The first "season" was great and i would have happily given it 5 stars, but sadly goes down hill with each subsequent "season"
Chasing the "family" characters was great at first but it drags on way too long and the constant rejections get tedious, fighting hard over and over again for a tiny amount of intimacy with someone who says they love you back but none of them show any real interest in the MC when he is not constantly badgering them which gets very boring and by the time of the cabin tip i had totally lost interest in any of them, I also did a full love route on them and a full rejection and the text(outside of sex scenes) is 99% the same, which shows they really don't ever like the MC back no matter what(for example you would expect Charlotte to lean towards divorce in the love route but no its exactly the same).
The banter between the characters comes off very natural with a pretty even mix of insults and praise at the start but later almost every-time the MC tries it it goes way too far and someone gets hurt making even simple conversations painful to watch.
The characters are well written with each feeling unique and realistic, but the body type is pretty much the same across the board, to the point that the older women especially the "mom" and "aunt" look too perfect for there supposed age.
The transitions between pictures can get nauseating when the conversation switches back and forward a lot(dosen't come up often) and seriously not every picture need to be moving.
For once i really liked the MC at the start but he gets dumber and dumber the longer the game goes on, like buying an expensive vehicle just before he is going to quit his job, thinking with his dick during serious events, not coming clean about the accident to protect people, doing blackmail-able things in the enemies lair, then there is the main plot stupidness
It was clear from Sheila's story about how her sister went missing that she did so of her own free will
The art is really good and the sex scenes are too, although they are quite bland.
Story 2/5 (not strong)
Sex 2/5 (visually good but plane)
Characters 2/5 (get worse and worse as time goes on)
Art 4/5 (great)
Choices 2/5 (choose girl and see sex scene)
Kinks 1/5 (couple of light ones)