My Real Desire completely fails every goal of making a porn game and an AVN. The MC is basically an emotionless robot. Imagine Data from Star Trek TNG, with even less emotion. The MC doesn't care what any of the LIs are doing, whether they live or die, whether they see him or don't. Each LI, goes out of their way, inexplicably, to please the MC at every turn, and his response is basically "OK. Goodbye". There is some plot point about how his lonely childhood made him like that, but he never improves one iota, after years of game development.
Second, none of the LIs have any memorable personality to distinguish them from each other, except paper thin tropes seen in every bad slice of life porn game or bad anime. All the tropes are here, Jock Girl, Shy Girl, Motherly Type, Slut. But that is it about their characters. You already know from the first sentence of talking with them, everything you will ever know.
Is there a story? Something about the MCs orphan-like upbringing, and his long lost family trying to find him, a few characters from his past showing up, and industrial espionage, but it is all so half-done and bland, as a player it's impossible to care.
The sex scenes are all totally unexciting. There is so little passion between the MC and any of the LIs, as a player you are surpried to see any sex scenes at all. Maybe the LI's feel sorry for the MC, but the scenes are ice-cold as far as any passion or flirty fun interaction goes.
And the dialog. Oh my god the dialog. This is the second worst game I have every played, out of many hundreds here, for terrible empty dialog. Every scene is some variation of, "Hello", "How are you", "I am fine", "Did you have a good night", "Yes, I did", "Do you want to go to lunch.", "I haven't eaten yet. Ok". Bla, bla, bla. If you've read this paragraph, basically that is the entire game.
Finally, none of the choices make any difference at all in anything that happens, as a player there is no agency. It is just a boring MC, boring cookie cutter LIs, boring story, and just more of it.
The only slight positive, is that there is an overall mystery about the MCs past, with slow and steady reveals about his upbringing and the people involved, that there is a spark of interest as a player, just to find out what happened.
There is a hint of a decent AVN buried here that could be interesting and entertaining to play, if the dialog was not so god-awful terrible, boring, and repetitive, if the MC grew in some way as a character and cared about any of the LIs, and if each of the LIs had some distinguishing characteristics to make them in any way memorable or interesting.
Lastly, the quality has taken a nose-dive in chapter 3. The dialog is getting even more bland, the story, such that it is, seems to have been forgotten, and every day is just a bland go out with some LI and have a boring sex scene. You might as well play the actual Honey Select, than this game. It was never actually good, but it seems to have moved into actively bad territory. Maybe the main dev quit and left it up to someone else to write, and they don't have any idea where to take the story, so they just repeat pointless uninteresting scenes day after day.
I think this game was slightly below average from the first few chapters, but with Chapter 3 it seems all the issues with bland dialog and repetitive interactions with the LIs have gotten worse, and the story, such as it is, has been forgotten.
I give it 2 stars just because there are no obvious bugs making it unplayable, the images are pretty much standard-fare for Honey Select games. Not great, but not terrible. And there is some hint of an interesting story buried here.
Update:
The story has picked up a bit since the prior update, so that is an improvement. However, the story is still predictable and not very interesting. The latest update finally shows the MC starting to care about the other characters, just a tiny, tiny, bit, with the "story" coming to its apparent conclusion, at least regarding the main arc with the MC. Hard to believe it's possible, but the dialog is even more monotonous, predictable, and boring. I would think the dev is using AI, but I think AI would actually be more interesting and less predictable than what is here.
Summary:
Graphics: Passable, but no different than any HS game without mods.
Story: There is one, but it's predictable and not very interesting. I will admit that it is at least fairly original, for AVNs that is, and I get the sense that there are a few surprises in store. Worth an extra half star, so 2.5.
Characters: Terrible. All cliches no distinct personality whatsoever.
Dialog: The worst. 0/100.
Sex Scenes: Lifeless. No passion. If anything, they've gotten worse. The LIs are like a dead fish, so is the MC. So cold and dry, why bother. Imagine robots having sex based on what they saw in a movie. That is what we have here.
I have to say it is just on the edge of playability. Not bad enough for me to give up seeing where the story goes, just because of how much time it took to get here, but every line of dialog has my finger itching to press the skip button, which I never like to do with AVNs. The sex scenes, such as they are, now get the full skip treatment.