Review for v0.2
This is kind of a strange start. I feel like potential is here, and I want to like this. But after playing these first two versions it's hard to tell you what this game is about?
First, there's just no real intro. I'm not sure if the game expected me to read the overview (I didn't until after I played) but it doesn't really set up any sort of context or background info before just kind of dropping you in. Sometimes that works for a game, but not here. I felt like I've loaded into someone's early game save rather than starting at the beginning as an analogy. It's weird.
Apparently we were forced to flee our home due to an encroaching war. It was difficult. We went though a lot. Alright cool. Why not show any of that?
I'm pretty sure it's because this game is trying VERY hard to be cryptic and create intrigue, to the point where it's actually a fault in some ways. It's great when games don't tell you everything at once, but here it tells you almost nothing before just throwing you in with all these new characters. I feel like I'm being bashed in the head with how many flashbacks/memories (?) the MC has already had as well. It just means very little to me so early on when I'm not invested enough to start theory crafting.
The dev has clearly spent time world building. I can tell they have things more thought out than other VNs when it comes to the plot and such, and that's nice don't get me wrong. But I think the delivery of it all so far is what's off for me. When the game does start to give you info about the world, it's also throwing info about the strange magic system at the same time. I would have liked to learn about it all more naturally than sitting in a room with a character we barely know dumping it on me.
It's missing fluff really. Every part of this so far feels like it wants to push you forward or give you something new to think about. It's too much too quickly. Slowing things down and expanding characters more before throwing us into the thick of everything would make me enjoy this a lot more. Only one girl has actually stuck with me out of all of them shown (the blind one).
So clearly I have some issues with this, but again I think potential is here. It's not as if I hated what I just played either. I like the character designs, the renders are rather atmospheric, it has sound(!), and again there's clearly some thought being put into the game. It's early, so I'm hoping time does this favors. A cautious 4 stars right now.