your every day routine meaning going to school and sleeping. Translate all of that by click, click, click, click, click, keep clicking something like 30 times, then get an event, and go back to square one. I can feel your index thrilling.
Of course, the second level ask more points, having a growth of twofold! (20⇒40, or more with some characters) Which mean more fun!
Oh, but there are news mid-events halfway, so don't worry much. I have no idea what a half-way event means and I got my save broken thanks to the add of script but whatever.
Did I mention that you need to grind the different personalities of the MC too by the way?
The direction. Or lack of thereof.
The MC is a wimp, everyone have bigger asset than him, so he will be fucked be everyone.
But wait, he has multiple personalities with a progress menu, so he will fuck them.
But but in an event, one of the LI fuck her sister, so it is just a fuckfest.
But wait again, the sister being fucked wasn't speaking, didn't give her consent and had tearing eyes all along, it is a game about rape, obviously.
But you forget that in an event, the script had a note to add a corruption variable to make NTR, it is an NTR game!
So, what the hell it is?
Well, seeing the future tags, the add of script halfway to have halfway events, the slowpoke pacing, the lack of actual content by events, the grind of personalities, I would say that... The dev doesn't know. He seems to be going with the flow which means that we'll have a game with a bit of everything in some years since you know, it's slow and the development is actually adding an event all every few months, same event having almost no progress, it takes time.
I need to stop a bit and be honest on one point though, at first, the events had actual progression. If you look at the tomboy events, you can see that the second event was actually a progress. But then was added the half-assed events and this aspect disappeared.
On a timescale, the tomboy was the first to have her events, then the others sisters got added with nothing of substance, proving that it is actually becoming slower and lacking a proper aim.
So what would all of it make My Futa Family? A bait, obviously. Which seems to work rather well.